Finding a place to crash in New York City is usually a nightmare of balancing "I want to be near stuff" with "I don't want to go bankrupt." Honestly, the Sheraton Brooklyn New York Hotel has been sitting right in that sweet spot for years, but the neighborhood—and the hotel scene—has changed so much lately that people are starting to wonder if it's still the go-to.
It’s located at 228 Duffield Street. If you know Brooklyn, you know that area used to be a bit... well, let's call it "transitional." Now? It’s basically the heart of the tech and residential boom. You’ve got City Point across the street and the subway lines are so close you can practically hear the 2 train from the lobby (okay, not really, but it’s a two-minute walk).
But here’s the thing. Most people booking this spot are trying to avoid the $500-a-night price tags in Manhattan. Is it worth the commute? Is the "Sheraton" name still a guarantee of quality, or is it starting to feel like a relic of 2010? Let’s get into what’s actually happening on the ground there.
Why the Location Matters More Than the Room
Location is everything. Seriously.
If you stay at the Sheraton Brooklyn New York Hotel, you aren't just staying in "Brooklyn." You're in Downtown Brooklyn. This isn't the hipster-haven of deep Bushwick or the brownstone-quiet of Cobble Hill. It’s loud. It’s busy. It’s vertical.
The biggest selling point is the transit access. You have the A, C, F, R, 2, 3, 4, and 5 trains all within a five-block radius. That is insane connectivity. You can be at the World Trade Center in 10 minutes or Union Square in 20. For a tourist, that’s gold. For a business traveler hitting the Financial District, it’s often faster to stay here than in Midtown.
The City Point Factor
Right across the street is City Point. If you haven’t been, it’s a massive mixed-use complex.
💡 You might also like: Flights to Chicago O'Hare: What Most People Get Wrong
- Katz’s Delicatessen has an outpost in the basement (DeKalb Market Hall).
- There’s a Target for the forgotten toothbrush.
- Alamo Drafthouse is there if you want to catch a movie and a burger.
Having that right next door solves the "where do we eat?" problem instantly. DeKalb Market Hall has over 30 vendors. You can get pierogi, tacos, and craft beer without ever having to check a Yelp review or wander more than 200 feet from the hotel entrance.
The Reality of the Rooms and Amenities
Expectations are a funny thing. If you’re expecting the St. Regis, you’ll be disappointed. This is a workhorse hotel. The rooms at the Sheraton Brooklyn New York Hotel are exactly what you’d expect from a Sheraton: clean, functional, and maybe a little bit "corporate."
The "Sheraton Sleep Experience" beds are actually legit. They’re consistently ranked well for comfort. If you get a room on the higher floors, the views of the Manhattan Bridge or the Statue of Liberty in the distance are surprisingly good. But—and this is a big but—the noise can be an issue. Even high up, New York finds a way in. Sirens are the soundtrack of the city, so bring earplugs if you’re a light sleeper.
The Club Lounge and Rooftop
One of the perks that used to be a massive draw was the Sheraton Club Lounge. It's still there, and if you have Marriott Bonvoy Elite status, it’s a decent place for a quick breakfast. However, don’t expect a five-course gala. It’s Starbucks coffee, some pastries, and fruit.
Then there’s Kimoto Rooftop Garden. It’s technically connected but operates with its own vibe. It’s an Asian-fusion beer garden. On a Friday night, it gets packed. If you're staying at the hotel, it’s a great spot for a drink, but keep in mind that the elevator situation can get a bit slow when the rooftop crowd starts arriving.
Addressing the "Brooklyn vs. Manhattan" Debate
Most people look at the Sheraton Brooklyn New York Hotel because they see a lower price point than the Marriott Marquis or the Sheraton Times Square. But is the "Brooklyn tax" worth it?
📖 Related: Something is wrong with my world map: Why the Earth looks so weird on paper
Let's talk about the vibe. Manhattan hotels often feel like you're in a pressure cooker. The moment you step outside, you're hit with the wall of tourists. Downtown Brooklyn feels more "real." You see people going to work at the courthouse, students from NYU Tandon, and locals shopping. It’s less of a theme park.
