Ever stared at a green light across the water and wondered if Jay Gatsby was a real guy? It's a fair question. The book feels so specific, so lived-in, that it’s hard to believe F. Scott Fitzgerald just made it all up out of thin air while sitting on a porch in France.
Honestly, the answer isn’t a simple yes or no. It’s more of a "kinda."
While you won't find a "James Gatz" in the 1920s census records of North Dakota, the world he lived in was very real. The parties? Real. The bootlegging? Definitely real. Even that weird "old sport" catchphrase? That actually belonged to a guy Fitzgerald knew.
The man who really was Gatsby (mostly)
If you're looking for the closest thing to a "real" Jay Gatsby, you’ve got to talk about Max Gerlach.
Gerlach was a German-born bootlegger who lived near Fitzgerald on Long Island. He was a mystery wrapped in a pinstripe suit. He claimed to be an Oxford man. He told people he was related to the German Kaiser. He threw massive, booze-fueled parties during Prohibition when the rest of the country was technically "dry."
Sound familiar?
We know for a fact Fitzgerald knew him because of a note Gerlach sent the author in 1923. He signed it, "How are you and the family, old sport?" Fitzgerald was a magpie for details. He saw Gerlach's flamboyant lifestyle—the shirts he never wore twice, the fabricated noble background—and he swiped it. But Gerlach wasn't the whole story. He provided the "lurid dimensions," as some biographers put it, but the soul of the character came from somewhere else entirely.
📖 Related: Dragon Ball All Series: Why We Are Still Obsessed Forty Years Later
The "poor boy" syndrome
The emotional gut of the story—the "poor boy" trying to win the "rich girl"—that was all F. Scott Fitzgerald.
Before he married Zelda, Scott fell hard for a socialite named Ginevra King. She was the "it girl" of Chicago's elite. Scott was a Midwesterner at Princeton with big dreams but a very small bank account.
He stayed at her family's estate, but the romance was doomed. Legend has it that Ginevra’s father told Scott point-blank: "Poor boys shouldn't think of marrying rich girls."
That line haunted him. It became the blueprint for Gatsby’s obsession with Daisy Buchanan. Fitzgerald later told a friend that the whole idea of the book was the "unfairness of a poor young man not being able to marry a girl with money." He lived that rejection. He didn't need to invent the pain; he just needed a character like Max Gerlach to act it out in a more dramatic, criminal way.
The real people behind the characters
Fitzgerald didn't just stop at Gatsby. Almost everyone in the book has a real-world counterpart.
- Daisy Buchanan: Deeply inspired by Ginevra King, though Zelda (Fitzgerald’s wife) definitely contributed some of the "flapper" energy and the Southern belle charm.
- Tom Buchanan: Based largely on William "Bill" Mitchell, the wealthy, polo-playing man Ginevra King actually married. He also pulled traits from Tommy Hitchcock, a famous polo player who lived on Long Island.
- Jordan Baker: This one is a direct lift. Jordan is based on Edith Cummings, a real-life champion golfer and a close friend of Ginevra King. Even the name "Jordan Baker" is a mash-up of two car brands from the 20s: the Jordan Motor Car Company and the Baker Motor Vehicle.
- Meyer Wolfsheim: Based on Arnold Rothstein, the real-life mobster who actually was accused of fixing the 1919 World Series.
The setting: West Egg is a real place (sorta)
The geography of the novel is incredibly precise. West Egg and East Egg are fictional names, but they represent the Great Neck and Port Washington areas of Long Island.
👉 See also: Down On Me: Why This Janis Joplin Classic Still Hits So Hard
In 1922, Scott and Zelda moved to a house in Great Neck (6 Gateway Drive). It was a "new money" town. Across the bay was the "old money" of the North Shore. Scott spent his nights at parties hosted by people like Edward Fuller (a crooked broker) and Allan Dwan (a film director).
He was an outsider looking in.
He’d watch the massive estates from his relatively modest house and see the "careless people" smashing things up. The "Valley of Ashes"? That was a real place too—a massive ash dump in Corona, Queens, that people had to drive through to get from the Long Island mansions to the speakeasies of Manhattan. Today, that's where Flushing Meadows-Corona Park is. You've probably seen the Unisphere there if you've ever flown into LaGuardia.
Is the story actually "true"?
It's a "true story" in the sense that it’s a composite of the 1920s experience.
It wasn't a biography. It was a autopsy of the American Dream. Fitzgerald took his own heartbreak, his neighbor's illegal business, his friend's golfing career, and the headlines of the 1919 Black Sox scandal and stitched them together.
The tragic irony is that Max Gerlach, the guy who likely inspired Gatsby's "old sport" persona, didn't have a glamorous ending either. After Prohibition ended and the Great Depression hit, he lost everything. He eventually tried to end his own life, survived, but went blind and died in a hospital ward in 1958. He even tried to contact Fitzgerald’s biographer to tell him he was the "real" Gatsby, but the biographer didn't believe him.
✨ Don't miss: Doomsday Castle TV Show: Why Brent Sr. and His Kids Actually Built That Fortress
Actionable ways to see the "Real" Gatsby today
If you want to touch the reality of the book, you don't have to look far.
First, go look up the "Big Four" debutantes of Chicago. Seeing photos of Ginevra King and Edith Cummings makes Daisy and Jordan feel much less like literary symbols and more like actual people who once walked around in silk dresses.
Second, if you're ever in New York, take the Long Island Rail Road. Look out the window as you pass through Queens. That stretch between the city and the suburbs is still the same ground Nick Carraway traveled.
Finally, read Fitzgerald's letters. Specifically, look for his correspondence with Maxwell Perkins. You can see the moment he stops trying to write a "story" and starts trying to capture the "feel" of the parties he was actually attending. The book isn't a history book, but it's the most accurate vibe-check of 1925 that exists.
Next time someone asks if the story is real, tell them it’s the most honest lie ever told.