You’re standing in the beverage aisle. It’s a literal wall of neon cans. Lime, black cherry, hibiscus, and "pure." You grab a 12-pack because you're trying to quit soda, or maybe you just hate the taste of flat tap water. But then that nagging thought hits: Is this actually hydrating me, or am I just drinking fancy battery acid that’s going to melt my teeth? Honestly, the internet is a mess of conflicting takes on this. One person says it causes bone loss, another says it’s the holy grail of weight loss.
Let's get into it.
Is seltzer water good for you? The short answer is yes, mostly. But the nuance matters. If you’re swapping a Coke for a LaCroix, you’re winning. If you’re swapping all your regular water for carbonated water and you already have IBS, you might be in for a rough afternoon. Seltzer is basically just water with carbon dioxide gas dissolved into it under pressure. That’s it. No sugar, no phosphoric acid, no caffeine.
The Myth of the Melting Enamel
People worry about their teeth. It makes sense. Carbonation creates carbonic acid, which sounds terrifying. If you dropped a tooth into a vat of seltzer and left it there for a week, yeah, it wouldn't look great. But your mouth isn't a stagnant jar of acid. You have saliva.
Saliva is your body's secret weapon. It buffers the acidity. According to the American Dental Association (ADA), sparkling water is generally fine for your teeth as long as it doesn't have added sugars or citric acid. Pure seltzer has a pH of about 3 to 4, which is acidic, but plain old orange juice is way more aggressive on your enamel.
The real danger isn't the bubbles. It’s the "flavor."
If your seltzer has citric acid or "natural flavors" that lean heavily into citrus, the erosive potential ticks up. A study published in the Journal of the American Dental Association found that while plain sparkling water is minimally erosive, those flavored versions can be more like soda than we’d like to admit. Don't panic, though. You don't have to quit the lime flavor. Just don't swish it around your mouth like mouthwash. Drink it, enjoy it, and maybe have some plain water afterward to rinse.
Bone Density and the "Leaching" Scare
There’s this weirdly persistent myth that carbonation leaches calcium from your bones. This usually stems from a misunderstanding of the Framingham Osteoporosis Study. That study did find a link between cola consumption and lower bone mineral density in women.
📖 Related: Dr. Sharon Vila Wright: What You Should Know About the Houston OB-GYN
Note the keyword: Cola.
Colas contain phosphorus. Seltzer does not. It’s the phosphorus in sodas that interferes with calcium absorption, not the bubbles themselves. There is zero evidence that the $CO_2$ in your bubbly water is making your skeleton brittle. Dr. Robert Heaney, a bone health expert, has gone on record multiple times explaining that carbonated water has no effect on calcium excretion. So, you can breathe easy. Your spine is safe.
Digestion, Bloating, and the "Fullness" Factor
Here is where it gets a bit personal. Seltzer is a double-edged sword for your gut.
For some, it’s a miracle. Research in the European Journal of Gastroenterology & Hepatology showed that carbonated water can actually help with dyspepsia (indigestion) and constipation. The bubbles seem to stimulate the digestive tract.
For others? It’s a nightmare.
If you have Irritable Bowel Syndrome (IBS) or a sensitive stomach, that gas has to go somewhere. It leads to bloating. It leads to burping. It can even trigger acid reflux if you’re prone to it because the gas puts pressure on the lower esophageal sphincter.
"I have patients who swear by seltzer to settle their stomachs, and others who feel like a balloon about to pop after three sips," says Dr. Ayesha Akbar, a consultant gastroenterologist.
👉 See also: Why Meditation for Emotional Numbness is Harder (and Better) Than You Think
It’s also surprisingly good for weight management. Not because of some magical fat-burning chemical, but because of physics. The gas takes up space in your stomach. It makes you feel fuller, faster. A small study even suggested that sparkling water can increase the "fullness hormone" ghrelin in some people, though that research is still a bit controversial and mostly based on animal models. For humans, the benefit is usually just satiety. You drink a pint of bubbles before a meal, and you're probably not going to reach for seconds of lasagna.
