Is the 25 pound medicine ball actually too heavy for you?

Is the 25 pound medicine ball actually too heavy for you?

You’re standing in the gym, staring at that rack of rubber spheres. There’s the 10-pounder that feels like a toy and the 50-pounder that looks like a literal boulder. Then your eyes land on the 25 pound medicine ball. It’s the "tweener." It looks manageable until you actually try to chuck it against a wall twenty times in a row. Honestly, most people underestimate how much of a jump that 25-pound mark actually is from the lighter gear.

It’s heavy.

If you’re coming from a background of lifting dumbbells, 25 pounds sounds like nothing. You curl that for breakfast, right? But physics is a jerk. A medicine ball isn't just a dead weight; it’s a tool for velocity. When you add momentum to twenty-five pounds of shifting sand or dense rubber, that weight multiplies. If you’re doing a standard overhead slam, you aren't just moving 25 pounds—you’re managing the eccentric force of that weight coming down and the explosive power needed to send it back up.

Most people use it wrong. They treat it like a slow-motion strength tool when it’s actually meant to be an engine for power.


Why the 25 pound medicine ball is the "ego killer" of the gym

There is a very specific phenomenon that happens when a gym-goer grabs a 25 pound medicine ball for the first time. They think they can handle the high-volume CrossFit style "wall balls." Then, about six reps in, the lungs start burning and the form goes to trash. Why? Because 25 pounds is right at the threshold where aerobic capacity meets raw strength.

According to various strength and conditioning standards—think NSCA or NASM guidelines—power is defined as force times velocity. If the ball is so heavy that you’re moving like you’re stuck in molasses, you aren't training power anymore. You’re just doing a really awkward, rounded-back squat. For a lot of intermediate athletes, 25 pounds is actually too heavy for high-speed metabolic conditioning but just right for rotational strength.

It’s about the "sticking point."

If you can’t throw the ball with enough force that it would hypothetically break a piece of drywall, you should probably be using a 15 or 20-pounder. But if you’re using that 25-pound weight for something like a "Russian Twist" or a "Weighted Sit-up," it becomes a different beast entirely. It’s an anchor. It forces your internal obliques and your transverse abdominis to fire in a way that a light ball never will.

💡 You might also like: Can DayQuil Be Taken At Night: What Happens If You Skip NyQuil

The different types of balls (and why it matters)

You’ve got the hard rubber ones that bounce back and hit you in the face if you aren't careful. Then you’ve got the "Slam Balls"—usually filled with sand—that hit the floor with a satisfying thud and stay there.

  1. The Bounce Factor: If you’re doing wall balls against a target, you want a "Medicine Ball" (often soft-shelled). A 25 pound medicine ball with a 14-inch diameter is the standard for "Heavy" Rx workouts in many competitive circles.
  2. The "Dead" Ball: If your goal is to slam the thing into the ground as hard as possible to blow off steam and build explosive hips, get a Slam Ball. If you use a bouncy rubber ball for slams, you’re going to end up with a broken nose. No joke.

Rotational Power: The 25-Pound Sweet Spot

Let’s talk about the "Side Toss." This is where the 25 pound medicine ball really shines for athletes, specifically baseball players, golfers, or anyone who needs to rotate their torso with violence.

When you stand perpendicular to a wall and launch that ball sideways, you’re training "transverse plane" power. It’s a movement we rarely do in the land of bench presses and squats. Most trainers, like Eric Cressey (who is basically the godfather of baseball strength), emphasize that you shouldn't just arm the ball. You have to push from the back foot.

Twenty-five pounds provides enough resistance to force your body to use your glutes to drive the movement. If the ball is too light, you just flick it with your wrists. If it’s 25 pounds, you have to use your legs. That’s the magic of this specific weight. It’s heavy enough to demand respect but light enough to actually move.

Does it actually build muscle?

Kinda. But that’s not really the point. If you want huge biceps, go do chin-ups. If you want a core that feels like a suit of armor, start doing "Halo" circles with a 25 pound medicine ball.

