You probably recognize Mikey Day from his frantic, high-energy sketches on Saturday Night Live or as the guy who cuts into realistic-looking shoes on Netflix's Is It Cake? but when it comes to his personal life, things are a lot quieter. For years, fans have been asking the same question: is Mikey Day married?
The answer used to be a little complicated, but as of very recently, it’s a definitive yes.
Honestly, it’s kind of refreshing. In an era where every celebrity wedding is a three-day Instagram extravaganza with sponsored floral arrangements, Mikey Day and his long-time partner, Paula Christensen, kept everyone guessing for over a decade. They didn't feel the need to rush to an altar just because they had a kid or a mortgage. They just... lived their lives.
The Big Update: Mikey Day and Paula Christensen Finally Tied the Knot
For the longest time, if you Googled this, you’d find articles calling Paula his "partner" or "longtime girlfriend." They were the ultimate "if it ain't broke, don't fix it" couple.
But things changed recently. Mikey Day married Paula Christensen in late 2024. It wasn't some massive Hollywood gala at a vineyard. According to several reports, the couple opted for a low-key Christmas Eve ceremony at City Hall. It makes sense for them. After being together for roughly 14 years, a massive wedding probably felt a bit redundant. They already had the life, the kid, and the career partnership. The paperwork was just the final touch.
Who is Paula Christensen?
She isn't just "the wife." Paula is a powerhouse in her own right. Born in Buenos Aires, Argentina, she moved to the U.S. when she was just a toddler. She's a talented actress and producer with a resume that includes spots on Modern Family, The Other Two, and Abbott Elementary.
👉 See also: Rosalynn Carter: What Most People Get Wrong About Her Age and Legacy
The two of them actually have a lot in common professionally. They both cut their teeth at The Groundlings, the legendary improv theater in Los Angeles. If you’re a comedy nerd, you know that place is basically the Navy SEAL training ground for SNL cast members. It’s highly likely they met through that scene, or at least bonded over the shared trauma of trying to make a room full of strangers laugh at 10:00 PM on a Tuesday.
That Time He Dated Selma Blair
Before Paula, there was a brief period where Mikey was in a very public relationship with Selma Blair. They met back in 2008 on the set of the U.S. version of Kath & Kim.
It lasted about two years.
While they were a "thing" in the tabloids for a minute, it’s clear that Mikey prefers the more private life he’s built since then. You won't find him posting "Woman Crush Wednesday" posts every week. He’s more likely to post a photo of a weird prop from the SNL set or a shot of his son.
The Real Star of the Family: Abbott Day
If you’re a die-hard SNL fan, you’ve actually seen Mikey's son, Abbott, before. He was born in August 2012, which means he’s well into his "tween" years now.
Abbott became a bit of a breakout star during the "SNL at Home" episodes during the pandemic. Remember those? When the cast had to film sketches in their apartments using iPhones and whatever wigs they had in their closets?
- Abbott appeared in the "Children's Clothing Ad" sketch.
- He played the "menacing child YouTuber" who pranks his dad.
- He even voiced characters in some of the animated segments.
Mikey has joked in interviews—specifically with Romper—that he basically had to bribe Abbott to be in those sketches. Since professional child actors weren't exactly an option during lockdown, Abbott was in high demand. His "payment"? Apparently, whatever he wanted off Amazon. That's a pretty sweet gig for a kid.
Why the "Married" Question Kept Trending
The confusion about Mikey Day being married persisted for so long because the couple was so casual about their labels. Paula would post throwback photos on Instagram with captions like "Still feel this way about you," but they weren't wearing rings.
💡 You might also like: Sabrina Carpenter Perfume Pink: What Most People Get Wrong
In Hollywood, people usually get married after six months and divorced after two years. Seeing a couple stay together for nearly 15 years without a marriage license was an anomaly. People assumed they must be married, or they assumed there was some secret drama.
The truth was just boringly healthy: they were happy, and they were busy. Between Mikey’s grueling schedule at Studio 8H—where he’s now one of the longest-tenured cast members—and Paula’s own acting and producing career, planning a wedding was probably at the bottom of the to-do list for a decade.
Actionable Takeaways for Fans
If you're following Mikey Day's career or just curious about how he balances a high-stress job with a stable family life, here is what you need to know:
- Check the Credits: Paula Christensen is often working on the same types of projects. Keep an eye out for her name in guest spots on sitcoms; she’s incredibly funny.
- Watch the Background: If you see a kid in an SNL sketch who looks suspiciously like a mini-Mikey, it’s probably Abbott. He’s been making cameos since 2019.
- Respect the Privacy: Unlike some of his costars who end up in the "Page Six" gossip columns, Mikey and Paula keep a tight lid on their home life. If you want updates, your best bet is following Paula's Instagram, as she's slightly more active there than Mikey.
- Don't believe old Wikis: Many sites still list them as "partners." As of their 2024 ceremony, they are officially husband and wife.
The story of Mikey Day and Paula Christensen is a nice reminder that you don't have to follow the traditional celebrity blueprint to have a successful relationship in the spotlight. They did it their way, on their own timeline, and they seem a lot happier for it.