Is the 1 Hotel Brooklyn Bridge pool actually worth the price of admission?

Is the 1 Hotel Brooklyn Bridge pool actually worth the price of admission?

You’ve seen the photos. Honestly, if you’ve spent more than five minutes scrolling through New York City travel tags on Instagram, you’ve definitely seen that specific angle of the Manhattan skyline framed by a glass railing and a cocktail. It looks perfect. It looks like the peak of Brooklyn luxury. But let’s be real for a second—hotels are great at selling a vibe that doesn't always match the reality of standing in a crowded space with a $25 drink in your hand.

The 1 Hotel Brooklyn Bridge pool is one of those places that people talk about with a mix of reverence and slight annoyance. It’s iconic. It’s also incredibly exclusive. Located on the 10th-floor rooftop (aptly named Harriet’s Rooftop), this "plunge pool" isn't exactly where you’d go to swim laps for your morning cardio. It’s a scene. It’s a mood. And if you aren't prepared for how the hotel manages access, you’re probably going to end up disappointed at the elevator bank.

The Reality of the "Plunge"

Size matters, but maybe not here. If you are expecting an Olympic-sized swimming hole, you’re in the wrong zip code. The pool at 1 Hotel Brooklyn Bridge is small. Like, surprisingly small. It is deep enough to cool off, but the primary function is clearly to act as a foreground for the view of the East River and the Statue of Liberty.

Because the hotel leans so heavily into its "eco-luxury" branding, the aesthetic is all reclaimed wood, greenery, and neutral tones. It feels organic. It feels expensive. The water is kept at a comfortable temperature, but the real draw is the fact that you are hovering right at the edge of Brooklyn Heights, looking directly at the Financial District.

Who actually gets in?

This is where things get tricky. People often assume that booking a room at a high-end hotel automatically grants them a poolside lounge chair for the duration of their stay. At the 1 Hotel Brooklyn Bridge, that is a dangerous assumption to make.

The pool is primarily for hotel guests. That sounds simple, right? Not quite. During peak season—basically May through September—the rooftop becomes one of the most coveted spots in the city. Even if you are staying in a $800-a-night room, you aren't guaranteed a seat. The hotel operates on a first-come, first-served basis for the loungers. If you show up at 2:00 PM on a Saturday in July, you’re probably going to be standing.

Then there’s the "non-guest" factor.

📖 Related: Novotel Perth Adelaide Terrace: What Most People Get Wrong

Can you visit if you aren't staying there?

Technically, Harriet’s Rooftop (the bar area) is open to the public, but the pool itself is usually reserved for guests. However, they sometimes offer day passes through platforms like ResortPass, though these are rarer than a quiet subway car. If you’re just visiting the bar, you can look at the pool, but don't expect to dip a toe in unless you’ve got a room key or a very specific reservation.

The Harriet’s Rooftop Vibe

The pool is basically an extension of Harriet’s Rooftop. It’s loud. It’s buzzy. On weekends, there is almost always a DJ playing something that sounds like it belongs in a high-end boutique in Soho. It’s not a place for a quiet nap.

Waitstaff are constantly weaving through the crowds. The menu is what you’d expect: seasonal cocktails, local beers, and "elevated" snacks. You’re going to pay a "view tax." A margarita here will cost you significantly more than it would at a dive bar in Bushwick, but you aren't paying for the tequila; you’re paying for the fact that you can see the Brooklyn Bridge while you sip it.

The crowd is a mix of international tourists, influencers doing "content days," and locals who are celebrating something big. It’s a dressed-up environment. Even though it’s a pool, you’ll see people in high-end designer swimwear and linen sets that probably shouldn't get wet.

Sustainability or Just Good Marketing?

The 1 Hotel brand hangs its hat on being "green." At the Brooklyn Bridge location, this translates to things like a rain-water reclamation system that helps irrigate the local park and the greenery on the building. The pool itself is part of this ecosystem.

Does the "eco-friendly" nature of the pool make the water feel different? No. But it does give you a bit of a moral cushion while you’re indulging in high-end hospitality. The hotel uses a lot of natural materials, and the pool deck is no exception. It feels less like a sterile concrete slab and more like a high-end garden that happens to have a pool in the middle of it.

