You're driving out East, the windows are down, and the air starts smelling less like highway exhaust and more like salt. You pass through the manicured hedges of Southampton and the $50 million estates of East Hampton. Then, the road stretches out. The trees get scrubbier. The land gets thinner. You hit the "Stretch" at Napeague, and suddenly, you’re at the end of the world. Or at least, the end of the island.
This is where the debate starts.
People love to argue about whether is montauk the hamptons or something else entirely. If you ask a real estate agent, they’ll say "yes" before you even finish the sentence because it pads the property value. If you ask a local surfer who’s been hitting Ditch Plains since the 70s, they might give you a dirty look and tell you Montauk is the "un-Hamptons."
Honestly? They’re both right. It’s a bit complicated.
The Boring Legal Answer vs. The Real Vibe
Technically, yes. Geographically and politically, Montauk is a hamlet within the Town of East Hampton. It’s part of that cluster of villages and hamlets on the South Fork of Long Island that everyone collectively calls "The Hamptons." It's the caboose on the train.
But if you’ve spent five minutes in Bridgehampton and five minutes at the Montauk Lighthouse, you know they aren't the same.
📖 Related: Doylestown things to do that aren't just the Mercer Museum
The Hamptons—the "real" ones like Southampton and Quogue—are about old-school prestige. Think starch-white linen, perfectly manicured lawns, and high-end galleries. Montauk? It’s historically a fishing village. It’s rugged. It’s got "The End" tattooed on its soul. It’s where the pavement literally runs out and turns into the Atlantic Ocean.
Why the "Is Montauk the Hamptons" Question Matters
For years, Montauk was the blue-collar escape. While the rich were sipping rosé in Sagaponack, the fishermen were grabbing beers at the Shagwong Tavern. It was a place for people who didn't want to be seen.
Then the 2010s happened.
The opening of The Surf Lodge in 2008 basically changed everything. Suddenly, the "laid-back" vibe became a brand. The "un-Hamptons" became the hippest part of the Hamptons. Now, you’ve got the same crowds from Manhattan, just wearing $300 "distressed" trucker hats instead of loafers.
The Real Differences You'll Feel
- The Architecture: In the Hamptons, you see massive shingle-style "cottages" (that are actually 12,000-square-foot mansions). In Montauk, you find mid-century motels, A-frames, and those weirdly charming Tudor-style buildings in the village center—a remnant of Carl Fisher’s failed 1920s dream to make Montauk the "Miami of the North."
- The Water: Most of the Hamptons is about the bays or the flat, sandy ocean beaches. Montauk has cliffs. It has rocks. It has the best surf break on the East Coast at Ditch Plains.
- The Nightlife: In East Hampton, nightlife is often a private dinner party at a gated estate. In Montauk, it’s a public "scene." Places like Ruschmeyer’s or Crow’s Nest are where people go to see and be seen. It's louder. It's younger.
Is it Cheaper? (Spoiler: No)
There was a time when you’d go to Montauk to save a buck. Those days are dead.
👉 See also: Deer Ridge Resort TN: Why Gatlinburg’s Best View Is Actually in Bent Creek
While the median home price in Southampton might still dwarf Montauk because of the sheer scale of the estates, the price per square foot in Montauk has absolutely exploded. According to recent real estate data from 2024 and 2025, even a small "Leisurama" cottage (those tiny pre-fab homes from the 60s) can fetch millions.
Gurney’s Montauk Resort & Seawater Spa is one of the most expensive stays in the country. You aren't "roughing it" here anymore, even if the vibe tries to convince you otherwise.
The Celebrity Factor
If you want to spot Jerry Seinfeld or Beyoncé, you stay in East Hampton. If you want to spot Paul Simon, Julianne Moore, or Robert De Niro, you head to Montauk.
Montauk attracts a different kind of famous person. It’s the "I want to walk my dog in peace" kind of famous, not the "I’m hosting a red-carpet fundraiser" kind of famous. Though, with the influx of influencers and TikTokers over the last few years, that line is getting pretty blurry.
What You Should Actually Do
If you’re trying to decide where to spend your weekend, don’t get hung up on the labels.
✨ Don't miss: Clima en Las Vegas: Lo que nadie te dice sobre sobrevivir al desierto
Go to the Hamptons if: You want world-class shopping on Main Street, quiet luxury, and a high-end dining scene where you need a reservation three weeks in advance for a Tuesday night.
Go to Montauk if: You want to hike the bluffs at Camp Hero, watch the sun set over Fort Pond Bay with a drink in your hand, and don't mind a little more grit with your glamour.
A Few Must-Visit Spots That Define the "Montauk" Identity:
- The Lighthouse: It’s the oldest in New York. You have to do it once.
- Ditch Plains: Even if you don’t surf, the energy here is the heart of the town.
- Gosman’s Dock: A bit touristy? Sure. But it’s the link to the town’s commercial fishing roots.
- Deep Hollow Ranch: The oldest working cattle ranch in the US. Yes, in Montauk.
The Verdict
So, is montauk the hamptons?
Legally, yes. Culturally, it’s the Hamptons’ rebellious younger sibling who moved out, started surfing, and now charges everyone $25 for a cocktail just to prove a point. It’s part of the same ecosystem, but it breathes different air.
To truly understand the difference, you have to drive all the way to the end of Route 27. When you can’t go any further without driving into the Atlantic, you’ll know you’re in Montauk. And you’ll know it doesn’t feel like anywhere else.
Actionable Next Steps
- Check the LIRR schedule: If you're visiting in the summer, take the Cannonball express train to avoid the "trade parade" traffic on Route 27.
- Book early: If you want a spot at Gurney's or even a decent Airbnb in Montauk for July, you should have booked it six months ago.
- Visit in the "Second Summer": Go in September. The water is still warm, the crowds are gone, and the "Is this the Hamptons?" debate finally quiets down enough for you to enjoy the view.