Manhattan real estate is a graveyard of things we used to love. If you lived in New York anytime between 1973 and 2020, you probably knew the logo. It was everywhere. Those red, white, and blue circles. The nautical flags. The New York Health and Racket Club wasn't just a place to lift weights or sweat through a spin class; it was a bona fide institution of the city's social fabric. Then, it just stopped.
The story of the New York Health and Racket Club is a messy blend of luxury, gym culture, and a sudden, painful collision with a global pandemic.
When people talk about NYHRC today, they usually sound a bit nostalgic. They remember the saltwater pools. They remember the squash courts and the mahogany-heavy locker rooms that felt more like a 1980s boardroom than a place to change your socks. It felt permanent. But in New York, "permanent" is usually just a lease that hasn't expired yet.
The Rise of a Manhattan Icon
Founded in 1973 by Fred Stallman, the New York Health and Racket Club was a pioneer. You have to understand that back then, the concept of a "health club" was still sort of new. Most guys were lifting heavy things in dingy basements, and the idea of a high-end, multi-sport facility in the middle of Midtown was revolutionary.
Stallman didn't just want a gym. He wanted a club.
He focused on what he called the "total person." This meant you weren't just paying for a treadmill. You were paying for access to a 75-foot yacht. Honestly, that was the ultimate NYHRC flex. For decades, members could hop on the Kimberly for sunset cruises around Manhattan. It was ridiculous. It was over-the-top. It was exactly what New Yorkers wanted in the 80s and 90s.
The club expanded aggressively. At its peak, there were locations scattered across prime real estate—23rd Street, 13th Street, 50th Street, 56th Street, and Whitehall. They dominated the landscape before Equinox became a lifestyle brand and before Barry’s Bootcamp made everyone do sprints until they puked. NYHRC was the old guard.
What Actually Happened in 2020
The end wasn't a slow fade. It was a cliff.
When the COVID-19 pandemic hit in March 2020, every gym in New York City was forced to shutter. We all thought it would be a few weeks. Maybe a month. But for the New York Health and Racket Club, the doors never really opened again. By the time the city allowed gyms to resume operations in late 2020, NYHRC remained dark.
👉 See also: The Gospel of Matthew: What Most People Get Wrong About the First Book of the New Testament
Rumors flew. Members were ghosted.
If you were a member back then, you likely remember the confusion. People were still being charged dues while the buildings were locked. Then came the emails—or rather, the lack of them. Eventually, it became clear that the business wasn't just struggling; it was folding.
Life Time, the massive national luxury gym chain, eventually stepped in to take over several of the former NYHRC leases. The locations at 23rd Street, 62nd Street, and even the iconic 13th Street spot were swallowed up. They were renovated, modernized, and stripped of that weirdly charming, slightly dated NYHRC aesthetic.
Why the New York Health and Racket Club Felt Different
Most modern gyms feel like a nightclub or a hospital. They are either neon and loud or white and clinical. NYHRC was... cozy? That’s probably the wrong word for a gym, but it fits.
The Famous "Vibe"
- The Saltwater Pools: While every other gym had chlorine that burned your eyes, NYHRC bragged about their saltwater filtration.
- The Wood Paneling: Walking into the 56th Street location felt like walking into a library where people happened to be wearing spandex.
- Squash Culture: They kept the "Racket" in the name alive long after most clubs moved toward Zumba.
- The Yacht: Seriously, the yacht. It’s hard to overstate how much that single perk defined their brand.
The club catered to a specific New York demographic. It was the place where you’d see a hedge fund manager playing squash against a school teacher. It wasn't as pretentious as some of the high-end boutiques that replaced it, but it certainly wasn't a budget gym. It occupied a middle ground that basically doesn't exist anymore in Manhattan's "premium or nothing" economy.
The Reality of the Business Model
Why did it fail when others survived?
It’s complicated. Real estate in Manhattan is the ultimate predator. The New York Health and Racket Club sat on some of the most valuable dirt in the world. When you have thousands of square feet dedicated to squash courts and pools—things that don't generate "per square foot" revenue like a row of 50 treadmills—the math starts to get ugly.
Stallman’s passing in the early 2010s also shifted the leadership. Running an independent, family-owned chain against the venture-capital-backed might of Equinox or the massive scale of Life Time is a losing battle. The pandemic was just the final shove.
✨ Don't miss: God Willing and the Creek Don't Rise: The True Story Behind the Phrase Most People Get Wrong
A Look at the Current Locations (The Aftermath)
If you go to these addresses today, you won’t see the flags.
The 23rd Street location is now a Life Time. It’s beautiful. It’s got all the bells and whistles. But if you talk to the old-timers, they’ll tell you it isn't the same. The "club" aspect has been replaced by "efficiency."
The 13th Street location in Greenwich Village—once a cornerstone of the neighborhood—underwent a massive transformation. It’s still a place to work out, but the history is effectively painted over.
There were attempts to save parts of the brand. Some members tried to organize. There were lawsuits over unrefunded dues. It was a messy divorce between a city and one of its favorite legacy brands.
Can You Still Join?
The short answer is no.
The New York Health and Racket Club as a functioning entity is gone. There are some remnants in the digital space, and you might still find an old website or social media page that hasn't been updated in years, but the membership offices are closed.
If you are looking for that specific NYHRC experience, you have to piece it together. You go to Life Time for the luxury, or you find a dedicated squash club if that was your thing. But the "all-in-one" lifestyle that included a boat ride and a saltwater swim in Midtown? That’s a wrap.
The Lasting Legacy
We should care about the disappearance of places like this because they represent a version of New York that is being slowly erased. A version where things weren't perfectly polished.
🔗 Read more: Kiko Japanese Restaurant Plantation: Why This Local Spot Still Wins the Sushi Game
The New York Health and Racket Club wasn't perfect. The equipment was sometimes old. The locker rooms could be a bit musty. But it had character. It felt like a neighborhood spot in a city that is increasingly becoming a collection of global brands.
It also served as a lesson for the fitness industry. You can't just sell gym equipment; you have to sell community. When the gym closed, people didn't just miss the weights—they missed the people. They missed the routine.
Actionable Steps for Former Members and New Seekers
If you’re still holding onto a membership card or looking for a replacement, here is the current state of play.
1. Check for Unclaimed Funds
If you were a member during the 2020 shutdown and never got your dues back, check the New York State Comptroller’s Office for unclaimed funds. Many gym refunds were eventually processed through state channels after the business liquidated.
2. Evaluate the "New" Options
If you loved the Greenwich Village or 23rd Street locations, visit the Life Time clubs that replaced them. They often offer "legacy" tours for former NYHRC members to show how they’ve updated the space. Be prepared for a much higher price tag, though.
3. Find Your Sport
Since NYHRC was one of the few places with decent squash courts, former players should look toward the University Club (if you can get in) or specialized spots like Manhattan Squash. The "Racket" part of the fitness world has largely moved to dedicated boutiques.
4. Embrace the Boutique Era
If it was the social aspect you craved, look into social-heavy gyms like Chelsea Piers Fitness. They’ve inherited a bit of that "multi-sport/lifestyle" DNA that NYHRC pioneered back in the 70s.
The New York Health and Racket Club is a reminder that in Manhattan, even the giants can fall. It was a 47-year run that defined an era of fitness. Now, it’s just another piece of New York lore, filed away next to the Stage Deli and the original Yankee Stadium. Use the memory of the club to find a place that actually values the social connection of fitness, because as we saw in 2020, the equipment is the least important part of the equation.