You’re standing in the aisle, or more likely scrolling through a targeted Instagram ad, and you see them. Sleek, black, surprisingly thin briefs that claim they can replace your tampons and pads forever. It sounds like magic. But then you remember a headline from a couple of years ago. Something about lawsuits. Something about "forever chemicals." You start wondering: is period underwear safe, or are we just trading one toxic product for another?
Honestly, the answer isn’t a simple yes or no. It's more of a "yes, but you need to know what you’re buying."
For decades, the period industry was a stagnant pool of plastic applicators and bleached cotton. Then came the disruption. Brands like Thinx, Knix, and Modibodi promised a world with less waste and more comfort. But as the popularity of these products exploded, so did the scrutiny. We’re going to get into the weeds of PFAS, silver treatments, and vaginal health because your body deserves more than a marketing slogan.
The PFAS Elephant in the Room
Let's talk about the big scare first. If you've been googling "is period underwear safe," you’ve definitely seen the acronym PFAS.
PFAS stands for per- and polyfluoroalkyl substances. They’re a group of thousands of synthetic chemicals used to make things water-resistant, stain-resistant, and non-stick. Think Teflon or Scotchgard. In period underwear, they were used to ensure the moisture-wicking layer didn’t leak through to your jeans.
The problem? They’re called "forever chemicals" because they don't break down in the environment or your body.
Back in 2020, an environmental health professor at the University of Notre Dame, Graham Peaslee, tested Thinx underwear and found high levels of fluorine, which is a marker for PFAS. This sparked a massive class-action lawsuit. People were rightly furious. You buy these products to be healthier and more eco-friendly, not to expose your most absorbent skin to chemicals linked to kidney cancer, thyroid disease, and decreased fertility.
Thinx eventually settled that lawsuit in 2023, though they denied any wrongdoing. They’ve since tightened their manufacturing processes. But the lesson remained: just because a brand says they are "organic" doesn't mean the technical layers are clean.
Beyond the Chemicals: What About Bacteria?
Chemistry isn't the only concern. Biology is just as loud.
💡 You might also like: Images of Grief and Loss: Why We Look When It Hurts
Think about the environment of period underwear. It’s warm. It’s dark. It’s moist. Basically, it's a five-star resort for bacteria and yeast. If you’re wearing the same pair of underwear for 12 hours, and that underwear is holding blood against your skin, you’re naturally going to worry about infections.
Most brands handle this by adding an antimicrobial treatment. Often, this is silver or copper.
Silver ions are incredibly effective at killing microbes. They puncture the cell walls of bacteria and stop them from reproducing. Sounds great, right? Well, some gynecologists are skeptical. Your vagina has a delicate microbiome—a balance of "good" bacteria like Lactobacillus that keeps everything acidic and healthy. There is a theoretical risk that if silver ions migrate from the fabric to your skin, they could disrupt that balance, leading to yeast infections or bacterial vaginosis (BV).
However, real-world data on this is sparse. Dr. Jen Gunter, a well-known OB-GYN and author of The Vagina Bible, has noted that while the risk of silver migration is a valid question, we don't have definitive studies showing that period underwear causes more infections than traditional pads. In fact, many people find that period underwear is more breathable than plastic-backed disposable pads, which can cause significant chafing and "diaper rash" style irritation.
How to Tell if a Brand is Actually Safe
You shouldn't have to be a chemist to buy underwear. But since the industry isn't strictly regulated like medical devices, you have to do a little homework.
Look for the OEKO-TEX Standard 100 certification. This is a third-party label that tests for hundreds of harmful substances, including PFAS, formaldehyde, and heavy metals. If a brand doesn't have this, or a similar certification like bluesign®, take their "non-toxic" claims with a grain of salt.
Another thing to check is the fabric composition.
- Cotton and Merino Wool: These are the gold standards for the layer touching your skin. They are naturally breathable and less likely to cause irritation.
- Synthetic blends (Polyester/Nylon): Usually found in the outer leak-proof layers. These are fine, provided they aren't treated with "durable water repellent" (DWR) coatings that contain PFAS.
- The Gusset: This is the "pad" part. It’s usually a sandwich of several layers. Ask the brand: what is the antimicrobial agent? If they use "nanosilver," be aware that nanoparticles are more likely to migrate into your body than larger silver particles.
The Reality of All-Day Wear
Is period underwear safe for 24-hour use? No. Not even if the capacity says it can hold five tampons' worth of blood.
