You crack an egg over a hot skillet, expecting that perfect sunrise yellow, but then you see it. A tiny, angry-looking crimson speck or a distinct streak of red in yolk of egg. Your stomach probably did a little flip. It looks like a mistake. It looks like something that shouldn't be in your breakfast. Most people immediately reach for a spoon to scoop it out, or worse, they toss the whole egg down the drain.
But hold on.
Before you waste a perfectly good protein source, let's talk about what that spot actually is. It isn't a sign of a "bad" egg, and it definitely doesn't mean you're about to eat a baby chick. Honestly, the poultry industry spends millions of dollars trying to keep these eggs off your grocery store shelves, but nature is persistent.
What causes that red in yolk of egg?
Technically, that spot is a hemorrhage. Sounds intense, right? It's really not. During the ovulation cycle of a hen, a yolk is released from the ovary. It travels through the oviduct to be wrapped in whites and a shell. The yolk is held in a vascularized sac. If a tiny blood vessel—a capillary—ruptures when the yolk is released, a drop of blood hitches a ride. That’s it.
Sometimes the rupture happens in the ovary itself. Other times, it happens in the oviduct. If the blood is on the yolk, it happened earlier in the process. If you see a "meat spot" (which is usually brown or white) in the egg white, that's often a bit of tissue or an older blood spot that has changed color.
Why do some eggs have them and others don't?
It's mostly down to the hen's age and genetics. Younger hens just starting their laying cycle are more prone to these little "glitches." Their systems are still finding a rhythm. Think of it like a new machine that occasionally sparks before it's broken in.
✨ Don't miss: Williams Sonoma Deer Park IL: What Most People Get Wrong About This Kitchen Icon
Then there's the breed. Did you know brown egg layers have a higher frequency of blood spots? It’s true. Statistics from the University of New Hampshire Cooperative Extension suggest that while white-egg-laying Leghorns rarely produce these spots, some heavy brown-egg breeds might have them in up to 10% of their output.
Commercial egg producers use a process called candling. They pass eggs over a bright light to peek through the shell. If they see a spot, the egg is diverted. It might end up in "liquid egg" products where it's filtered out, or sold to bakeries where the appearance doesn't matter. But candling isn't perfect. Brown shells are thicker and darker, making it way harder for the light to reveal that tiny bit of red in yolk of egg. That’s why you’re more likely to find them in those "organic, cage-free, farm-fresh" brown eggs you bought for five bucks a dozen.
Is it safe to eat?
Yes.
I’ll say it again: yes. The USDA and the Egg Safety Center both confirm that eggs with blood spots are completely safe for human consumption as long as you cook them properly. A blood spot isn't a sign of bacteria. It's not a sign of disease. It’s just a localized bit of protein and iron.
If the sight of it grosses you out, just take a clean knife and flick it out. You don't need to throw the whole egg away. Honestly, once the egg is scrambled or baked into a cake, you’ll never know it was there.
🔗 Read more: Finding the most affordable way to live when everything feels too expensive
Debunking the "Fertilized" Myth
There is a massive misconception that red in yolk of egg means the egg was fertilized and a chick was starting to grow. This is 100% false.
Fertilization happens at the germinal disc—a tiny, barely visible white spot on the yolk. A blood spot is a mechanical error of the hen's anatomy, not a biological sign of an embryo. In fact, most commercial eggs come from hens that have never even seen a rooster. No rooster, no baby chick. Period.
Why you're seeing more of them lately
If you feel like you're seeing more red specks lately, you might be right. The rise in popularity of "backyard chickens" and local farmers' markets is the main culprit.
Small-scale farmers don't always have high-tech mass-candling machines. They might candle by hand, or not at all. Plus, heritage breeds—the ones that produce those beautiful chocolate-brown or blue-green eggs—are genetically more "excitable" in their reproductive tracts.
- Dietary Factors: Sometimes a lack of Vitamin A or Vitamin K in a hen's diet can lead to more frequent hemorrhaging.
- Stress: A sudden loud noise or a predator lurking near the coop can startle a hen, causing a physical "jump" that results in a ruptured vessel during the laying process.
- Lighting: Changes in the length of the day can mess with a hen's cycle, leading to more "errors" in the egg-making factory.
The difference between a blood spot and a "bloody" egg
Every once in a long while, you might crack an egg and find the entire white is tinted pink or red. This is different. This isn't a simple blood spot.
💡 You might also like: Executive desk with drawers: Why your home office setup is probably failing you
A pink or pearlescent egg white (albumen) is often a sign of spoilage caused by Pseudomonas bacteria. This is the one time you should actually worry. If the white looks cloudy-pink or has a weird iridescent sheen, toss it. Don't even taste it. It's rare in store-bought eggs but can happen if an egg has been sitting in a warm environment for too long.
How to handle an egg with a spot
Don't panic. Take a breath. If you’re making an omelet, just whisk it in. If you’re making a poached egg where presentation is everything, use the tip of a shell or a spoon to lift the spot out.
It’s actually quite difficult to catch every single one of these. Even with modern sensors that use sound waves and light spectrums, some slip through. It’s just part of eating a natural product. We've become so used to "perfect" food that any slight variation feels like a threat. It isn't.
Steps for the home cook:
- Check for odor: If the egg smells like sulfur or "off," throw it away regardless of spots.
- Inspect the white: If the white is clear (or slightly cloudy, which is actually a sign of freshness), you're good. If it's pink, discard it.
- Remove or ignore: Use a spoon to remove the red in yolk of egg if it bothers you.
- Cook thoroughly: As with any egg, cooking to an internal temperature of 160°F kills any potential pathogens like Salmonella, though the blood spot itself is harmless.
Nature is messy. Hens aren't machines. Sometimes the "factory" has a little hiccup, and you get a tiny bit of red in yolk of egg. It’s a sign that your egg came from a living creature, not a lab.
Next time you're at the store, remember that those "Grade AA" eggs are just the ones that passed the beauty pageant. The ones with the spots are just as nutritious, just as tasty, and totally fine for your Sunday brunch.
Actionable Next Steps
To minimize your chances of encountering blood spots, stick to Grade AA white eggs from large commercial producers, as their candling processes are the most rigorous. However, if you prefer the flavor and ethics of pasture-raised or local eggs, simply keep a small ramekin on your counter. Crack each egg into the ramekin first before adding it to your pan or mixing bowl. This allows you to inspect the yolk and easily remove any spots without ruining the rest of your ingredients. If you find a "bloody" white that looks pinkish throughout, discard the egg immediately and wash the ramekin with hot, soapy water to prevent cross-contamination from potential bacteria.