People are obsessed with labels. Especially when it comes to Sabrina Carpenter. She’s the 5-foot-nothing powerhouse currently dominating every playlist, and with that level of fame comes the inevitable deep-dive into who she’s dating, what her lyrics mean, and whether she’s hinted at being part of the LGBTQ+ community.
Honestly, if you spend ten minutes on "Gaylor" TikTok or Twitter, you’ll see fans convinced she’s dropping "Easter eggs" about her identity. But is there any weight to the theory? Or is this just a classic case of fans projecting their own stories onto a pop star who’s just living her life?
The Lyrics That Started the Conversation
Let’s look at the music. That’s usually where the "is Sabrina Carpenter bisexual" questions start. In her 2024 album Short n' Sweet, she didn't shy away from being incredibly bold about her desires. Some fans pointed to the track "Slim Pickins," where she laments the dating pool and drops the line: "And since the Lord forgot my gay awakening / Then I'll just have to settle for this guy."
Is it a literal admission? Or just a sharp-tongued joke about how frustrating men can be?
She’s got a biting sense of humor. That’s her brand. In a June 2025 interview with Rolling Stone, she addressed the way people dissect her sexuality. She didn't give a "yes" or "no" answer. Instead, she laughed off the idea that her music is only about one thing. She basically told the world that while people fixate on the sexual "Juno" positions, she’s actually writing about human connection—which is messy for everyone.
Then there was the "Busy Woman" controversy. She released a bonus track with the lyric: "If you don't want me, I'll just deem you gay." That one didn't go over so well with everyone. Some saw it as a dated trope, while others felt it was just her signature campy, slightly bratty persona.
💡 You might also like: Kellyanne Conway Age: Why Her 59th Year Matters More Than Ever
Her History With "The Girls and the Gays"
Sabrina knows her audience. She has been a vocal ally for years. At the 2024 Governors Ball, she famously shouted out "People who hate Pride can suck my gov balls." She also performed at the 2025 VMAs with "In Trans We Trust" signage prominently displayed on stage.
She clearly cares about the community. But being an ally and being part of the community are two different things.
Why the speculation persists:
- Past Interviews: Back in the Girl Meets World days, she once told an interviewer, "We appreciate the male gender, as well as the female."
- The "Vibe": There’s a specific "camp" energy to her performances. Think the vintage Madonna vibes at the VMAs or her constant references to 90s starlets.
- The Friendships: Her close bond with fellow stars like Rowan Blanchard (who is queer) led many to assume Sabrina was on a similar journey of public self-discovery.
But let’s be real. Sabrina has a very public dating history that, so far, has focused entirely on men.
A Look at Her Relationship Timeline
If we’re going by the "who has she actually dated" metric, the list is pretty clear.
- Bradley Steven Perry: Her first big Disney-era romance.
- Griffin Gluck: Her co-star from Tall Girl.
- Joshua Bassett: The relationship that launched a thousand "Driver's License" theories.
- Shawn Mendes: A brief, low-key fling in 2023.
- Barry Keoghan: The Saltburn star who famously appeared in her "Please Please Please" video.
As of early 2026, reports suggest she and Keoghan split toward the end of 2024, and she’s recently been spotted with a "mysterious blonde man" at Soho Farmhouse. Notice a pattern? It’s a lot of men.
📖 Related: Melissa Gilbert and Timothy Busfield: What Really Happened Behind the Scenes
Does this mean she couldn't be bisexual? Of course not. But it does mean she hasn't confirmed a relationship with a woman, and she hasn't explicitly used the label for herself.
The Problem With the "Queerbaiting" Accusations
Some critics have accused her of "queerbaiting"—using LGBTQ+ aesthetics to sell records without actually being queer. This is a heavy word to throw around.
In a 2025 profile, Sabrina noted that she feels "mad pressure to be funny" and that her lyrics are often hyperbolic. If she says the Lord forgot her gay awakening, it might just be her way of saying she’s tired of "men who don't know the difference between 'there,' 'their,' and 'they're'" (shoutout to "Slim Pickins").
We have to allow artists to be tongue-in-cheek without demanding a signed affidavit about their orientation. Sexuality is a spectrum. Maybe she’s still figuring it out. Maybe she knows exactly who she is and just doesn't feel like sharing that specific part of herself with millions of strangers.
What Sabrina Has Actually Said
In 2025, she gave us the most clarity we're likely to get for a while. She told Popstar! Magazine that navigating fame as a young woman is "tricky."
👉 See also: Jeremy Renner Accident Recovery: What Really Happened Behind the Scenes
She said, "It's always so funny to me when people complain... Clearly you love sex. You're obsessed with it." She wasn't just talking about her lyrics. She was talking about our collective obsession with who she’s sleeping with.
She hasn't come out as bisexual. She hasn't claimed the label "straight" either. She’s just... Sabrina. She’s 26, successful, and seemingly more interested in her "superpower" of performing than in checking a box on a census form.
Moving Forward: How to Follow the Story
If you're looking for a definitive "yes" or "no," you aren't going to find it yet. And that's okay. The best way to understand Sabrina's stance on identity is to watch her actions.
- Watch the Lyrics: She writes her own music. If her identity shifts or she chooses to share more, it’ll be in the songs first.
- Ignore the "Leaked" Reports: Unless it comes from her or a major outlet like Rolling Stone or Variety, it's usually just fan fiction.
- Focus on the Allyship: She has proven that she’ll stand up for the LGBTQ+ community regardless of her own label. That’s arguably more important than a public "coming out" moment.
Ultimately, speculating on someone’s sexuality is a bit of a parasocial rabbit hole. Whether she’s bisexual or just a very funny, very frustrated straight woman, her impact on pop culture remains the same. She’s making music for people who feel a lot, love a lot, and occasionally want to tell their ex to suck it.
Actionable Insights:
- Follow her official social media: She often uses her "Nonsense" outros to address rumors or current events in real-time.
- Listen to "Short n' Sweet" and "Man's Best Friend": These albums contain the most personal reflections on her dating life and gender dynamics.
- Respect the boundaries: Support her music and her advocacy, but remember that her private life belongs to her until she decides otherwise.