Tim Allen is back in a garage. For anyone who spent nine seasons watching Mike Baxter navigate the trials of a male-dominated household and a corporate marketing job at Outdoor Man, the first look at his new project felt like a warm, familiar hug. Or maybe a case of déjà vu. The roar of an engine, the flannel shirts, the grunts—it’s all there. This has naturally led to a massive wave of confusion online. People are asking the same question over and over: is shifting gears a spin off of last man standing, or are we just seeing a spiritual successor?
The short answer is no. It’s not a spin-off.
But honestly, the long answer is a lot more interesting because of how TV works today. Shifting Gears is a brand-new multi-cam sitcom pilot for ABC. It stars Tim Allen as Matt, a widower who owns a classic car restoration shop. The premise kicks off when his estranged daughter and her kids move into his house. If that sounds like the "classic Tim Allen formula," that’s because it is. But Mike Baxter and Matt are officially two different people, living in two different fictional universes.
Why the Shifting Gears and Last Man Standing Connection is So Strong
It’s easy to see why the internet got turned around on this one. First, you have the network. Last Man Standing actually started its life on ABC before being canceled and famously resurrected by Fox. Now, Allen is returning "home" to ABC. Seeing him back on that specific channel, in a sitcom format, makes it feel like he never left the Baxter family behind.
Then there’s the character archetype. Tim Allen has built a career on playing the "man’s man" who is slightly bewildered by the modern world. In Home Improvement, he was Tim Taylor, the tool-obsessed dad. In Last Man Standing, he was Mike Baxter, the outdoor-obsessed dad. In Shifting Gears, he is Matt, the car-obsessed dad. He isn't playing Mike Baxter again, but he’s playing a character cut from the exact same cloth.
The supporting cast also fuels the fire. Shifting Gears stars Kat Dennings as Matt’s daughter, Riley. Dennings is a sitcom powerhouse in her own right (think 2 Broke Girls), and her presence gives the show a weight that most new pilots don't have. Because the show focuses on a father-daughter dynamic—much like Mike Baxter’s relationship with Mandy, Kristin, and Eve—the "spin-off" rumors were basically inevitable.
The Difference Between a Spin-Off and a Spiritual Successor
To understand why is shifting gears a spin off of last man standing is a "no," we have to look at the legalities. A spin-off requires shared intellectual property. For example, Young Sheldon is a spin-off of The Big Bang Theory because they share characters and a timeline.
📖 Related: Gwendoline Butler Dead in a Row: Why This 1957 Mystery Still Packs a Punch
Shifting Gears doesn't share anything with the Baxter family. There is no Vanessa Baxter (Nancy Travis), and there is no Outdoor Man. Instead, this show is what we call a "spiritual successor." It’s meant to appeal to the exact same demographic—people who miss the traditional, family-oriented multi-cam sitcom that doesn't shy away from "old school" perspectives.
ABC is looking for a hit. They know that Tim Allen brings a built-in audience of millions who followed him from ABC to Fox and then to Disney+ for The Santa Clauses. By putting him back in a garage, they are playing to his strengths. It’s a calculated move. It’s not a continuation of the old story; it’s a reboot of the vibe.
The Kat Dennings Factor
One of the biggest departures from the Last Man Standing formula is the casting of Kat Dennings. In Allen’s previous shows, the daughters were often there to be the "foil" to his conservative or traditional views. While Riley will likely do the same in Shifting Gears, Dennings brings a very specific type of dry, cynical wit that is different from the Baxter girls.
The plot revolves around Riley moving back home with her two teenage kids. This sets up a "grandpa versus the new generation" dynamic. We saw a bit of this with Mike Baxter and his grandson Boyd, but Shifting Gears seems poised to make this the central pillar of the show. It’s about a man who has spent his life fixing cars but realizes he can't "fix" his family with a wrench.
What Really Happened with the Production?
The development of Shifting Gears has been a bit of a rollercoaster. Originally, the pilot was written by Mike Scully and Julie Thacker Scully, both veterans of The Simpsons. However, in late 2024, news broke that they were departing the project as showrunners. This kind of creative shift during a pilot phase can be a red flag, but for a pro like Allen, it’s often just part of the "fine-tuning" process.
They are looking for the right "voice." If the show feels too much like Last Man Standing, it risks being called a derivative clone. If it feels too different, it risks alienating the fans who want to see Tim Allen being, well, Tim Allen.
