You’re standing in the grocery aisle, looking at a jar of maraschino cherries. They’re bright. Almost neon. That’s Red Dye 3 at work. It’s also known as Erythrosine. While most people worry about Red 40, Red 3 is actually the one that’s been causing a massive stir in the legislative world lately. California basically banned it, and other states are looking to do the same. It’s weird, honestly, because the FDA actually banned this stuff from cosmetics back in 1990. Yeah, 1990. They said it caused thyroid cancer in rats. Yet, for some reason, it’s still totally fine to put in your kid’s fruit snacks? It doesn't make a lot of sense when you really think about it.
Understanding the list of foods with red dye 3 isn't just about avoiding a specific color. It’s about navigating a weird loophole in food safety law that has existed for over thirty years.
Why Red Dye 3 is Suddenly Making Headlines
For decades, this synthetic dye lived in the shadow of its more popular cousin, Red 40. But things changed when the California Food Safety Act was signed. This law, which hits the shelves in 2027, targets Red Dye 3 specifically. Consumer advocacy groups like the Center for Science in the Public Interest (CSPI) have been screaming about this since the Reagan administration. They point to studies showing that high doses of the dye lead to thyroid tumors in laboratory animals. The FDA agreed with the risk for topical applications—lipsticks and blushes—but never followed through on the food side. It’s a regulatory quirk that feels more like a mistake than a policy.
The Surprising List of Foods With Red Dye 3
You might think you can spot it just by looking for anything "cherry flavored," but it’s sneakier than that. Manufacturers use it because it’s incredibly stable. It doesn’t fade under high heat or bright light.
The Maraschino Cherry Culprit
This is the classic example. Most brands of maraschino cherries rely on Red 3 to get that iconic, almost radioactive glow. If you’re making a Shirley Temple or topping a sundae, you’re likely consuming it. Some organic brands use beet juice or black currant for color, but the mainstream stuff? It’s almost always synthetic.
Seasonal Candies and Holiday Treats
Ever notice how Valentine’s Day hearts or Easter jelly beans have a specific "vibe"? Red Dye 3 is often the secret ingredient in those seasonal drops. It’s especially common in those small, hard conversation hearts. Because it’s a "certified color," it provides a precision that natural dyes just can’t match. Kids eat a ton of this stuff during the holidays. That’s where the exposure really spikes.
🔗 Read more: That Time a Doctor With Measles Treating Kids Sparked a Massive Health Crisis
Fruit Cocktails and Canned Peaches
This one catches people off guard. You’d think canned fruit is just fruit and syrup. Nope. Check the label on a can of fruit cocktail. Those little cherry halves? They are often dyed separately with Red 3 so they don't bleed color onto the pears and peaches. It keeps the can looking "clean." If they used Red 40 or fruit juice, the whole can would turn a muddy pink within a few weeks on the shelf.
Packaged Baked Goods and Frostings
Betty Crocker and Duncan Hines have used it in various frostings over the years, specifically the strawberry or "cherry chip" varieties. It’s also found in those pre-packaged snack cakes that have a long shelf life. Hostess products have occasionally been flagged for it. It’s basically everywhere in the "middle aisles" of the grocery store where things are designed to stay "fresh" for months.
Some Surprising Savory Items
Believe it or not, some brands of sausage or flavored rice mixes have used Red 3 to "enhance" the meaty appearance. It’s less common now than it was ten years ago, but it still pops up in generic or budget brands. Always flip the package over.
The Health Concerns Nobody Can Agree On
The debate isn't just about cancer. It’s about behavior. Many parents swear that synthetic dyes turn their kids into tiny whirlwinds. The Environmental Working Group (EWG) has highlighted research suggesting a link between synthetic food dyes and ADHD-like symptoms in children.
The FDA’s current stance is that most people don’t eat enough of it to matter. But "most people" is a vague term. If a child eats dyed cereal for breakfast, a fruit cup for lunch, and a snack cake after school, that cumulative load is significant. There's also the "Delaney Clause." This is a 1958 amendment to the Food, Drugs, and Cosmetic Act. It says the FDA cannot approve any food additive shown to cause cancer in humans or animals. Since the FDA admitted Red 3 caused cancer in rats, many legal experts argue its continued use in food is technically illegal. It’s a massive legal gray area that’s finally being challenged in court.
💡 You might also like: Dr. Sharon Vila Wright: What You Should Know About the Houston OB-GYN
How to Spot It on the Label
Marketing departments are smart. They don't always put "RED DYE 3" in big bold letters. You have to look at the fine print at the very bottom of the ingredient deck. It might be listed as:
- FD&C Red No. 3
- Erythrosine
- Red 3 Lake (this is a version used in fatty foods or coatings)
If you see "Beet Juice," "Annatto," "Turmeric," or "Purple Carrot Juice," you’re in the clear. Those are the natural alternatives. They’re more expensive for the company, which is why the cheap stuff stays red with chemicals.
The Shift Toward Natural Alternatives
Companies are panicked. With California’s ban looming, national brands have two choices: make a special "California-only" version of their product or change the recipe for everyone. Most will change the recipe. It’s too expensive to run two different supply chains.
We’re already seeing huge shifts. Major retailers like Whole Foods have banned Red 3 for years. Now, even mainstream giants like Kraft and Mars are looking for ways to swap out synthetics. They use things like paprika or hibiscus. It’s harder to get the color "right," but it’s becoming the industry standard.
Practical Steps for a Cleaner Pantry
You don't need to throw everything away today. That's wasteful and honestly a bit dramatic. But you can be smarter about your next grocery run.
📖 Related: Why Meditation for Emotional Numbness is Harder (and Better) Than You Think
Start with the cherries. Switch to brands like Tillen Farms or look for "organic" labels. They use vegetable juices for that red tint. Next, look at your sprinkles and cake decorating kits. Those are Red 3 hotspots. There are plenty of "dye-free" sprinkle brands online now that look just as good on a cupcake.
If you have kids, pay attention to their "red" foods. Strawberry milk, red yogurt, and fruit snacks are the big ones. Switching to a brand that uses fruit-based coloring is an easy win. You aren't losing flavor; you're just losing a chemical that the government already decided was too risky for your lipstick.
Check your medicine cabinet too. Some liquid cough syrups and chewable vitamins use Red 3 to make them look "cherry flavored." It’s ironic that a health product would contain a controversial dye, but it happens all the time. Look for "dye-free" versions of infant Tylenol or Motrin.
The bottom line is that the list of foods with red dye 3 is shrinking, but it’s still long enough to be a nuisance. Being a conscious consumer isn't about being perfect. It’s about making a slightly better choice than you did last week. Check your labels, favor brands that prioritize natural ingredients, and keep an eye on the legislation in your state. The era of synthetic dyes is slowly coming to an end, and your health will probably be better for it.