Moving a weight in a circular motion around your head requires every tiny stabilizer muscle in your shoulders and spine to wake up. It’s "functional" in the sense that it prepares you for the weird, off-balance movements of real life—like lugging a heavy suitcase into an overhead bin or wrestling a toddler.

The Safety Reality Check

We have to be honest here: 25 pounds is heavy enough to mess up your lower back if your ego gets in the way.

📖 Related: Nuts Are Keto Friendly (Usually), But These 3 Mistakes Will Kick You Out Of Ketosis

The biggest mistake? Rounding the spine during a pickup. People treat a medicine ball like a piece of trash on the floor. They bend at the waist, grab it with straight legs, and yank. That’s a recipe for a herniated disc. You have to squat to the ball. You have to treat that 25 pound medicine ball with the same technical respect you’d give a 300-pound barbell.

Also, watch your toes. Seriously.

A workout that isn't just "Slams"

Instead of just throwing the ball at the floor until you're bored, try a "Complex."

  • Start with 5 Goblet Squats holding the ball at chest height.
  • Immediately go into 5 Overhead Presses.
  • Finish with 5 Slams.
  • Rest for 30 seconds.
  • Repeat until you hate your life choices.

This works because the 25 pound medicine ball stays in your hands the whole time. There’s no "off" switch for your core. Your heart rate will spike faster than if you were running sprints. It’s efficient. It’s brutal.


What to look for when buying one

If you’re shopping for a 25 pound medicine ball, don't just buy the cheapest one on Amazon. Cheap balls have a tendency to become "lopsided." The sand or stuffing inside shifts to one side, and suddenly you’re trying to throw a weight that wobbles in mid-air. It’s annoying and it ruins your rhythm.

Look for "double-stitched" seams if it’s a soft-shell ball. If it’s a slam ball, look for a textured surface. Sweat is the enemy of a good grip. Once that rubber gets wet, a 25-pound ball becomes a 25-pound projectile slipping out of your hands.

Wait, what about the size?
A standard "Wall Ball" is usually about 14 inches in diameter regardless of weight. This is intentional. It keeps your posture consistent whether you’re throwing 10 pounds or 30. If you get a tiny, 9-inch rubber ball that weighs 25 pounds, it’s going to feel way heavier because the weight is concentrated. It’s harder to catch. It’s harder to hold.

👉 See also: That Time a Doctor With Measles Treating Kids Sparked a Massive Health Crisis

For most people, the larger diameter soft-shell 25 pound medicine ball is the better entry point for home gyms. It’s more versatile. You can sit on it (kind of), you can use it for wall balls, and it won't crack your floor tiles if you drop it.

The Verdict on 25 Pounds

Is it the "perfect" weight? For a grown man with some lifting experience, yeah, it’s probably the best all-around utility weight. For most women or beginners, it’s a "heavy" ball used for specific strength sets rather than high-rep cardio.

The goal isn't just to move the weight. It's to move the weight with intent. If you're sluggish, put the 25-pounder down and grab the 15. There’s no shame in it. The ball doesn't care about your feelings, but your rotator cuff definitely does.

Practical Next Steps

If you’re ready to actually use this thing effectively, stop doing random reps. Start by mastering the Chest Pass. Stand 5 feet from a sturdy wall, hold the 25 pound medicine ball at your sternum, and explode forward, stepping into the throw. Catch it on the rebound and immediately go again. Do 3 sets of 8 reps.

Once that feels fast—not just "possible" but fast—move on to the Overhead Slam. Focus on using your abs to "crunch" the ball down, rather than just using your arms.

Finally, incorporate the 25 pound medicine ball into your lunges. Hold it on one shoulder for one set, then switch to the other. The asymmetrical loading will force your obliques to stabilize your spine in a way a balanced barbell never could. Stop thinking of it as a "weight" and start thinking of it as a tool for instability and power. That's how you actually get results from it.