Walk into any boutique fitness studio and you’ll see people shaking. Their muscles are quivering, sweat is dripping off their noses onto the carriage of a Reformer, and they look like they’ve just run a marathon. But if you check their heart rate monitor, it might only show 110 beats per minute. So, is Pilates cardio or strength? Honestly, it’s a bit of a trick question.
People love boxes. We want to put our workouts into neat little categories like "this is for my heart" or "this is for my muscles." Joseph Pilates, the creator of the method, didn't really care about those categories. He called his system "Contrology." It was about complete coordination of body, mind, and spirit.
If you’re looking for a simple "yes" or "node," you’re going to be disappointed. It's both. And neither. Sorta.
The Muscle Myth: Is Pilates Actually Strength Training?
When we think of strength training, we usually think of a guy named Chad lifting a 400-pound barbell until his face turns purple. That’s hypertrophy training. Pilates isn't that. But if we define strength as the ability of a muscle to exert force against resistance, then Pilates is absolutely strength training.
In a mat class, your resistance is gravity and your own body weight. On a Reformer, Cadillac, or Wunda Chair, the resistance comes from springs. These springs are sneaky. Unlike a dumbbell, where the weight stays the same throughout the movement, spring resistance increases as the spring stretches. This creates a unique type of "eccentric" load. You're strengthening the muscle while it's lengthening.
Research published in the Journal of Strength and Conditioning Research has shown that consistent Pilates practice significantly improves abdominal strength and upper body muscular endurance. You aren't just getting "toned"—a word fitness marketing loves but which basically just means building muscle and losing fat—you are fundamentally changing how your motor units fire.
It's deep strength. It's the kind of strength that helps you carry all the grocery bags in one trip without blowing out your lower back.
💡 You might also like: Can DayQuil Be Taken At Night: What Happens If You Skip NyQuil
Let’s Talk About the Heart: The Cardio Debate
Now, let's address the elephant in the room. Most people think "cardio" means huffing and puffing on a treadmill. Technically, cardiovascular exercise is any activity that increases your heart rate and respiration while using large muscle groups repetitively.
Does Pilates do this?
Well, it depends on how you play the game. If you’re doing a classical, slow-paced Mat level 1 class, your heart rate probably won't stay in the aerobic zone for long. You're focusing on precision. You're breathing deeply, but you aren't exactly sprinting.
However, things change when you move into "Jumpboard" classes or high-intensity Reformer flows. A study by the American Council on Exercise (ACE) found that an advanced Pilates workout can burn about 7.5 calories per minute. That’s comparable to a brisk walk or a light jog. It’s not "sprinting uphill" cardio, but it definitely hits the mark for low-impact aerobic activity.
There’s also the "flow" factor. In advanced Pilates, there are no breaks. You move from the Hundred directly into the Roll Up, then the Roll Over, then the Single Leg Stretch. By the time you’re ten minutes in, your heart is pumping because your body has no time to recover. It’s a steady-state cardio effect disguised as a core workout.
Why the "Long and Lean" Marketing is Kinda Misleading
You've seen the ads. They promise that Pilates will give you "long, lean muscles."
📖 Related: Nuts Are Keto Friendly (Usually), But These 3 Mistakes Will Kick You Out Of Ketosis
Science check: You cannot change the actual length of your muscles. Your muscle attachments are fixed to your bones. Unless you’re getting some very questionable surgery, your muscles are staying the same length.
What Pilates actually does is improve your posture and eccentric strength. When you strengthen your core, you stand taller. When you're not slumped over a desk like a gargoyle, you look longer and leaner. It’s an optical illusion backed by better biomechanics.
The Resistance Factor: Springs vs. Weights
- Dumbbells: Gravity pulls them down. The hardest part of the move is usually at the bottom or the middle.
- Springs: The further you push, the harder they fight back. This forces your muscles to stabilize in ways that free weights just don't.
- The "Core" Focus: In weightlifting, the core is often a secondary stabilizer. In Pilates, the core (the "Powerhouse") is the initiator of every single movement.
Is Pilates Enough on Its Own?
This is where I might lose some hardcore Pilates enthusiasts, but we have to be honest. If your goal is to run a sub-4-hour marathon or compete in a bodybuilding show, Pilates alone won't get you there.
It's the ultimate "support" workout.
Professional athletes—like LeBron James or various NFL players—use Pilates because it fixes the imbalances created by their primary sport. If you only do cardio (running), your hip flexors get tight and your glutes might get "lazy." Pilates wakes those glutes up. If you only lift heavy, your range of motion might decrease. Pilates keeps you mobile.
For the average person just trying to stay healthy? Yes, you can get away with just Pilates, provided you are doing high-intensity sessions at least three times a week and maybe throwing in a long walk on the off days. But for optimal bone density, especially as we age, some form of heavy-ish resistance (whether that's heavy springs or actual weights) is pretty much non-negotiable.
👉 See also: That Time a Doctor With Measles Treating Kids Sparked a Massive Health Crisis
The Verdict: How to Categorize It
If you forced me to pick, I’d say Pilates is 70% strength and 30% cardio. It’s a functional strength system that prioritizes the health of the spine. The "cardio" part is a happy byproduct of moving your body through complex patterns without stopping.
Think of it this way:
- Strength: It builds endurance in the deep stabilizing muscles (transverse abdominis, multifidus, pelvic floor).
- Cardio: It improves circulatory efficiency through specific breathing patterns (lateral costal breathing).
How to Get the Most Out of Your Sessions
If you want more "strength" out of your Pilates, you need to increase the resistance. On a Reformer, don't be afraid of the heavy springs for leg work. On the mat, slow down. The slower you go, the less momentum you use, and the more your muscles have to work.
If you want more "cardio," look for "Contemporary" Pilates studios. They often incorporate HIIT (High-Intensity Interval Training) elements, jumpboards, or faster transitions.
Actionable Next Steps for Your Fitness Routine
- Assess Your Current Mix: If you already run 20 miles a week, look for a "Stretch and Restore" or "Classical" Pilates class. You don't need more cardio; you need the structural alignment and core stability.
- Frequency Matters: To see the strength benefits, you need to show up. Twice a week is maintenance; three to four times a week is where the transformation happens.
- Focus on the "Exhale": In Pilates, the breath is what engages the deep core. If you aren't breathing correctly, you're just doing calisthenics. Exhale on the effort.
- Don't Skip the Mat: People think the Reformer is "harder" because of the springs, but mat work is often more difficult because there’s nothing to help you. Try a 20-minute advanced mat flow and tell me your heart isn't racing.
- Mix in Heavy Loads: If you’re over 40, try to pair your Pilates with one or two days of dedicated weight training to keep your bones strong. Pilates is great for muscles and joints, but the skeleton loves a bit of heavy loading.
Stop worrying about whether it's "cardio" or "strength." Your body doesn't actually know the difference; it only knows stress and recovery. Pilates provides a high-quality stress that builds a resilient, functional body that won't break down when you're 80. That’s worth more than a high calorie-burn number on a watch anyway.