We’ve all been there. You're trying to book a flight or coordinate with the in-laws and you find yourself staring at a calendar asking, is thanksgiving always the 4th thursday, or did I just make that up? It feels like a law of nature. It’s the anchor of the American autumn. But honestly, if you feel a little confused about the timing some years, there's a good reason for it. The date has actually shifted more than you’d think, and for some pretty weird reasons involving department store tycoons and a very frustrated President.
It hasn't always been the fourth Thursday. Not even close.
For decades, the holiday was basically a "floating" event that depended entirely on who was in the Oval Office. We take the consistency for granted now, but the path to our current "fixed" schedule was paved with political drama and a massive national argument over—believe it or not—the Christmas shopping season.
The Long Road to the Fourth Thursday
The short answer is yes, currently, by federal law, it is. But the "why" is where it gets interesting. Back in the day, after George Washington issued the first proclamation, it was sort of a free-for-all. It wasn't until Sarah Josepha Hale, the woman who wrote "Mary Had a Little Lamb," spent thirty years badgering presidents that we got any real consistency. She wanted a unified national day to help heal the country as it tore itself apart over slavery.
Abraham Lincoln finally listened in 1863. He set it for the last Thursday of November.
Wait. The last Thursday?
Exactly. That's different from the fourth Thursday. Most of the time, those two things are the same. But every once in a while, November has five Thursdays. This is where the chaos started. For over 70 years, Americans just got used to it being the final Thursday of the month. It was predictable. It was tradition. Then came 1939, a year that messed everything up and briefly gave us two different Thanksgivings.
📖 Related: Why Transparent Plus Size Models Are Changing How We Actually Shop
Franksgiving: The Year the Calendar Broke
Imagine it’s 1939. The Great Depression is still weighing heavy on everyone's wallet. Retailers are panicked. That year, November had five Thursdays, which meant the "last" Thursday fell on November 30th. This left only about twenty shopping days before Christmas.
Enter Franklin D. Roosevelt.
Basically, the heads of major department stores like Macy’s and Gimbels got in FDR's ear. They argued that if he didn't move the holiday up a week, the economy would tank because people wouldn't start shopping until after the turkey was cleared. FDR, focused on the New Deal and economic recovery, thought, "Sure, why not?" and moved the holiday to the fourth Thursday (November 23rd) instead of the fifth.
People lost their minds.
It was a total mess. Half the country ignored him. In fact, 23 states stayed with the traditional last Thursday, while 22 followed FDR’s "Franksgiving" date. Texas, being Texas, decided to take both days off. Football coaches were furious because their big Thanksgiving rivalry games were already scheduled. Calendar makers had already printed millions of copies with the "wrong" date. It was a cultural divide that made people feel like the government was meddling with their very souls.
The Law That Finally Fixed It
By 1941, even FDR had to admit the experiment was kinda a failure. Data showed that moving the date didn't actually make people spend significantly more money. People just shopped later and more frantically. Congress stepped in to stop the madness.
👉 See also: Weather Forecast Calumet MI: What Most People Get Wrong About Keweenaw Winters
On December 26, 1941, they passed a joint resolution. This officially mandated that is thanksgiving always the 4th thursday would be the answer from that point forward. They chose the "fourth" instead of "last" as a compromise. This gave retailers that extra week in those rare five-Thursday years, but it stopped the date from jumping around at the whim of the executive branch.
It’s been that way ever since. We’ve had a solid 80+ years of consistency, which is probably why the 1939 "Franksgiving" drama feels like such a weird fever dream in American history.
Why Does the Thursday Even Matter?
You might wonder why we don't just pick a numerical date like Christmas. Why not just say November 25th?
Tradition is part of it, but there's a practical side to the Thursday choice too. Historically, Thursday was a "slow" day for ministers and a good day for mid-week religious lectures. It also allowed for a "bridge" day on Friday, creating what we now know as the four-day weekend. If it were on a Tuesday, the entire work week would be gutted. A Thursday holiday effectively shuts down the American economy for a long weekend of travel and leftovers, which is exactly how we like it.
Calculating Future Dates
If you're trying to plan way ahead, you can actually predict the date without a calendar. Since the earliest the fourth Thursday can fall is November 22nd and the latest is November 28th, you’re always looking at that final full week of the month.
- 2024: November 28
- 2025: November 27
- 2026: November 26
- 2027: November 25
If November 1st is a Friday, you’re going to have a "late" Thanksgiving. If November 1st is a Thursday, you’re eating turkey as early as humanly possible.
✨ Don't miss: January 14, 2026: Why This Wednesday Actually Matters More Than You Think
The Evolution of the Long Weekend
Because the date is always a Thursday, it has birthed a whole ecosystem of sub-holidays. We have Black Friday, Small Business Saturday, and Cyber Monday. There’s also "Green Wednesday" (the busiest day for dispensaries) and "Blackout Wednesday" (the biggest bar night of the year).
None of this would exist if the date moved to a Monday or a fixed calendar day. The "fourth Thursday" structure is essentially the heartbeat of the American retail and travel industry. AAA usually reports that over 50 million people hit the road during this specific window. It’s the most traveled time of the year, mostly because that Thursday-to-Sunday block is so predictable.
Common Misconceptions About the Date
A lot of people think the Pilgrims set the date. They didn't. In 1621, the "first" Thanksgiving was likely a three-day harvest festival held sometime between late September and early November. They didn't even have a set "day" for it annually. It was a sporadic religious observance.
Another big myth is that it’s the "last" Thursday. As we saw with the FDR debacle, people still get this confused. If you see a calendar where November has five Thursdays, remember: we celebrate on the fourth one, not the fifth. If you show up to a dinner party on the 30th of November when the 23rd was the fourth Thursday, you’re going to be eating cold leftovers by yourself.
Actionable Steps for Planning Your Next Thanksgiving
Knowing the "fourth Thursday" rule is great for trivia, but it’s more useful for your wallet. Here is how you can use this calendar quirk to your advantage:
- The "Six Month" Flight Rule: Since you now know the date will always be the 4th Thursday, don't wait for the holiday to appear on "top 10" lists to book travel. Set a Google Flights alert for the Wednesday before and the Sunday after exactly six months out.
- The "Fifth Thursday" Buffer: Check your calendar for years with five Thursdays (like 2029). These are the years where you actually have more time between Halloween and Thanksgiving to prep. Use that extra week for frozen turkey sales.
- Grocery Timing: The "Thursday" rule means grocery stores hit peak chaos on Tuesday afternoon. If you want to avoid the crowds, hit the store on the Sunday before the fourth Thursday. Most "loss leader" deals (like the 49-cent-per-pound turkeys) are already live by then.
- Confirming PTO: Don't assume your office knows the calendar. In years where November starts on a Friday or Saturday, people often miscalculate the 4th Thursday. Put your request in early using the specific date to avoid "scheduling conflicts" with coworkers who also want the long weekend.
While the history of is thanksgiving always the 4th thursday is full of political bickering and retail lobbying, the result is a rare bit of American stability. We know when the turkey is coming. We know when the parade starts. And we know exactly when we have to start bracing ourselves for the holiday shopping rush. Knowing the "why" behind the date just makes that first slice of pie taste a little more like a hard-won victory.