Netflix found a goldmine. When Nobody Wants This dropped in late 2024, it didn't just trend; it basically took over the collective consciousness of anyone who still believes in the "opposites attract" rom-com trope. It's rare for a show to feel both incredibly fresh and deeply nostalgic for the 2000s era of romantic comedies, but Kristen Bell and Adam Brody somehow pulled it off. Naturally, the only thing people are asking now is: is there another season of Nobody Wants This?
The short answer is a resounding yes. Netflix didn't wait long to pull the trigger on a renewal.
But there is a catch. Or rather, a change in scenery behind the scenes. While the show is officially returning for a second season, the leadership is shifting, and the stakes for Joanne and Noah are getting significantly higher.
The Official Word on Season 2
Usually, Netflix waits a grueling 28 days to look at the data before they tell us if a show lives or dies. With this one, they moved faster. The chemistry between Bell’s agnostic podcast host and Brody’s "hot rabbi" was too electric to ignore. The series creator, Erin Foster, based much of this on her own life—specifically her experience falling for her now-husband and converting to Judaism. Because the source material is essentially her life, there's plenty of story left to tell.
They’ve confirmed Season 2 is happening.
However, we are seeing a bit of a "showrunner shuffle." Jenni Konner and Bruce Eric Kaplan, the heavy hitters from HBO’s Girls, are joining the team as executive producers and showrunners for the second outing. This is a massive signal that Netflix wants to maintain that specific "prestige comedy" feel while perhaps tightening the narrative structure. Foster is still very much involved, but bringing in the Girls alumni suggests the humor might get a bit sharper, maybe a little more cynical, but hopefully just as heart-wrenching.
Why the Ending Left Everyone Spiraling
Let's talk about that finale. If you’re asking about is there another season of Nobody Wants This, you’re probably still thinking about that bus scene.
Noah’s choice at the end of Season 1 was the ultimate "romance vs. reality" moment. He walked away from the path that would have guaranteed him the Head Rabbi position to stay with Joanne. It was beautiful. It was also, realistically, a professional disaster for him.
📖 Related: Big Brother 27 Morgan: What Really Happened Behind the Scenes
The conflict hasn't been solved; it’s just been postponed. Joanne isn't Jewish. She hasn't converted. Noah’s entire identity and career are built on a foundation that technically excludes her unless she makes a massive life change. Season 2 has to deal with the fallout of that decision. It’s not just about "will they, won't they" anymore—it's about "how do they make this work without someone losing their entire identity?"
Honestly, the show works because it doesn't treat Joanne’s hesitation to convert as a villainous trait. It treats it as a real, complicated identity crisis.
What the Cast is Saying
Kristen Bell has been vocal about wanting to explore the "what now?" phase of a relationship. In several interviews, she’s mentioned that the initial spark is easy, but the "middle part" is where the actual work happens. Adam Brody, who has essentially become the internet’s boyfriend all over again, seems just as game.
Then there’s the supporting cast. We need more of Morgan and Sasha. Their "loser sibling" dynamic provided some of the best comedic relief in the first season. Justine Lupe and Timothy Simons have this weird, platonic-ish chemistry that honestly rivals the main couple for some fans. We’re expecting both of them to return in a big way.
Production Timeline and Release Date Rumors
Netflix is notoriously tight-lipped about exact dates until a month before things drop. But we can do some math. If the renewal happened late in 2024 and scripts are being polished under the new showrunners throughout early 2025, we’re likely looking at a late 2025 or early 2026 release.
Filming in Los Angeles is generally faster than high-fantasy shows that require months of CGI. This is a "walk and talk" show. It’s about diners, podcast studios, and synagogues.
If they start cameras rolling by mid-2025, a Valentine’s Day 2026 release would be the smartest marketing move Netflix could make. That’s pure speculation, but it fits their historical pattern for romantic dramedies.
👉 See also: The Lil Wayne Tracklist for Tha Carter 3: What Most People Get Wrong
Addressing the Skepticism
Is there a risk of a sophomore slump? Always.
Some fans are worried that the "will they, won't they" tension was the only thing holding the show together. Once a couple is actually together, writers sometimes struggle to keep things interesting without resort to cheap cheating plots or forced misunderstandings.
However, the "Rabbi vs. Agnostic" conflict is a structural barrier, not just a romantic one. It’s baked into the premise. As long as Noah is a Rabbi and Joanne is... well, Joanne... the tension is built-in. They don't need to invent drama; they just need to look at the religious and social requirements of Noah's job.
The Impact of Erin Foster’s Real Life
The show resonates because it feels lived-in. Foster’s real-world conversion process was documented on her social media and podcast long before the show existed. In real life, she did convert.
Does this mean Joanne will convert in Season 2?
Not necessarily. The show isn't a documentary. Foster has said in interviews that she wants the show to explore the messy parts of the process that she maybe skipped over or handled differently. This gives the writers room to play. They might take Joanne down a different path where she decides she can't do it, which would be a bold, heartbreaking move for a Netflix series.
Navigating the Religious Nuance
One of the reasons many people keep checking back to see is there another season of Nobody Wants This is because of how it handled Judaism. It wasn't just a backdrop; it was a character.
✨ Don't miss: Songs by Tyler Childers: What Most People Get Wrong
The show received some criticism for how it portrayed Jewish women—specifically the "shiksa" trope and the "overbearing Jewish mother" stereotype. It’ll be interesting to see if Season 2 leans into those tropes or tries to add more layers to characters like Esther and Bina. There’s a lot of room to grow there. Making the "antagonists" of the relationship more three-dimensional would only make the show better.
What to Expect Next
If you’re looking for actionable ways to stay updated or dive deeper while you wait for the new episodes:
- Watch the "shilling" podcasts: Follow Erin and Sara Foster’s podcast, The World’s First Podcast. They often drop nuggets about production and the real-life inspirations behind the scripts.
- Revisit the soundtrack: The music supervisor for Season 1 deserves a raise. The soundtrack is half the vibe.
- Keep an eye on the "Hot Rabbi" trend: Seriously, Adam Brody’s resurgence is a case study in how to age gracefully in Hollywood.
The return of the series is a certainty. The only question is how much heartbreak we have to endure before Joanne and Noah find a middle ground. Netflix has a hit on its hands, and they aren't going to let it go anytime soon.
Prepare for more awkward family dinners, more podcast oversharing, and definitely more complicated theological debates disguised as flirtation.
The best way to prep for the upcoming season is to track the production starts in Los Angeles. Typically, once the cast starts posting table-read photos on Instagram, you're about six to eight months away from a premiere. Keep your eyes on Kristen Bell’s feed—she’s usually the first to signal when the "work" begins.
***