📖 Related: Why the Ginger and Lemon Shot Actually Works (And Why It Might Not)
Hygiene is the user's responsibility. If you feel damp, change them. Period. Most experts recommend changing your period underwear at least as often as you would a high-capacity pad. For many, that's every 8 to 12 hours. If you have a heavy flow and try to push a pair for a full day, you aren't just risking a leak; you're risking skin irritation. Blood starts to break down, and the pH of your vulvar skin can shift.
It’s also about the wash. You can’t just throw these in with your jeans and hope for the best.
Blood contains proteins that "set" in heat. To keep them safe and hygienic, you need to rinse them in cold water until the water runs clear, then wash on a delicate cycle. Never use fabric softener. Softener coats the fibers in a waxy film that actually destroys the absorbency and can trap bacteria inside the fabric. If your underwear starts to smell even after a wash, that’s a sign of "bacterial buildup," and it's time to do a vinegar soak or reconsider that specific brand's durability.
Comparing the Risks: Period Underwear vs. The Rest
To answer "is period underwear safe," we have to ask: "compared to what?"
- Tampons: These carry a small but real risk of Toxic Shock Syndrome (TSS). They can also cause micro-tears in the vaginal wall and often contain trace amounts of dioxins from the bleaching process.
- Disposable Pads: These are often 90% plastic. They aren't breathable and can lead to contact dermatitis. Plus, the adhesives and fragrances are common allergens.
- Menstrual Cups: Generally very safe, but they require internal insertion and a learning curve. There’s a very slight risk of TSS if left in too long.
When you look at it that way, period underwear is actually a very low-risk option for most people. It’s external. It doesn't involve sticking anything into your cervix. It doesn't use the same level of harsh plastics found in a Stayfree pad.
The Environmental Win
We can't talk about safety without talking about the planet. An average person uses about 11,000 disposable period products in their lifetime. Those end up in landfills or, worse, the ocean.
If a pair of period underwear lasts you two to three years, you are preventing hundreds of pieces of plastic from entering the ecosystem. While this is an "environmental safety" point, it circles back to human health. Microplastics are now being found in human placentas and bloodstreams. Reducing our reliance on single-use plastics is a long-term health play for everyone.
Common Misconceptions That Scare People Off
"They're just diapers."
Actually, modern tech is wild. Some brands are as thin as regular Hanes. You don't get that "crinkle" sound when you walk, and the silhouette is usually pretty invisible under leggings.
👉 See also: How to Eat Chia Seeds Water: What Most People Get Wrong
"They smell bad."
If they smell, something is wrong. Either the antimicrobial layer has failed, or you've left them in a damp gym bag for three days. Fresh period underwear, even when "full," shouldn't have a pungent odor because the blood is wicked away from the surface and dried into the inner layers.
"You'll get a rash."
This usually happens if you’re allergic to the synthetic materials or if the underwear is too tight. Friction + moisture = rash. Finding the right fit is crucial.
Summary of Actionable Safety Steps
If you're ready to make the switch but want to stay on the safe side, follow these rules.
First, ignore the "influencer" brands that don't list their testing data. Stick to established names that explicitly state they are PFAS-free and have third-party lab results to prove it. Brands like Period. (that's the name), Saalt, and Modibodi have been very transparent about their testing since the Thinx controversy.
Second, start slow. Wear them at home on a Sunday. See how your skin reacts. Do you feel itchy? Do you feel wet? If your skin is sensitive, look for brands that use organic cotton as the top layer.
Third, have a rotation. You need enough pairs to allow for thorough washing and air-drying. Putting on a pair that is still slightly damp from the wash is a fast track to a fungal infection.
Lastly, listen to your body. If you start getting recurring BV or yeast infections after switching, your specific microbiome might not play nice with the antimicrobial treatments. Everyone's chemistry is different. What works for your best friend might not work for you.
The Bottom Line
Is period underwear safe? Yes. For the vast majority of people, they are a healthy, comfortable, and revolutionary way to manage a period. The "scary" chemicals are largely being phased out due to consumer pressure, and the biological risks are minimal if you practice good hygiene.
Stop settling for itchy plastic pads. Buy a pair from a reputable, certified brand, wash them properly, and enjoy the fact that you aren't contributing to a mountain of landfill waste every month. Just remember: rinse cold, skip the softener, and check for that OEKO-TEX label. Your body will thank you.
Next Steps for Your Health:
- Check your current period underwear brand's website for their PFAS testing results.
- Look for the OEKO-TEX Standard 100 certification on the packaging of any new pairs you buy.
- Audit your laundry routine: switch to a "free and clear" detergent and ditch the fabric softeners to maintain the fabric's integrity.