You’re standing in front of the fridge, parched. You reach for that cold, sweating can of seltzer because plain tap water feels like a chore, but then that nagging voice in the back of your head pipes up. Is sparkling water good for you, or are you just drinking "diet soda" in disguise? People have been arguing about this since the first bottle of Schweppes hit the shelves. Some folks swear it rots your teeth. Others claim it leaches calcium from your bones. Honestly, most of that is just leftover myth from the days when we didn't know better.
Carbonated water is basically just water with carbon dioxide gas dissolved into it under pressure. That’s it. Whether it's naturally occurring from a spring or forced in by a SodaStream in your kitchen, the chemistry is roughly the same. When $CO_2$ hits water, it creates a very weak acid called carbonic acid. This is what gives your tongue that slight "sting" or "bite." It’s also the source of almost every health rumor attached to the drink.
The Tooth Decay Debate: Does It Eat Your Enamel?
Let's talk about your teeth first because that's where people get the most freaked out. The logic seems sound: acid melts enamel, seltzer is acidic, therefore seltzer melts your teeth. But the scale of acidity matters immensely here.
Pure water has a neutral pH of around 7. Sparkling water usually sits somewhere between 3 and 4. While that sounds scary, it's nothing compared to a cola, which can drop down to a pH of 2.4. Research published by the American Dental Association (ADA) suggests that while sparkling water is slightly more "erosive" than plain water, it’s about 100 times less damaging than sugary soft drinks.
If you're drinking plain, unflavored sparkling water, your saliva actually does a great job of neutralizing the acid almost instantly. The real danger comes when you start sipping on the "lemon-lime" or "grapefruit" versions. Those citrus flavors often come from citric acid, which drops the pH even further.
Dr. Edmond Hewlett, a professor at the UCLA School of Dentistry, has noted that as long as you aren't sipping on flavored seltzer all day long without any breaks, your spit can remineralize your teeth faster than the bubbles can break them down. Basically, don't worry about the bubbles; worry about the "zest."
💡 You might also like: Supplements Bad for Liver: Why Your Health Kick Might Be Backfiring
The Bone Density Myth
There is a persistent old wives' tale that carbonation sucks the calcium right out of your bones. This probably started because of a 2006 study published in the American Journal of Clinical Nutrition which found that women who drank cola every day had lower bone mineral density.
Notice the keyword: cola.
The researchers didn't find that same link with other carbonated drinks. It turns out the culprit wasn't the bubbles at all—it was the phosphorus found in dark sodas. Phosphorus can interfere with calcium absorption if you aren't getting enough Vitamin D and calcium in your diet. Plain seltzer doesn't have phosphorus. It’s just water and air. You're safe. Your skeleton isn't going to turn into Swiss cheese because you like Perrier.
Digestion, Bloating, and the "Fullness" Factor
Ever feel like you’ve eaten a Thanksgiving dinner after drinking one can of LaCroix? That’s the gas. For some people, especially those with Irritable Bowel Syndrome (IBS), the extra air can cause genuine distress. It leads to burping, bloating, and that "heavy" feeling in the gut.
But for others? It’s a weight-loss miracle.
📖 Related: Sudafed PE and the Brand Name for Phenylephrine: Why the Name Matters More Than Ever
There's some evidence that sparkling water might keep food in your stomach slightly longer than still water. A small study involving young women found that carbonated water increased feelings of fullness more than plain water did. If you’re trying to stop snacking between lunch and dinner, a glass of bubbles might actually help you white-knuckle it through the afternoon.
The Weird Truth About Hunger Hormones
Okay, here is where it gets a bit nuanced. There was a study back in 2017 involving rats (and a very small group of humans) that suggested carbonated water might increase levels of ghrelin, the "hunger hormone." The idea was that the $CO_2$ gas triggers a release of ghrelin in the stomach lining, making you want to eat more.
Does this mean sparkling water makes you fat? No.
Most dietitians will tell you that the evidence in humans is still way too thin to make a definitive claim. If you find yourself raiding the pantry every time you crack a can of seltzer, maybe pay attention. But for the vast majority of us, the "fullness" effect of the gas usually outweighs any tiny spike in ghrelin.
Is Sparkling Water Good for Hydration?
Hydration is the whole point of drinking water, right? The U.S. National Academies of Sciences, Engineering, and Medicine doesn't differentiate between still and sparkling when it comes to meeting your daily fluid intake. Your body absorbs them exactly the same way.
👉 See also: Silicone Tape for Skin: Why It Actually Works for Scars (and When It Doesn't)
Some athletes actually prefer it. It feels more "refreshing." However, if you're doing an intense HIIT workout or running a marathon, the carbonation might make you feel too bloated to drink the volume of water you actually need. In those cases, flat water is king. But for sitting at your desk or going for a walk? It’s a perfect one-to-one replacement for the tap.
Identifying the "Hidden" Junk
Not all sparkling waters are created equal. You have to be a bit of a detective when you're looking at labels.
- Seltzer: Just water and $CO_2$. This is the gold standard.
- Club Soda: Water with added minerals like sodium bicarbonate or potassium sulfate. It’s meant to mimic the taste of natural mineral water. Usually totally fine, though watch the sodium if you have high blood pressure.
- Mineral Water: Comes from a natural spring and contains minerals like magnesium and calcium. Brands like Gerolsteiner or San Pellegrino fall here. This can actually be a decent source of electrolytes.
- Tonic Water: This is the "villain" of the group. It contains quinine for bitterness and a massive amount of sugar. A 12-ounce bottle of tonic water has about 32 grams of sugar—nearly as much as a Sprite. Do not treat tonic water like seltzer. It's soda.
Making the Best Choice for Your Routine
Is sparkling water good? Yeah, mostly. It’s a thousand times better than drinking a Coke, and it’s a great bridge for people who find plain water "boring."
If you want to be the healthiest version of a seltzer drinker, try these habits:
- Drink it with meals. This helps neutralize the acidity and protects your tooth enamel.
- Rinse with flat water. If you're drinking flavored seltzer, take a sip of regular water afterward to wash away the citric acid.
- Check for "Natural Flavors." This is a catch-all term. While usually harmless, some brands use sweeteners like stevia or erythritol which can cause digestive issues in some people.
- Avoid the "Cocktail" versions. Anything labeled "Sparkling Water Beverage" often contains sucralose or aspartame. Stick to the cans that list "Carbonated Water, Natural Flavors" and nothing else.
At the end of the day, the best water is the one you actually drink. If bubbles help you stay hydrated, keep popping those tabs. Just don't let it be the only thing you drink. Your teeth (and your stomach) will appreciate a little variety.
Next Steps for the Hydration Obsessed:
Check your favorite brand's label specifically for "Citric Acid." If it’s high on the list and you have sensitive teeth, consider switching to a plain mineral water and squeezing in real lime or adding a slice of cucumber. The pH of a DIY fruit infusion is often much less aggressive than the lab-created flavors found in the "essenced" cans. Also, try drinking through a straw if you’re nursing a seltzer over several hours; it keeps the acidic liquid away from your front teeth entirely.