👉 See also: Why ASAP Rocky F kin Problems Still Runs the Club Over a Decade Later
Why Google Discover is Obsessed with This Show
You might have noticed this show popping up in your feed constantly. That’s because Tim Allen is a lightning rod for engagement. He represents a specific type of television that has largely disappeared from streaming services: the "middle-America" sitcom. Whether you love his brand of humor or not, the data shows that people click on it.
When people search is shifting gears a spin off of last man standing, they aren't just looking for a yes or no. They are looking for a reason to watch. They want to know if the "magic" of the Baxter household is going to be present in this new car shop.
Factual Breakdown: Shifting Gears vs. Last Man Standing
If we look at the two shows side-by-side, the differences become clearer:
Setting the Scene
Last Man Standing was set in Denver, Colorado. Mike Baxter worked at a giant retail store. It was very "corporate outdoorsy."
Shifting Gears is centered on a classic car restoration shop. This is a more blue-collar, intimate setting. It’s more Home Improvement than Last Man Standing in that regard.
The Family Structure
Mike Baxter had a wife who was his intellectual equal and three daughters who were already mostly grown.
Matt in Shifting Gears is a widower. This is a massive shift in tone. A widower protagonist brings a level of pathos and vulnerability that Mike Baxter rarely had to show. Matt is lonely, even if he won't admit it. Riley isn't just visiting; she’s moving in because she has nowhere else to go. The stakes feel a bit more grounded and perhaps a bit more "real world" than the polished life of the Baxters.
The "Vibe"
Last Man Standing was famous for Mike Baxter’s "vlogs." They were a way for the character to speak directly to the audience about his frustrations with society. We don't know yet if Shifting Gears will have a similar "breaking the fourth wall" mechanic. Early reports suggest a more traditional narrative structure.
✨ Don't miss: Ashley My 600 Pound Life Now: What Really Happened to the Show’s Most Memorable Ashleys
Is it Worth Watching for LMS Fans?
Honestly? Yeah, probably. If you liked the banter and the "clash of cultures" in Last Man Standing, Shifting Gears is being built specifically for you. The creative team knows exactly who the audience is.
There’s a comfort in these types of shows. You know there will be a misunderstanding in the first act, a confrontation in the second, and a heartfelt realization over a car engine in the third. It’s "comfort food" TV. In a world of complex prestige dramas where everyone dies, there’s a huge market for a show where the biggest problem is a teenager's phone usage or a daughter’s new boyfriend.
What’s Next for the Series?
As of now, the pilot has been filmed and ABC is looking at the results. The buzz is strong, mostly due to the pairing of Allen and Dennings. If the show gets a full season order, expect a late 2025 or early 2026 premiere.
The industry is watching this closely. If Shifting Gears is a massive hit, it proves that the "old school" sitcom model still has legs in the era of TikTok and Netflix. It also proves that Tim Allen is one of the few remaining TV stars who can carry a show on his name alone.
Summary of Actionable Insights for Fans
If you're trying to stay ahead of the curve on this show, here is how you should approach it:
- Stop looking for Mike Baxter: If you go into Shifting Gears expecting a continuation of the Last Man Standing storyline, you’ll be disappointed. Treat it as a "multiverse" version of Tim Allen’s life.
- Watch the "Santa Clauses" on Disney+: If you want to see how Tim Allen handles "aging" characters in a modern setting, his recent work on the Santa Clause series is a good indicator of his current acting style.
- Follow Kat Dennings on Social Media: She is often more active in sharing "behind the scenes" glimpses than the older stars, and she’ll be the first to hint if the show gets picked up for a full season.
- Keep an eye on ABC’s Fall Schedule: Usually announced in May, this will be the moment we know for sure if Shifting Gears is a "go" or if it’s staying in the garage.
While the answer to is shifting gears a spin off of last man standing is a definitive no, the spirit of the show is very much a continuation of the brand Tim Allen has spent thirty years building. It’s about family, it’s about tools, and it’s about a man trying to find his place in a world that’s changing faster than he can keep up with.
Next Steps for You
To stay updated, you should set a Google Alert for "Shifting Gears ABC" to get the latest casting news. Additionally, if you haven't seen Kat Dennings' previous work, watching a few episodes of 2 Broke Girls will give you a great idea of the comedic energy she’ll be bringing to her scenes with Tim Allen. This contrast is going to be the "secret sauce" of the new show.