You've probably seen the TikToks. The cryptic captions about "deserving better" and the aesthetic videos of a new apartment that "he has never been in." If you're wondering is Tyler and Kay still together, the short answer is a pretty firm no. Honestly, it was a wild ride that ended almost as quickly as the cameras stopped rolling.
While Netflix’s Temptation Island Season 9 (which hit streaming in early 2025) painted a picture of a "ride off into the sunset" romance, the real world had other plans. Tyler Breshears and Kay Carlson are officially over. They aren't even really "it's complicated" over—they've both moved on to entirely different lives.
The Temptation Island Breakup No One Saw Coming
On screen, Tyler and Kay looked like the real deal. Tyler basically blew up his relationship with Tayler Byrd for Kay. He told the world he’d finally found someone who "saw his value." They left the island together in a cloud of romance and promise. But here’s the kicker: they didn't even make it past the final overnight date before the cracks started showing.
According to updates shared shortly after the finale, the pair realized their lives didn't actually align. Kay later admitted that the romantic setting of the island played a huge role in their chemistry. Basically, it was a "vacation romance" that couldn't survive a trip to a local grocery store. Kay mentioned she wanted Tyler to actually experience being single instead of jumping from a long-term relationship straight into a new one with her.
🔗 Read more: Shamea Morton and the Real Housewives of Atlanta: What Really Happened to Her Peach
Where Are Tyler and Kay Now?
If you’re looking for a reconciliation, don’t hold your breath. Tyler didn't exactly take Kay’s advice about staying single. He met a woman named Lauren Bennett—a fitness influencer and podcast host—almost immediately after returning home.
They are very much "Instagram official" now. In fact, if you check Tyler's socials, he's frequently featured in Lauren’s workout videos and they seem settled into a serious routine. It's a bit of a "copy and paste" situation according to some fans, as Lauren bears a striking resemblance to his ex, Tayler.
As for Kay Carlson, she’s been living her best life. She confirmed in interviews that while she gave Tyler "another shot" briefly after filming, it just wasn't meant to be. She’s famously posted about moving into an apartment he’s never stepped foot in. She basically summed it up by saying he’s a "good guy," but definitely "not her guy."
💡 You might also like: Who is Really in the Enola Holmes 2 Cast? A Look at the Faces Behind the Mystery
Why It Didn't Work Out
- The Bubble Effect: Like most reality shows, the island isn't reality. Kay noted that without the "romantic setting," they likely would have just been friends.
- Life Goals: Tyler was transitioning from medical device sales to modeling, and the financial and lifestyle stability just wasn't there yet.
- Timing: Tyler was coming off a five-year marriage and a two-year relationship. Kay saw the writing on the wall that he needed to find himself first.
Other Tylers You Might Be Thinking Of
In the world of reality TV, there are a lot of Tylers. If you aren't thinking of the Temptation Island duo, you might be confused with these other high-profile Bachelor Nation stars who are frequently searched alongside this keyword.
Tyler Cameron and Tate Madden
If you're wondering if The Bachelorette legend Tyler Cameron is still with his "Kay," he’s actually with Tate Madden. They are very much together in 2026. In fact, they recently shared updates about renovating their home in Jupiter, Florida, and have even hinted at marriage and kids. Tyler Cameron confirmed they are living together and "making all the strides" toward a permanent future.
Tyler Norris and Alyssa Sheridan
Then there's Tyler Norris from The Bachelorette and Bachelor in Paradise. He isn't with a Kay either. He recently got engaged to Alyssa Sheridan (from The Voice) in May 2025. They are currently planning their life together after a romantic beach proposal in New Jersey.
📖 Related: Priyanka Chopra Latest Movies: Why Her 2026 Slate Is Riskier Than You Think
The Actionable Reality
The takeaway here is that reality TV "final couples" have a notoriously short shelf life once the plane touches down at home. If you were rooting for Tyler and Kay, the best thing to do is follow their solo journeys.
- Follow Kay Carlson on TikTok for her "single girl" era content and fitness updates; she’s leaned heavily into her influencer brand.
- Check out Tyler Breshears' new life with Lauren Bennett if you want to see how he’s doing in the fitness/modeling world.
- Don't believe every "final rose" or "final bonfire" moment. Most of these couples break up within weeks of the cameras turning off.
The "is Tyler and Kay still together" saga is officially closed. They’ve joined the long list of reality stars who found a connection in paradise but couldn't make it work in the real world.
Next Steps for Reality Fans:
If you're still following the fallout from Season 9, you can look for the "Where Are They Now" special on Netflix which deep-dives into the final bonfire confrontations. You might also want to check out Kay's recent podcast appearances where she discusses the "bitch tendencies" comment that became the meme of the season.