The Price Gap
Usually, you’re saving anywhere from $50 to $150 a night by staying here instead of Midtown. Over a four-night stay, that’s $600. That’s a lot of dinners at Peter Luger.
The Commute Reality
If your entire itinerary is based around Central Park and the Upper East Side, the commute might get annoying after day three. But if you're planning on seeing DUMBO, the Brooklyn Heights Promenade, or the Barclays Center? Staying here is a no-brainer. You're a 15-minute walk from the Promenade, which has the best view of the Manhattan skyline in the world. Period.
What Most People Get Wrong About This Hotel
There’s a misconception that staying in Brooklyn is "inconvenient." That’s old-school thinking. In 2026, Brooklyn is the destination.
People also worry about safety. Look, it’s a major city. Duffield Street is well-lit and busy. There’s a police presence nearby because of the courts and government buildings. Like anywhere else, you keep your head on a swivel, but it’s not the "Wild West" narrative some travel forums from 2005 might suggest.
Another thing? The gym. Most hotel gyms are a treadmill and a broken dumbbell. The fitness center here is surprisingly decent. It’s got enough equipment to actually get a workout in, and there's a small indoor pool. It’s not an Olympic lap pool—don't get your hopes up—but for kids or a quick dip, it works.
👉 See also: Pic of Spain Flag: Why You Probably Have the Wrong One and What the Symbols Actually Mean
Nuance: The Small Annoyances
No hotel is perfect. The elevators at this property can be a test of your patience. They’re smart elevators where you press the floor on a keypad outside, which sounds cool until everyone is trying to go to breakfast at 8:30 AM.
The WiFi can also be hit or miss depending on where your room is. If you're a digital nomad trying to upload 4K video, you might want to tether to your phone or head to a local coffee shop like Devoción nearby.
Also, be aware of the "Destination Fee" or "Resort Fee." It’s a common plague in NYC hotels now. At the Sheraton Brooklyn New York Hotel, they usually bundle some credits for food or beverage into it. Make sure you actually use them. Go to the bar and get a drink. Don't let them take your $25-$30 a night for nothing.
Navigating Your Stay Like a Local
If you decide to book, don't just eat at the hotel restaurant (Avere). It’s fine, but you’re in Brooklyn.
- Junior’s Cheesecake is right around the corner. Yes, it’s touristy. Yes, the cheesecake is still that good. Get the plain one.
- Walk to DUMBO. Head down Jay Street. It takes about 20 minutes. You’ll end up at Brooklyn Bridge Park. It’s the best free activity in the city.
- The Shopping. Fulton Mall is right there. It’s loud, it’s chaotic, and it has every major brand you can think of.
- The Transit. Use the "OMNY" tap-to-pay system with your phone or credit card. Don't bother with a MetroCard unless you want a souvenir.
Final Practical Insights
The Sheraton Brooklyn New York Hotel remains a solid choice for the pragmatist. It’s for the traveler who wants a reliable brand name, easy access to every subway line, and a slightly lower bill than what they’d find across the East River.
It’s not the trendiest hotel in the borough—if you want that, you go to the 1 Hotel Brooklyn Bridge or the Wythe—but it’s one of the most functional.
Actionable Steps for Your Visit:
- Request a high floor: Specifically ask for a North-facing room if you want a chance at seeing the Manhattan skyline.
- Check the Barclays Center schedule: If there’s a massive concert or a Nets game, the hotel lobby and local trains will be significantly more crowded.
- Download the Marriott Bonvoy app: Use it for mobile check-in to bypass the front desk lines, which can get long during peak afternoon hours.
- Explore the "Secret" Brooklyn: Take the F train a few stops south to Fourth Avenue-Ninth Street and walk into Park Slope for a completely different, quieter neighborhood vibe.
- Verify the Destination Fee: Upon check-in, ask exactly what is included in the daily fee so you can maximize the value of the credits provided for the bar or pantry.