The secondary market is bleeding. If you’ve walked into a liquor store lately and actually saw a bottle of Buffalo Trace sitting on the shelf for its MSRP of $35, you aren’t dreaming. It’s happening. For a decade, the American whiskey scene felt like an unstoppable freight train fueled by FOMO, Instagram "crotch shots" of rare bottles, and a massive influx of "taters" looking to flip Blanton’s for a 300% profit. But look at the data from late 2024 and heading into 2026. The frantic energy has shifted. People are starting to ask the uncomfortable question: is the bourbon boom over?
It's complicated.
Actually, it’s a reckoning. For years, every mid-sized distillery in Kentucky and Indiana was expanding, adding rickhouses like they were LEGO sets. Now, the industry is staring down a massive surplus of aging liquid just as consumer demand starts to wobble. We’re seeing a classic "bullwhip effect." Distillers overproduced to meet the insane demand of 2021, and now that supply is finally hitting the market, the buyers are tightening their belts. High interest rates, a cooling economy, and a general "bourbon fatigue" have turned the hunt into a chore.
The Secondary Market Collapse and Why It Matters
Let's talk about the "Blue Book" of bourbon—the secondary groups on Facebook and Discord. A couple of years ago, a bottle of Weller Antique 107 would vanish at $200. Today? You see them sitting at $120, and even then, buyers are haggling. The 2025 auction cycles showed a significant dip in "hammer prices" for mid-tier collectibles. Even the heavy hitters like Pappy Van Winkle or George T. Stagg aren't seeing those vertical price climbs anymore. They’ve plateaued. Or worse, they’re slipping.
Why? Because the "investors" are fleeing. When the bourbon boom was at its peak, people who didn't even like whiskey were buying bottles to store in closets as alternative assets. That’s a dangerous game. Whiskey isn't gold. You can’t eat it, and if the market sours, you’re left with a very expensive glass of fermented corn mash. As the "easy money" dried up, these flippers started dumping their "cellars," flooding the market and driving prices down.
🔗 Read more: Price of Tesla Stock Today: Why Everyone is Watching January 28
Honestly, it’s a relief for those of us who just want to drink the stuff.
The Oversaturation of "Craft" and the $100 MGP Problem
Go to any local liquor store. You’ll see dozens of brands you’ve never heard of. Most of them have fancy labels, a story about a "great-grandfather’s recipe," and a $95 price tag. Most of them are also just sourced whiskey from MGP in Indiana or Bardstown Bourbon Company. There is nothing wrong with sourced whiskey—some of the best bottles on my shelf are sourced—but the consumer has caught on. They’re tired of paying a 400% markup for a 4-year-old bourbon just because the bottle has a wax seal and a cork made of reclaimed barn wood.
The market is currently choked with "premium" releases that aren't actually premium.
Distilleries are feeling the heat. Look at the recent financial reports from giants like Brown-Forman (who own Old Forester and Woodford Reserve) or Campari Group (Wild Turkey). They’ve noted a "normalization" of the market. That's corporate-speak for "people aren't buying cases of everything we put out anymore." When the big players start getting nervous about inventory levels, you know the tide has turned.
💡 You might also like: GA 30084 from Georgia Ports Authority: The Truth Behind the Zip Code
The Rise of Tequila and "Sober Curiosity"
Bourbon isn't competing in a vacuum. It’s fighting for "share of throat." Right now, tequila is the monster in the room. High-end additive-free tequilas are stealing the "connoisseur" crowd that used to obsess over high-proof wheated bourbons. Then you have the Gen Z factor. Younger drinkers are demonstrably consuming less alcohol than their parents. They’re into "functional beverages" or mocktails. A 130-proof "hazmat" bourbon that burns your throat isn't exactly a priority for a generation focused on wellness and $18 Erewhon smoothies.
Is the Bourbon Boom Over for Distilleries?
Not exactly, but the "Easy Mode" is definitely disabled. If you're a distillery that started five years ago thinking you could just put anything in a bottle and sell it for $80, you’re probably panicking. Many smaller operations are currently looking for buyers or considering shifting their production to contract distilling for others just to keep the lights on.
We are entering the "Age of Quality."
- Transparency is mandatory. No more fake stories. Consumers want to know the mash bill, the age, and exactly where it was distilled.
- Price corrections. We are seeing more "allocated" bottles appearing in MSRP-only state stores and staying there for more than ten minutes.
- Experience over ownership. People are spending money on distillery tours and tastings rather than hoarding bottles they’ll never open.
A friend of mine who runs a high-end liquor store in Chicago told me last month that his "allocated" list has shrunk by half. People just aren't calling every Tuesday morning to see if the truck arrived. The fatigue is real. You can only be told "no" by a store clerk so many times before you decide that Wild Turkey 101—which is always on the shelf and always delicious—is good enough.
📖 Related: Jerry Jones 19.2 Billion Net Worth: Why Everyone is Getting the Math Wrong
What This Means for You (The Actual Drinker)
If you love bourbon, this is actually the best news you've heard in a decade. The end of the "hype" era means the return of the "drinking" era. We are heading toward a buyer's market.
- Wait them out. Don't pay secondary prices for anything right now. The prices are dropping. That bottle of Eagle Rare you’ve been eyeing? It’ll be $40 again soon if you’re patient.
- Explore the "Shelfers." Revisit the staples. Knob Creek 12, Old Grand-Dad 114, and Russell’s Reserve 10 are consistently better than 90% of the "limited edition" bottles that cost three times as much.
- Watch the Craft Fallout. Within the next 18 months, expect to see a lot of small-brand liquid being sold off or discounted as companies try to clear inventory. This is where you’ll find the real bargains.
- Demand age statements. If a brand is asking for $100, it better have a double-digit age statement. The days of "NAS" (No Age Statement) bottles commanding premium prices are dying.
The bourbon boom is over in the sense that the irrational, speculative bubble has popped. The "gold rush" is finished. But bourbon itself? It's not going anywhere. Kentucky didn't stop making the best spirit in the world. They just finally made enough of it that we don't have to fight each other in a Total Wine parking lot at 6:00 AM to get a taste.
Take a breath. Pour a glass. The madness is fading, and for the first time in a long time, the whiskey world feels like it's for the drinkers again.
Next Steps for Savvy Bourbon Fans:
- Audit your collection: If you have bottles you bought solely for "investment," consider selling them now before the secondary floor drops further.
- Track MSRP vs. Market: Use tools like Bourbon Blue Book or Wine-Searcher to see real-time price trends; you'll notice the gap is closing fast.
- Support Transparent Distillers: Direct your spending toward distilleries like Castle & Key, New Lineage, or Peerless that are open about their processes and pricing.
- Stop chasing "Leads": Instead of following delivery trucks, join a local tasting club where the focus is on sharing pours rather than hoarding glass.