Hydration vs. Plain Water
Is it as hydrating as regular water? Yes.
The National Academies of Sciences, Engineering, and Medicine doesn't distinguish between types of water when it comes to daily intake requirements. Your body absorbs the $H_2O$ molecules just the same, regardless of whether they’re hitching a ride on a carbon dioxide bubble.
However, there is a "chug-ability" factor. It’s much harder to chug a liter of seltzer than a liter of tap water. The carbonation forces you to sip. If you’re an athlete or someone working in 100-degree heat, stick to flat water or electrolytes. You need volume, and seltzer makes volume difficult.
The Dark Side: Added Stuff
We need to talk about what's not seltzer.
- Club Soda: Has added minerals like sodium bicarbonate or potassium sulfate. Good for flavor, but watch the sodium if you have high blood pressure.
- Tonic Water: This is basically soda. It has quinine and a massive amount of sugar (or high fructose corn syrup). Do not mistake tonic for seltzer.
- Mineral Water: Naturally carbonated from a spring. Brands like San Pellegrino or Perrier. These actually contain beneficial minerals like magnesium and calcium.
The "Natural Flavors" label is a black box. The FDA defines them loosely. Usually, they’re essences derived from plants, but "derived from" is doing a lot of heavy lifting. Most of the time, they’re harmless, but if you’re trying to be a purist, look for brands that use organic fruit extracts or just squeeze a real lemon into plain bubbly water.
PFAS and the "Forever Chemicals" Problem
In recent years, a new concern has bubbled up: PFAS.
✨ Don't miss: Images of Grief and Loss: Why We Look When It Hurts
In 2020, Consumer Reports tested several popular sparkling water brands and found measurable levels of these "forever chemicals" in some of them. Brands like Topo Chico (which hurts to say because it’s delicious) were found to have higher levels than others. Since then, many of these companies have updated their filtration processes.
If you're worried about long-term chemical exposure, check for brands that use advanced reverse osmosis or carbon filtration. It’s not a reason to stop drinking seltzer entirely, but it’s a reminder that even "pure" bottled products come from a manufacturing chain.
How to Drink Seltzer Like a Pro
If you want the benefits without the downsides, there’s a strategy to it.
First, stop drinking it through a straw. Straws introduce more air into your system, which compounds the bloating issue. Drink it straight from the glass or can.
Second, timing is everything. Drinking seltzer with food can actually help digestion for many people. Drinking it on a completely empty stomach might cause a spike in acidity for some.
Third, watch the temperature. Ice-cold seltzer holds its carbonation longer. If it gets warm, the $CO_2$ escapes faster, leaving you with that weird, metallic "flat" taste that nobody likes.
Actionable Steps for the Seltzer Addict
You don't need to give up your habit, but you should optimize it. Here is how you handle your seltzer intake for maximum health:
- Check the Ingredient List: If you see "Citric Acid" or "Sugar" or "Aspartame," recognize that you’re moving away from seltzer and toward "diet soda" territory.
- Prioritize Enamel Health: If you drink multiple cans a day, try to drink them during meal times rather than sipping one over a six-hour period. This limits the "acid attack" window on your teeth.
- Switch to Mineral Water for a Boost: If you can afford it, naturally carbonated mineral waters provide actual nutrients like magnesium and calcium that plain seltzer lacks.
- The "Flat" Test: If you find yourself constantly bloated, try switching to flat water for 48 hours. If the bloating vanishes, you know your GI tract just doesn't handle the gas well.
- DIY Carbonation: Consider a home carbonator. It allows you to control the water source (use filtered water to avoid PFAS) and avoids the waste of hundreds of aluminum cans.
Seltzer isn't a miracle cure, and it's not a poison. It’s a tool for hydration that happens to be a lot more fun than tap water. As long as you aren't replacing every single drop of plain water with citrus-heavy bubbles, you're doing just fine. Your teeth will stay in your head, and your bones will stay strong. Drink up.