You know that feeling when you see the Restoration Hardware Cloud Couch in a magazine? It looks like a literal marshmallow. A dream. Then you look at the price tag and realize you'd have to sell a kidney just to afford the corner wedge. That’s why everyone and their mother is hunting for the Costco cloud couch dupe. It's the white whale of home decor. People stalk the Costco floor like they’re hunting big game, hoping to snag that massive, modular grey sectional that looks almost identical to the $10,000 original for about a fraction of the cost.
But here is the thing.
Not every "dupe" is actually a good deal. Sometimes a cheap couch is just a cheap couch. I’ve spent way too much time scrolling through Reddit threads, TikTok reviews, and actual furniture construction specs to figure out if the Costco version—formally known as the Thomasville Lowell or the Thomasville Tisdale—actually holds up. It’s not just about the look. It’s about whether the cushions turn into pancakes after three months of Netflix marathons.
The Reality of the Thomasville Tisdale vs. The Real Cloud
Restoration Hardware’s Cloud is famous because it’s filled with a high-density foam core wrapped in a massive amount of goose down. It’s meant to be messy. It’s meant to be "lived in." The Costco cloud couch dupe, specifically the Thomasville Tisdale, doesn't use 100% down. It can't. Not at that price point. Instead, Thomasville uses a mixture of foam and synthetic fibers.
Does it feel the same? Not exactly. The RH version feels like you're sinking into a puddle. The Costco version has a bit more "bounce back." For some people, that’s actually better. Have you ever tried to stand up from a real Cloud Couch? It’s an athletic event. You basically have to roll out onto the floor. The Costco dupe gives you that puffy aesthetic without the feeling of being trapped in a beanbag.
One major difference is the fabric. RH uses premium linens and cottons that are, frankly, a nightmare to clean if you have kids or a dog that likes mud. The Thomasville versions at Costco usually come in a heavy-duty polyester blend. It’s tougher. It’s "juice box" resistant. You sacrifice that ultra-soft linen texture for something that won’t be ruined by a single spilled glass of Cabernet.
Why Everyone Is Obsessed With the Thomasville Lowell
If you’re looking for the Costco cloud couch dupe, you’re probably looking for the Lowell. It’s the six-piece modular sectional that usually retails between $1,500 and $2,000 depending on your local warehouse.
🔗 Read more: Finding Another Word for Calamity: Why Precision Matters When Everything Goes Wrong
- Modular design: You can move the ottomans around to make a giant bed.
- The price: Seriously, it’s thousands cheaper.
- Availability: It pops up, sells out in four hours, and then disappears for months.
The Lowell is the closest thing to the "Cloud" look because of its low profile and square arms. But let's be real for a second. The reason people love it isn't just the style. It’s the Costco return policy. If the springs start squeaking in two years, you can basically bring it back. That’s a level of security you don't get at high-end furniture boutiques. Try returning a five-year-old couch to RH because it’s "saggy." They’ll laugh you out of the showroom.
Dealing With the "Sinking" Problem
Let's talk about the sagging. This is the biggest complaint with any Costco cloud couch dupe. Because these cushions are designed to be soft, the foam isn't as rigid as a traditional mid-century modern sofa.
After six months, you might notice a "butt groove."
You have to flip the cushions. Often. If you’re the kind of person who wants a couch to look pristine and tight 24/7, this is not the furniture for you. These couches are designed to look slightly disheveled. They are the "messy bun" of the furniture world. If you hate fluffing pillows, you are going to hate owning a modular cloud dupe. It’s a high-maintenance relationship.
Price Comparisons and What You Actually Pay
In 2024 and 2025, we saw the prices of these sectionals fluctuate wildly. At the warehouse, you might find the Thomasville Tisdale for $1,299. Online? It might be $1,899 because "shipping and handling" is included. And "included" is a sneaky word for "expensive because this thing weighs 500 pounds."
