You’re digging through a jar of old change, or maybe you just got a handful of coins back from the self-checkout, and there it is. A 1944 Lincoln Wheat cent. It looks different than the shiny zinc pennies we have today. It’s got that deep, chocolatey brown patina, or maybe it’s still surprisingly orange. Your first thought is probably the one everyone has: "Wait, isn't there a 1944 penny worth like a hundred thousand dollars?"
The short answer? Yes. But also, mostly no.
Understanding how much is a 1944 penny really worth requires you to look past the date and actually examine the metal. Most of the 1.4 billion pennies struck that year are worth about the price of a gumball—if you can even find a gumball for two cents anymore. But a tiny, microscopic fraction of them are legendary "wrong planchet" errors that collectors will sell their cars to own.
The Shell Casing Secret
To understand the value, you have to understand World War II. In 1943, the U.S. Mint famously switched to zinc-plated steel because copper was needed for the war effort. People hated them. They looked like dimes, they rusted, and they didn't work in vending machines. So, in 1944, the Mint went back to copper.
Sorta.
They didn't just use standard copper. They actually recycled spent brass shell casings from military firing ranges. This gives the 1944 penny a slightly different "recipe" than pennies from the 1930s. If you look at a high-grade 1944 cent, it sometimes has a slightly different luster because of that "shell casing bronze."
The Standard Value: What's in Your Pocket?
If you have a normal, circulated 1944 penny—the kind that's brown, a bit worn, and maybe has a few scratches—it's worth roughly 2 cents to 5 cents.
Honestly, the copper content alone is worth more than the face value. Since these are 95% copper, the melt value stays around 2.5 cents depending on the market. However, it's actually illegal to melt them down for the metal, so don't get any ideas about starting a foundry in your garage.
If the coin looks like it just rolled off the press—we call this "Uncirculated" or "Mint State"—the price jumps. A typical MS-63 grade 1944 penny might fetch $1 to $3. If it’s a beautiful "Red" version (meaning it hasn't oxidized to brown yet) and graded MS-67 by a service like PCGS or NGC, you’re looking at $200 to $400.
🔗 Read more: Monroe Central High School Ohio: What Local Families Actually Need to Know
The Steel 1944 Penny: The Holy Grail
Here is where things get wild.
In 1943, the pennies were steel. In 1944, they were copper. But in the chaos of the transition, a few steel blanks (planchets) from 1943 got stuck in the bins. They were fed into the machines in 1944 and struck with the new date.
This is the "Error" everyone dreams of finding.
How much is a 1944 penny made of steel worth? A lot. A genuine 1944 Steel Lincoln cent can sell for anywhere from $75,000 to over $150,000 depending on the condition and which mint it came from (Philadelphia, Denver, or San Francisco).
But wait. There are tons of fakes. People in the 40s and 50s would take a regular copper 1944 penny and plate it in zinc or chrome to make it look like steel. It's a common trick.
The Magnet Test
The easiest way to tell if you’re sitting on a gold mine or a piece of junk is a simple magnet.
- If the coin sticks to the magnet, it’s steel.
- If it doesn't stick, it's copper.
If your 1944 penny sticks to a magnet, stop everything. Don't clean it. Don't rub it. Put it in a soft plastic flip. However, be warned: even if it sticks, it could be a "reprocessed" steel cent from 1943 where someone messed with the date. Expert authentication is non-negotiable here.
Mint Marks Matter (A Little)
You’ll see a small letter under the date. If there’s no letter, it was made in Philadelphia. An 'S' means San Francisco, and a 'D' means Denver.
💡 You might also like: What Does a Stoner Mean? Why the Answer Is Changing in 2026
- 1944-D: Very common. Over 430 million made. Values are basically the same as Philly.
- 1944-S: Slightly lower mintage, but still in the hundreds of millions. Collectors might pay a tiny premium for a bright red one, but for a "jar find," it's still a few cents.
The "D over S" Variety
Coin nerds (and I say that with love) look for the 1944-D/S. This is an "OMM" or Over-Mintmark error. It happened when a Denver mint mark was punched over a San Francisco mint mark on the die.
You need a jeweler’s loupe or a microscope to see this. If you find one, even in "average" condition, it’s a $100 to $300 coin. In high grades? It can top $1,000. It’s the kind of detail that makes coin hunting actually profitable if you have the patience of a saint.
Why Condition Is Everything
I’ve talked to people who are convinced their 1944 penny is worth a fortune because it's "old."
Age doesn't equal value in numismatics. Demand and scarcity do. Because the U.S. minted billions of these to keep the economy moving during the war, they are not scarce.
To get the "big" money for a common copper 1944 penny, it has to be perfect. Professional graders like PCGS use a 70-point scale. A 1944 penny graded MS-68 Red is incredibly rare because copper spots easily and gets scratched. One of these sold at auction for over $10,000. But let's be real: the odds of finding an MS-68 in a coffee can are basically zero.
Spotting a "Woody"
Sometimes you'll find a 1944 penny that has weird, dark streaks through it, almost like wood grain. These are called "Woodies." They happen because the metal alloy wasn't mixed perfectly at the Mint—remember, they were using recycled shell casings.
While not "official" errors, there’s a niche group of collectors who love these. You might get $5 or $10 for a cool-looking Woody from the right buyer on eBay.
Actionable Steps for Your 1944 Penny
If you've got a pile of these coins, don't just dump them in a Coinstar machine. Follow this checklist to make sure you aren't literally throwing away thousands of dollars.
📖 Related: Am I Gay Buzzfeed Quizzes and the Quest for Identity Online
1. The Magnet Test
Grab a strong refrigerator magnet. If the 1944 penny jumps to it, you might have a steel error. This is the "lottery ticket" moment. If it doesn't stick, it's copper.
2. Check for the "D over S"
Get a 10x magnifying glass. Look at the mint mark under the date. Does it look "thick" or like there's a ghost of another letter underneath? If so, you need to compare it to known photos of the 1944-D/S OMM on sites like VarietyVista.
3. Evaluate the Color
Coin collectors categorize copper into three buckets:
- Red (RD): Original mint luster, looks like a new penny.
- Red-Brown (RB): Some darkening, but still some orange light.
- Brown (BN): The typical old penny look.
If your coin is "Red," handle it only by the edges. The oils in your skin will ruin it instantly.
4. Check for Laminations
Look for "peeling" skin on the coin. Because of the shell casing bronze, 1944 pennies often have lamination errors where the metal surface starts to flake off. These aren't worth a fortune—maybe $5 to $20—but they are much more valuable than a plain cent.
5. Authentication is Key
If you truly believe you have a 1944 steel penny or a high-grade "D over S," do NOT go to a "We Buy Gold" shop. They will lowball you. Instead, look for a local coin shop that is a member of the American Numismatic Association (ANA). Ask them if it’s worth sending to PCGS or NGC for grading. It costs about $50-$100 to get a coin professionally graded, so only do this if the potential value is much higher than that cost.
6. Store it Right
If you have a nice one, put it in a PVC-free plastic holder or a cardboard "2x2" flip. Do not use tape. Do not use paper envelopes with high acid content. And whatever you do, never clean the coin. Even a light rub with a cloth can leave microscopic scratches that a professional grader will see instantly, cutting the value by 90% or more.
Basically, your 1944 penny is likely worth about three cents. But that tiny "what if" is why people keep looking. Whether it's a steel error or just a cool piece of World War II history made from old ammunition, it's a hell of a lot more interesting than the pennies being made today.