Is Shell Stock Still a Good Buy? What Most People Get Wrong About the Oil Giant

Is Shell Stock Still a Good Buy? What Most People Get Wrong About the Oil Giant

Let's get one thing out of the way immediately: Royal Dutch Shell doesn't technically exist anymore. In early 2022, the company ditched the "Royal Dutch" part of its name, moved its tax residence from the Netherlands to the UK, and became simply Shell PLC. It was a massive corporate shakeup that basically ended a dual-share structure that had been around since 1907. If you are looking for royal dutch shell stock, you are really looking for Shell (SHEL) on the London Stock Exchange or the NYSE.

Investors are still reeling from the 2020 dividend cut. It was the first time since World War II that the company slashed its payout. People felt betrayed. For decades, Shell was the "widows and orphans" stock—the safe bet that paid out no matter what. Then the pandemic hit, oil prices went negative for a hot minute, and the board hit the panic button. But here’s the thing: that reset might have been the best thing to happen to the company’s long-term balance sheet.

The Strategy Shift: More Than Just "Greenwashing"

You've probably heard the critics. They say Shell is just pretending to care about the energy transition while pumping more oil. It’s a messy reality. Under CEO Wael Sawan, the company has pivoted slightly back toward "value over volume." This means they aren't just chasing wind farms for the sake of looking green; they want projects that actually make money.

Money talks.

The company is funneling billions into Integrated Gas. This is their crown jewel. Liquified Natural Gas (LNG) is the bridge the world is using to get off coal, especially in Asia. Shell is currently the largest player in the global LNG trade outside of state-owned entities. If you think the world will need gas for the next thirty years—and most data from the International Energy Agency (IEA) suggests we will—then the investment case for royal dutch shell stock starts looking a lot more robust than just a "dying oil play."

Why the London Discount Persists

It’s weird. If you compare Shell to ExxonMobil or Chevron, Shell looks cheap. Like, really cheap. European energy companies consistently trade at lower price-to-earnings multiples than their American cousins. Why? Part of it is the "ESG discount." European institutional investors are way more sensitive to carbon footprints than Wall Street is.

There's also the "Windfall Tax" headache. The UK government has been poking the pockets of North Sea producers with the Energy Profits Levy. It creates a lot of uncertainty. Investors hate uncertainty. They’d rather buy a Texas-based driller where the regulatory environment feels like a warm hug.

✨ Don't miss: Getting a Mortgage on a 300k Home Without Overpaying

Dividends and Buybacks: The New Reality

Shell is buying back its own shares at a frantic pace. We are talking billions of dollars every quarter. For a shareholder, this is great because it reduces the total number of shares, making your slice of the pie bigger.

The dividend is growing again, too. It’s not back to the pre-2020 levels in absolute terms, but the yield is often sitting comfortably between 3% and 4%. Sawan has been very vocal about one thing: the share price is undervalued, and he’s going to use every spare cent of cash flow to prove it to the market.

  • Cash flow from operations remains staggering when oil is above $70.
  • Net debt has been slashed significantly over the last three years.
  • Shareholder distributions are now the top priority, even over aggressive renewables expansion.

The Massive Natural Gas Bet

Natural gas is Shell's secret weapon. While BP went all-in on renewables a few years back (and then sort of backed away), Shell kept its grip on the gas pipe. The invasion of Ukraine changed the energy map of Europe forever. Russian pipe gas is gone, and it isn't coming back anytime soon. That leaves a massive hole that LNG has to fill.

Shell’s Pearl GTL plant in Qatar is a marvel of engineering. It turns gas into liquid products like oils and detergents. It’s a cash machine. Most people focusing on royal dutch shell stock only look at the price of Brent crude, but they should really be watching the JKM (Japan Korea Marker) gas prices. That’s where the real alpha is hidden.

The Risk of Being "Too Big to Pivot"

It’s not all sunshine and dividends. Shell faces constant legal pressure. In 2021, a Dutch court ordered them to cut emissions faster than they planned. While Shell won the appeal in late 2024—a huge victory for the company—the legal blueprint for climate litigation is now out there.

There is also the execution risk. Transitioning a supermajor is like turning an aircraft carrier in a bathtub. If they move too fast into renewables, they destroy shareholder value by entering low-margin businesses. If they move too slow, they risk becoming a "stranded asset" play. It's a tightrope walk. Honestly, most of the management's time is probably spent trying not to fall off either side.

