You know that feeling when you walk into a place and it just smells like old money and secrets? That’s the Waverly Inn. It’s tucked away in a West Village townhouse that looks like it hasn’t changed since the 19th century, mostly because it hasn't. People don't just go for the eggs. They go for the vibe. But if you're looking at the Waverly Inn NYC brunch menu, you’re probably wondering if the $30-plus entrees are just a tax for sitting near a mural of famous New Yorkers or if the food actually hits.
Honestly, it’s a bit of both.
The Waverly Inn is owned by Graydon Carter, the former editor of Vanity Fair. This explains why the dining room feels like a private club where everyone is wearing cashmere even in July. Brunch here isn't the rowdy, bottomless-mimosa-fueled chaos you find in Murray Hill. It’s a hushed, ivy-covered affair. You’re here to nurse a bloody mary and pretend you’re writing the next great American novel, or at least to overhear someone else talking about their publishing deal.
What’s Actually on the Waverly Inn NYC Brunch Menu?
The menu is shorter than you’d expect for a place this famous. It sticks to the classics but dresses them up in high-end ingredients. You won’t find experimental fusion here. It’s traditional American comfort food executed with a serious level of polish.
The star of the show—the thing people literally travel across boroughs for—is the Waverly Chicken Pot Pie. It’s not just a dish; it’s an institution. It comes to the table with a crust so golden and flaky it looks like a prop from a movie. Inside, it’s filled with chunks of tender chicken, peas, and carrots in a sauce that is thick but not cloying. It’s heavy. It’s expensive. It’s worth every penny on a rainy Sunday morning.
👉 See also: Desi Bazar Desi Kitchen: Why Your Local Grocer is Actually the Best Place to Eat
The Savory Side of the Morning
If you aren't in the mood for a pot pie at 11:00 AM, the eggs Benedict is the standard pivot. They usually offer a few variations, often featuring smoked salmon or high-quality ham. The hollandaise is remarkably stable—never broken, perfectly acidic.
Then there’s the burger. The Waverly burger is a massive, juicy beast topped with caramelized onions and usually a sharp cheddar or fontina. It’s served with fries that are thin, salty, and dangerously addictive. It’s the kind of meal that demands a nap immediately afterward. Some regulars swear by the steak and eggs, which uses a proper cut of beef, not the chewy scraps you get at cheaper brunch spots.
Sweet Toasts and Garden Vibes
For those with a sweet tooth, the French toast is usually thick-cut brioche soaked until it’s basically custard in the middle. They rotate the toppings based on the season—think macerated berries in the spring or spiced apples when the leaves start to turn in the Village.
The Atmosphere: Why the Menu is Only Half the Story
You can’t talk about the Waverly Inn NYC brunch menu without talking about the garden. If you can snag a table in the back patio area, do it. It’s enclosed, heated in the winter, and draped in greenery. It feels completely removed from the noise of Bank Street.
✨ Don't miss: Deg f to deg c: Why We’re Still Doing Mental Math in 2026
The main dining room is darker, moodier. This is where you find the Edward Sorel mural. It’s a sprawling piece of art depicting the "Bohemians of the Village." You’ll see everyone from Walt Whitman to Joan Didion staring back at you while you eat your avocado toast. It adds a layer of intellectual weight to the meal that justifies the price tag for a lot of folks.
The Drinks: Beyond the Basic Mimosa
The cocktail program is tight. They make a mean Bloody Mary—spicy, garnished with enough greenery to count as a salad, and packing a punch. If you want something lighter, their seasonal spritzes are usually excellent. They also have a massive wine list, though drinking a heavy Cabernet at noon might be a bit much for anyone who isn't a seasoned regular.
The coffee is strong. It’s served in heavy white mugs that feel good in your hand. They don't do fancy latte art here; it’s straightforward and effective.
What Most People Get Wrong About Dining Here
A lot of tourists think they can just stroll into the Waverly Inn on a Saturday morning and get a table. You can't. Reservations are basically mandatory if you want to eat at a human hour. Even then, you might have to wait a few minutes at the tiny, cramped bar.
🔗 Read more: Defining Chic: Why It Is Not Just About the Clothes You Wear
Another misconception? That it’s a "tourist trap." While it certainly attracts visitors, the Waverly still has a core group of neighborhood regulars. These are people who live in the million-dollar brownstones nearby and treat the Inn like their personal canteen. This mix of people makes for great people-watching. You might see a celebrity (it’s a favorite of actors and media moguls) sitting right next to a family celebrating a graduation.
The Price of Admission
Let’s be real: this is one of the more expensive brunches in the city. You aren't getting out of here for less than $60 per person once you add in a drink, tax, and tip. For many, that’s a "special occasion" price. But the Waverly Inn isn't trying to be a budget-friendly greasy spoon. It’s providing an experience. You’re paying for the history, the service, and the fact that the waiter knows exactly how to crumb a table without interrupting your conversation.
Is the Food Actually Good?
Yes. It’s solid. It’s not "molecular gastronomy" good, but it’s "this is exactly what I wanted" good. The ingredients are clearly sourced with care. The eggs have those deep orange yolks that suggest they came from a happy chicken. The bread is fresh. The butter is salty.
Logistics and How to Do It Right
The Waverly Inn is located at 16 Bank Street. It’s a beautiful walk from the 1/2/3 trains at 14th Street or the A/C/E at 8th Avenue.
- Timing: Aim for a 12:30 PM reservation. It gives the kitchen time to get into their groove, and the room is usually buzzing by then.
- Attire: You don't need a suit, but don't show up in gym clothes. "Smart casual" is the law of the land here. Think nice jeans and a sweater or a sundress.
- The Secret: If the pot pie feels too heavy, ask about the seasonal salad. They often have a warm grain or vegetable salad on the brunch menu that is surprisingly hearty but won't leave you in a food coma.
The Final Word on the Waverly Inn NYC Brunch Menu
If you’re looking for a quiet, sophisticated meal in one of the most beautiful neighborhoods in the world, this is it. The menu delivers on the promise of classic American luxury. It’s comfortable, consistent, and just a little bit snobby in a way that feels quintessentially Manhattan.
Don't overthink the order. Get the pot pie if it’s cold out. Get the burger if you’re hungry. Get a second cocktail if the conversation is good.
Actionable Next Steps
- Check the Current Menu: The Waverly Inn doesn't always post their full daily menu online, but their Resy page often has the most up-to-date highlights.
- Book Early: Set a reminder for two weeks out. Prime brunch slots go fast, especially for the garden tables.
- Bring a Book or a Date: This isn't a place for a quick bite. Plan to spend at least 90 minutes soaking in the atmosphere.
- Walk the Village After: You’re steps away from some of the best bookstores and boutiques in the city. Use the post-brunch energy to wander down toward Washington Square Park.