Manchester City has a way of making everything feel inevitable. You’ve seen it before. It’s that late-season surge where Pep Guardiola’s side turns into a relentless, blue machine that simply refuses to drop points. When people ask is the Premier League over, they usually aren't talking about the calendar. They’re talking about hope.
Football isn't played on paper, but lately, the paper looks pretty scary for everyone not named City. We’re sitting here in 2026, looking at a landscape where the financial gap between the elite and the "rest" feels more like a canyon. But honestly, declaring the title race "dead" in January or February is a loser's game.
The Psychology of the "Finished" Title Race
The Premier League is the most-watched league on the planet because of the "Any Given Sunday" mythos. We want to believe that Ipswich or Brentford can go to the Etihad and cause a riot. When that stops happening, the "is the Premier League over" chatter starts peaking on social media.
It’s about dominance fatigue.
Think back to the 2023/24 season. Arsenal led for a massive chunk of the year. Fans were convinced the cycle had finally broken. Then, April hit. City won nine games in a row. It felt like a foregone conclusion before the final day even kicked off. That’s where the "is it over?" sentiment comes from. It’s a defensive mechanism for fans who don't want to get their hearts broken again.
The Numbers That Say Yes (And the Ones That Don't)
Look at the points per game (PPG) averages. Historically, you needed 80+ points to win this league. Now? If you aren't hitting 90, you're basically playing for second place.
Since 2018, the bar has been raised to an almost impossible height. Liverpool once finished with 97 points and still didn't win the trophy. That is insane. It’s objectively ridiculous.
But here’s the thing: injuries change everything. One hamstring tweak for a key holding midfielder or a dip in form for a world-class keeper can turn a "guaranteed" title into a scrap. We saw it when Virgil van Dijk went down years ago. We see it whenever Kevin De Bruyne misses a month. The league is never over because the human body is fragile, and the English schedule is a meat grinder.
✨ Don't miss: The Division 2 National Championship Game: How Ferris State Just Redrew the Record Books
Is the Premier League Over for the Chasers?
Arsenal and Liverpool have stayed in the conversation by being nearly perfect, but "nearly" doesn't cut it anymore. For the Gunners, the question of whether the league is over usually centers on their ability to handle the pressure of the final six weeks. Mikel Arteta has built a squad that rivals City for defensive solidity, yet they still lack that "inevitable" aura.
The chase is exhausting.
Imagine sprinting for 38 miles and knowing if you trip once, the guy behind you—who happens to be a billionaire-backed cyborg—will glide past you. That’s the reality of the modern Premier League. It’s not just a test of footballing skill; it’s a psychological endurance test.
The Financial Fair Play (PSR) Factor
We can't talk about the end of the league as we know it without mentioning the legal battles. The 115 charges against Manchester City have been a cloud over the sport for years. If you ask a rival fan "is the Premier League over," they might point to the courtroom rather than the pitch.
The Profit and Sustainability Rules (PSR) have started to bite. Hard.
- Everton lost points.
- Nottingham Forest lost points.
- Teams are terrified to spend in January.
This financial gridlock actually makes the league more predictable. If the mid-table teams can’t spend to improve, the gap between the top four and the bottom ten just widens. It creates a "closed shop" feel that kills the drama. When the bottom half of the table feels like a separate league entirely, the overall competition suffers.
Tactical Stagnation and the Death of the Underdog?
Tactics have become a bit... samey. Everyone wants to build from the back. Everyone wants to press high. When everyone plays the same way, the team with the most expensive players usually wins.
🔗 Read more: Por qué los partidos de Primera B de Chile son más entretenidos que la división de honor
There was a time when a "Big Six" team going away to a cold, wet Stoke was a genuine 50/50 toss-up. Now, the technical quality of the elite is so high that they can pass through almost any "low block." The tactical evolution led by coaches like Guardiola and Klopp has made it much harder for smaller teams to fluke a result.
But don't tell that to the fans at Villa Park or St. James' Park. Newcastle and Aston Villa have shown that with the right investment and a specific coaching identity, you can rattle the cage. Is it enough to win a 38-game season? Probably not yet. But it keeps the league from becoming a total monologue.
Why We Keep Watching (The "Not Over" Argument)
The reason the "is the Premier League over" narrative fails is because of the sheer chaos of the English game. It’s the red cards. It’s the VAR drama that makes everyone scream. It’s the 98th-minute winners.
Drama.
Even if the winner feels predictable, the journey is usually a car crash you can't look away from. The battle for the Champions League spots and the relegation dogfight are often more compelling than the actual title race.
Last season, the fight to stay up went down to the wire. The "is it over" question looks very different when you're 17th in the table. For those fans, the league is a terrifying, living thing until the very last whistle of Game 38.
The "New" Challengers
Keep an eye on the shifting power dynamics. Chelsea's chaotic spending spree will eventually have to yield a coherent team, or they'll be the most expensive failure in sports history. Manchester United is forever "two transfer windows away" from being back, but the sheer size of the club means they are always a looming threat if they ever get their internal structure right.
💡 You might also like: South Carolina women's basketball schedule: What Most People Get Wrong
The league isn't over; it's just in a very specific era of dominance. These eras always end. Ask Manchester United fans from the 90s. Ask Liverpool fans from the 70s. Dominance feels permanent when you’re in the middle of it, but it never is.
Final Reality Check
So, is the Premier League over?
If you mean "is the race for first place often a foregone conclusion by May," then yeah, maybe. The financial disparity is a massive problem that the league hasn't solved. But if you mean "is the entertainment value dead," then absolutely not.
The league is transitioning. We are moving away from the "Big Six" era into something more fragmented. We have a "Big Two" at the top, a "Challenger Class" below them, and then a chaotic middle class that can beat anyone on their day.
What You Should Do Next
To get the most out of the current season, stop focusing solely on the trophy. The real "league" is happening in the sub-plots.
- Watch the tactical shifts: Track how teams are adapting to the "mid-block" to counter City’s possession.
- Follow the PSR rulings: These legal decisions will shape the next decade of the league more than any individual signing.
- Value the mid-table chaos: Teams like Brighton and Brentford are playing some of the most innovative football in Europe on a fraction of the budget.
- Ignore the "it's over" talk in December: The festive period is where the wheels usually fall off. Wait until February to make a real judgment.
The Premier League is a soap opera with a massive budget. Even if you know the ending, the episodes are still worth the subscription. Just don't expect the script to change until the financial rules actually level the playing field. Until then, enjoy the high-level football for what it is: a display of near-perfection that we'll probably look back on in twenty years with a mix of awe and frustration.