🔗 Read more: Class A Berkshire Hathaway Stock Price: Why $740,000 Is Only Half the Story

Reading the Financials: What to Look For

When you pull up the quarterly reports, ignore the "headline earnings." It's full of accounting noise and derivative movements. Look at the Adjusted Earnings and the Free Cash Flow.

In 2023 and 2024, Shell showed it could generate massive piles of cash even when oil wasn't at $100. Their break-even price—the price of oil they need to cover their dividends and capital spending—is now estimated to be below $50 a barrel. That provides a huge margin of safety. If oil stays in the $70-$80 range, they are basically printing money.

  1. Check the "Renewables and Energy Solutions" segment losses. They are still pouring money in, and it's not always profitable yet.
  2. Watch the "Marketing" segment. This is their gas station network and lubricants. It's a boring but incredibly stable business that provides a floor for the stock.
  3. Keep an eye on the buyback announcements. If they slow down, the stock price usually takes a hit.

What Most People Get Wrong

The biggest misconception is that Shell is an oil company. In reality, it's a massive global logistics and trading company that happens to deal in molecules. Their trading desk is legendary. When energy markets get volatile, Shell's traders make a killing. They have the infrastructure to move gas and oil to wherever the price is highest in real-time. You can't replicate that with a startup.

Another myth? That EV charging will kill them. Shell is actually one of the biggest builders of EV charging networks in Europe and China. They own ubitricity, a huge provider of on-street charging. They aren't fighting the transition; they are trying to own the "fueling" station of the future, whatever that fuel happens to be.

Technicals and Market Sentiment

As of early 2026, the sentiment around royal dutch shell stock is "cautiously optimistic." The "Drill, baby, drill" sentiment in the US has put pressure on global prices, but Shell’s diversified portfolio keeps it insulated.

The stock often tracks the FTSE 100 closely. If the UK economy is struggling, Shell often acts as a hedge because its earnings are primarily in US dollars. When the Pound is weak, Shell’s dollar-denominated earnings look even better for UK investors. It’s a classic currency play.

💡 You might also like: Getting a music business degree online: What most people get wrong about the industry

Actionable Insights for Investors

If you are looking at adding Shell to your portfolio, don't just "buy and forget." This is a cyclical beast.

  • Avoid buying at the peak of oil cycles. If everyone is talking about $120 oil, it's probably too late to get a good deal on SHEL.
  • Focus on the yield. If the dividend yield gets north of 5%, historical data suggests it's a strong "buy the dip" zone.
  • Diversify your energy exposure. Don't just hold Shell. Pair it with a US major like Exxon (XOM) or a pure-play renewable company to balance the geographic and regulatory risks.
  • Monitor the LNG market. Watch for new projects coming online in Qatar and the US, as these will dictate Shell's margins over the next decade.

Shell isn't the same company it was twenty years ago. It’s leaner, it’s more focused on gas, and it’s much more aggressive about returning cash to people who hold the shares. It’s a play on the messy, slow, and expensive reality of the global energy transition. It might not be the most exciting stock in the world, but in a volatile market, its "cash cow" status is hard to ignore.

The move from the Netherlands to London streamlined the company, but it didn't change the underlying assets. Those assets remain some of the most strategic in the world. Whether it's deepwater drilling in the Gulf of Mexico or massive gas projects in Australia, Shell is everywhere. For an investor, that global footprint is the ultimate insurance policy.

To track the progress, look at the upcoming Capital Markets Day presentations. That is where Sawan lays out the hard numbers for the next three to five years. If they stick to the "value over volume" mantra, the gap between Shell and its American peers might finally start to close. If it does, there's a lot of upside left in the tank.


Immediate Next Steps

Check the Current P/E Ratio: Compare Shell’s current forward P/E to its five-year average. If it’s trading significantly below 8x or 9x, it’s historically in the "value" territory.

Review the Latest Buyback Tranche: Shell usually announces buybacks in $3 billion to $3.5 billion chunks. Verify the status of the current program on their investor relations page to see how much support the stock has in the open market.

Assess Your Portfolio’s Energy Weighting: Most financial advisors suggest a 5% to 10% exposure to energy. If you are underweight, Shell offers a way to get global exposure without the specific risks of a single-country producer.