👉 See also: Magnolia Fort Worth Texas: Why This Street Still Defines the Near Southside

When to go (and when to avoid)

If you want the "I have the world to myself" feeling, you have to go early. Like, 8:00 AM early. The pool usually opens around then for guests, and the first hour is the only time you’ll find any semblance of peace. By noon, the energy shifts. By 4:00 PM, it’s a full-on party.

  • Weekdays: Your best bet for a lounge chair.
  • Sunset: The most crowded time, for obvious reasons. The light hitting the Manhattan skyline is genuinely breathtaking.
  • Rainy Days: Surprisingly great if it’s just a light drizzle. The rooftop clears out, but the bar area is partially covered.

Is it actually worth the hype?

Honestly? It depends on what you value. If you want a serious swimming experience, you’re better off at a public pool or a different hotel with a lap pool. If you want a "Brooklyn" experience that feels gritty and authentic, this isn't it. This is polished. This is curated.

But if you want that specific feeling of being "in" New York—where the city feels massive and you feel like you’re right in the center of the action—the 1 Hotel Brooklyn Bridge pool delivers. There are very few places in the world that offer that specific vantage point. Standing at the edge of the water, looking at the bridge cables and the skyscrapers across the water, it’s hard not to feel a little bit like you’ve made it.

Common Misconceptions

One thing people get wrong constantly is the "public access" rule. I’ve seen people show up in swimsuits thinking they can just buy a drink and jump in. Security is tight. They check room keys. Don't be that person.

Another thing: the wind. You’re on the 10th floor right on the water. Even on a hot day, it can get breezy up there. If you’re planning to spend the whole day, bring a light cover-up.

Logistics and Practicality

The hotel is located at 60 Furman St. It’s right in Brooklyn Bridge Park. This means if you get bored of the pool (if that’s possible), you can just walk out the front door and you’re in one of the best waterfront parks in the country.

✨ Don't miss: Why Molly Butler Lodge & Restaurant is Still the Heart of Greer After a Century

If you are staying at the hotel, use the app to check on rooftop capacity. Sometimes they can give you a heads-up if it’s totally slammed. Also, keep in mind that the rooftop can close for private events. There is nothing worse than paying for a room specifically for the pool and finding out a tech company has rented the whole deck for a corporate mixer. Always call ahead and ask about the schedule during your stay.

A Note on the "Pool Menu"

Don't expect a full steak dinner poolside. The food is designed to be eaten with one hand while holding a phone or a drink in the other. Think sliders, lobster rolls, and fresh fruit. It’s good, but it’s pricey. Budget about $100 per person if you plan on having a couple of drinks and a snack.

Is it overpriced? Probably. Is it a unique experience? Definitely.

Actionable Steps for Your Visit

If you’re planning to tackle the 1 Hotel Brooklyn Bridge pool experience, you need a game plan. Don't just wing it.

  1. Book your room early. This hotel sells out months in advance during the summer. If you want a specific weekend, start looking in February or March.
  2. Verify the pool hours. They can change based on the season or weather. Don't assume it’s 24/7.
  3. Pack the right gear. You want high-end swimwear but also something you can wear into the bar area, as they have a "resort casual" dress code for the indoor parts of Harriet’s.
  4. Arrive at the deck 15 minutes before opening. If you want a prime lounger with a view of the bridge, this is the only way to guarantee it.
  5. Check for private event closures. Call the front desk 48 hours before your check-in to see if any weddings or corporate events have blocked off the rooftop. This happens more often than people realize.
  6. Budget for the "Experience." Don't let the price of a $26 cocktail ruin your mood. Know going in that this is a "splurge" day.

The pool isn't just a place to get wet; it’s a literal overlook of the most famous skyline in the world. As long as you know the rules and manage your expectations regarding the crowd and the size, it remains one of the most spectacular spots in New York City. Just remember: the bridge isn't going anywhere, but your chance at a front-row lounge chair will disappear by 10:30 AM.