You see them everywhere if you hang out in anime circles. Girls with horse ears and fluffy tails, wearing idol outfits, sprinting down a turf track at 70 kilometers per hour. It sounds absurd. It looks even weirder if you're coming from a traditional sports background. But the question everyone keeps asking is simple: Is Uma Musume Pretty Derby good, or is it just another flashy mobile game designed to drain your wallet?
Honestly? It's kind of brilliant.
I’ve spent hundreds of hours in the Trenches of the Training Mode. I’ve felt the crushing weight of a last-place finish in the Arima Kinen and the pure, unadulterated dopamine hit of seeing a horse girl I raised from scratch finally cross the finish line first. This isn't just a "waifu" game. It’s a deep, punishing, and strangely moving sports simulator that treats Japanese horse racing history with more reverence than some actual sports documentaries.
The Weird Hook That Actually Works
At its core, Uma Musume is a "raising sim." You play as a trainer. Your job is to take a specific girl—who is the reincarnated soul of a real-life legendary Japanese racehorse—and guide her through a three-year career. You manage her stamina, her speed, her power, and her mental health. If she gets too stressed, she fails. If she eats too much, she gets "overweight" and loses stats. It's a balancing act that feels like a mix of Princess Maker and Football Manager.
The game succeeds because it understands the "Spirit of the Turf."
Every character isn't just a random design. Take Gold Ship, for example. In real life, Gold Ship was a legendary eccentric known for being incredibly difficult to handle and occasionally jumping at the start of a race just to mess with everyone. In the game? She’s a chaotic prankster who might just drop-kick you. The developers at Cygames did their homework. They took the personalities, the rivalries, and the tragic injuries of real horses and baked them into the narrative DNA of the game.
✨ Don't miss: Why the Burger King Pokémon Poké Ball Recall Changed Everything
Is Uma Musume Pretty Derby Good for Casual Players?
If you're looking for an "idle" game where you just press a button and win, you’re going to have a bad time. This game is hard. Really hard.
You will spend 30 minutes carefully crafting a training run, picking the right support cards, and managing every tiny detail, only to have your horse get blocked in the final 200 meters of the race because her "intelligence" stat was too low to find an opening. It’s frustrating. It makes you want to throw your phone. But that’s exactly why people stay. The stakes feel real.
The Strategy Layer
The depth is honestly intimidating at first. You aren't just clicking "Train Speed." You have to account for:
- Track Surface: Is it turf or dirt?
- Distance: Is it a short sprint or a grueling long-distance marathon?
- Strategy: Is she a "Runner" who stays at the front, or a "Chaser" who explodes from the back in the final stretch?
- Inheritance: This is the big one. You "breed" (via spiritual inheritance) new girls using the stats and traits of previous ones. It’s a generational project.
For a casual player, the barrier to entry is the language—most players are still navigating the Japanese version or the recently released English/Global versions—and the sheer volume of menus. But once you realize that the game is basically a giant math equation disguised as an anime, it becomes addictive. It's a "one more run" kind of experience.
The Production Value is Unmatched
Let’s talk about the races themselves.
🔗 Read more: Why the 4th of July baseball Google Doodle 2019 is still the best game they’ve ever made
The 3D modeling in Uma Musume is arguably the best in the mobile industry. When you watch a race, the camera angles mimic actual TV broadcasts. You see the sweat, the determination in their eyes, and the dirt kicking up from the track. And the music? When the "Winning Live" starts—where the winners of the race literally perform an idol concert—it’s a spectacle.
It sounds cheesy. It is cheesy. But by the time your underdog horse wins her first Grade 1 race, you’ll be unironically cheering for her on stage.
The Gacha Problem: The Elephant in the Room
We have to be honest here. Is Uma Musume Pretty Derby good when it comes to your bank account? That’s where things get murky.
The gacha system in this game is brutal. You have two separate banners: one for the characters and one for the Support Cards. To truly compete in the high-level PvP (the "Champions Meeting"), you don't just need the girls; you need specific Support Cards, and you usually need multiple copies of them to "Limit Break" their potential.
If you're a Free-to-Play (F2P) player, you can absolutely enjoy the stories and clear the main content. The writing is top-tier, and the emotional beats land hard. However, if you have a competitive itch, be prepared. The power creep is real, and the "meta" shifts whenever a new scenario is released. You have to be smart with your "Jewels." You can't just pull on every banner. You have to save for months for the "anniversary" cards that redefine how the game is played.
💡 You might also like: Why Pictures of Super Mario World Still Feel Like Magic Decades Later
Why It Dominates the Charts
In Japan, Uma Musume isn't just a game; it's a cultural phenomenon. It revived interest in actual horse racing among younger generations. Retired horses began receiving massive influxes of donations for their care because players fell in love with their in-game counterparts.
The game matters because it has heart. It’s not a cynical cash grab using a license. It’s a love letter to a sport. Even if you don't care about horses, the themes of overcoming failure and chasing a dream are universal.
The Verdict on Gameplay Loops
The loop is: Train, Race, Fail, Inherit, Repeat.
Some people find this repetitive. They aren't wrong. You will see the same dialogue events hundreds of times. You will see the same training animations until you start skipping them. But for those who love "min-maxing," the joy is in the marginal gains. Finding a way to get 50 more points of Stamina or proccing a rare gold skill is where the fun lies.
It’s a game of spreadsheets and soul.
What New Players Should Know
- Don't reroll for characters: Reroll for Support Cards. A Tier 0 Support Card will make every horse you own better. A Tier 0 horse with bad cards is useless.
- Learn the "Rock-Paper-Scissors" of stats: Speed is king, but Power is what lets you push through the crowd. Don't ignore Stamina for anything over 2000 meters.
- Watch the anime: Seriously. Season 2 of the Uma Musume anime is genuinely one of the best sports stories in recent years. It gives context to the characters that makes the game much more impactful.
Actionable Steps for Getting Started
If you're ready to dive into the world of horse girls, don't just download and click randomly. You'll hit a wall within two hours.
- Prioritize the "URA Finals" Scenario: When starting, stick to the basic training scenario. It’s the simplest way to learn how stats affect race performance without the complicated mechanics of later scenarios like "Grand Masters" or "Project L'Arc."
- Focus on "A" Rank first: Don't aim for the "S" or "SS" ranks immediately. Focus on building a well-balanced horse that can actually win races. A horse with 1200 Speed and 200 Stamina will lose a long race every single time.
- Join a Community: Whether it's a Discord server or a subreddit, you need a guide. The game has many "hidden" mechanics—like how "Guts" affects the "Last Spurt" or how certain skills only trigger on specific tracks.
- Manage Your Resources: Never spend your premium currency on the standard banner. Wait for the "Selection" banners or the 6-month anniversary events where the rates are better or the cards are game-changing.
Uma Musume Pretty Derby is a strange, beautiful, frustrating, and incredibly rewarding experience. It’s "good" if you value depth, character-driven storytelling, and the slow burn of seeing a long-term project come to fruition. It’s "bad" if you have an addictive personality prone to gacha traps or if you hate repetitive gameplay loops. But as a piece of game design? It’s a masterpiece of its niche.