- Warehouse Price: Often $300-$500 cheaper than the website.
- Delivery: If you buy in-store, you need a massive truck. Don't try to fit this in a Honda CR-V. I've seen people try. It’s heartbreaking.
- The "Hidden" Costs: You’ll probably want to buy fabric protector spray (like Scotchgard) because even though it’s durable, the light grey shows everything.
Is it a "Fake" Cloud or a Better Version?
Some furniture experts, like those you’ll find on interior design forums, argue that the Costco cloud couch dupe is actually a better "daily driver" than the original. Why? Because the original Cloud is notorious for needing professional steaming and fluffing to not look like a pile of laundry. The Thomasville versions have more structural integrity.
💡 You might also like: False eyelashes before and after: Why your DIY sets never look like the professional photos
There's also the issue of off-gassing. Some cheap dupes you find on random websites smell like a chemical factory for weeks. Costco tends to vet their suppliers better. The Thomasville brand has been around since 1904. They aren't some fly-by-night operation popping up on an Instagram ad. They use CertiPUR-US certified foam, which means you aren't breathing in the worst kinds of flame retardants while you nap.
The Delivery Nightmare Nobody Mentions
If you order the Costco cloud couch dupe online, prepare your soul. The boxes are gargantuan. We are talking about six or seven boxes that will take up your entire garage. Most Costco deliveries are "threshold," meaning they drop them at your door or in your garage. They won't set it up. They won't take away the cardboard.
You will have enough cardboard to build a small village.
Putting it together is easy—usually just clipping the sections together—but the sheer volume of trash is something nobody prepares you for in the TikTok "unboxing" videos. Plan for a trip to the recycling center.
Comparing the Specific Models
The Costco cloud couch dupe isn't just one couch. It changes every season.
Currently, the Thomasville Tisdale is the reigning champ. It has a slightly more "structured" look. Then there’s the Thomasville Lowell, which is fluffier and lower to the ground. Occasionally, Costco carries the Picket House Furnishings brand online, which is even closer to the RH aesthetic but often costs a bit more.
📖 Related: Exactly What Month is Ramadan 2025 and Why the Dates Shift
If you see the Maddox or the Davenport, those are also in the "cloud-like" family. The Davenport is more of a traditional sectional, but it uses that same soft, overstuffed cushion style. If you want the true "Cloud" feel, look for the one with the most pieces. The 6-piece modular sets allow for the most customization, which is a hallmark of the high-end original.
Pro Tips for Snagging One
You can't just walk into Costco and expect it to be there.
Check the "Last Chance" or "Manager's Special" areas in the back of the warehouse. Sometimes a floor model goes on sale for a ridiculous price—I’ve seen them as low as $800. Also, join the Costco fan groups on Facebook. People post "sightings" like they're tracking a rare bird. "Lowell spotted in New Jersey warehouse!"
Honestly, the best time to buy is usually late summer or right after the New Year when people are doing "home refreshes."
The Actionable Verdict
If you are obsessed with the aesthetic of the Cloud Couch but your budget is more "Target" than "Tribeca," the Costco cloud couch dupe is a solid win. You get the look, the modular flexibility, and the legendary Costco return policy. Just be ready to fluff the cushions every Sunday and have a plan for a mountain of cardboard.
Next Steps for Your Search:
- Measure your space twice. These modular sets are much larger in person than they look in the cavernous Costco warehouse.
- Check the SKU number. Call your local warehouse and ask if they have SKU #1440034 (Tisdale) or #1570086 (Lowell) in stock before driving down.
- Prepare your vehicle. Rent a U-Haul or a large pickup truck if you're buying in-store; the boxes will not fit in a standard SUV.
- Invest in a fabric shaver. Like many polyester blends, these can develop "pills" over time. A $15 fabric shaver will keep it looking brand new for years.
- Rotate the layout. Every three months, swap the corner pieces with the middle pieces to ensure the foam wears evenly across the entire sectional.