You’ve heard the advice a thousand times. Carry a gallon jug. Set an alarm on your phone. Chug until your pee is clear. We’ve been conditioned to think that hydration is a math problem where the only variable is H2O. But honestly, if you’re asking is just drinking water healthy, the answer is a lot more complicated than a simple "yes."
Water is essential. Obviously. But gulping down massive amounts of plain water without considering what else your body is losing—or what it’s not getting—can actually backfire. Sometimes, it makes you feel worse.
Think about it. Have you ever downed a liter of water because you felt thirsty, only to feel even more parched twenty minutes later? Or maybe you felt "sloshy" and tired? That’s not a lack of discipline. It’s biology. Your cells don't just need wetness; they need a specific chemical balance to actually absorb that liquid. If you’re just flushing your system with distilled or heavily filtered tap water, you might be unintentionally stripping your body of the very minerals that keep your heart beating and your muscles moving.
The Problem With the "Just Water" Philosophy
The human body is basically a salty ocean contained within skin. When we talk about hydration, we’re really talking about fluid balance. This balance is governed by electrolytes—sodium, potassium, magnesium, and calcium.
When you ask is just drinking water healthy, you have to look at what happens when you drink too much of it in isolation. There’s a medical condition called hyponatremia. It’s rare for the average person, but it happens to marathon runners and "water enthusiasts" all the time. Essentially, you drink so much plain water that you dilute the sodium in your blood. Your cells start to swell. In extreme cases, your brain can swell.
On a less dramatic level, most of us are just walking around slightly "waterlogged" but cellularly dehydrated.
Take a look at the work of Dr. Stacy Sims, a renowned exercise physiologist. She’s spent years arguing that "plain water" isn't the most effective way to hydrate, especially for active people. She points out that the gut needs a little bit of glucose (sugar) and sodium to activate the "sodium-glucose cotransport" system. This is the biological "door" that allows water to move from your intestines into your bloodstream. Without that tiny bit of salt and sugar, the water just sits there. Then it goes straight to your bladder. You aren't hydrated; you're just a filter.
What's Actually in Your Tap?
Not all water is created equal. Depending on where you live, your water might be "hard" or "soft." Hard water, like what you find in parts of the Southwest U.S. or the UK, is naturally high in calcium and magnesium. In this case, is just drinking water healthy? It's probably better than in a city with "soft" water where those minerals are stripped out.
But then we have the filtration issue.
Reverse osmosis (RO) filters are incredible at removing lead, arsenic, and PFAS (the "forever chemicals"). They are a godsend for safety. However, they are too good. They remove every single trace mineral. If you are drinking RO water all day, you are essentially drinking "hungry" water. It wants to bond with minerals, so it can actually pull them from your body as it passes through.
A study published in the journal Nutrients highlighted that chronically consuming demineralized water can lead to deficiencies in magnesium and calcium. These aren't just minor details. Magnesium is responsible for over 300 biochemical reactions in your body. If your water isn't providing it, and your diet is lacking, you’re going to feel it in your sleep quality, your stress levels, and your muscle recovery.
The Fruit and Veggie Factor (Eating Your Water)
We often forget that humans didn't evolve with 40-ounce stainless steel tumblers glued to our hands. Our ancestors got a huge chunk of their hydration from food.
- Cucumbers are 95% water.
- Watermelon is 92% water.
- Strawberries are about 91% water.
This is "structured water" or "gel water." Dr. Dana Cohen, author of the book Quench, argues that this type of hydration is actually superior to plain liquid. Why? Because it’s packed with fiber and nutrients that slow down the absorption. This allows your body to actually use the water rather than just peeing it out. Plus, the natural salts in these plants act as a built-in electrolyte kit.
If you’re wondering is just drinking water healthy when you aren't eating many fresh plants, the answer leans toward "no." You're missing the synergistic effect of how nature intended us to stay hydrated.
The Mineral Gap
Let's get real about sodium. We've been told for decades that salt is the enemy. But for hydration? It's the MVP.
When you sweat, you aren't just losing water. You’re losing salt. If you replace that sweat with only plain water, you’re thinning out your blood’s electrolyte concentration. This is why you get those "dehydration headaches" even after drinking three glasses of water. Your brain is screaming for salt, not more H2O.
👉 See also: Painful spots on bum: Why it hurts to sit and what’s actually going on down there
A quick breakdown of what you're actually missing:
- Magnesium: Found in pumpkin seeds and dark chocolate, but often filtered out of water. It helps you relax.
- Potassium: It counters sodium. It’s in bananas and avocados. Most people are chronically low on this.
- Sodium: It holds the water in your blood vessels so your blood pressure doesn't tank.
If you're drinking "just water" while on a low-carb or keto diet, you’re at an even higher risk. Low-carb diets cause the kidneys to dump sodium at an accelerated rate. This is the primary cause of the "keto flu." It’s not a virus; it’s just a massive electrolyte imbalance because people think they can survive on plain water alone.
How to Make Water "Healthier"
So, does this mean you should stop drinking water? Of course not. That’s insane. But you should stop drinking just plain, dead, filtered water if you want to feel your best.
You can "re-mineralize" your life pretty easily.
Add a pinch of sea salt. Not the bleached, iodized table salt. Use Celtic sea salt or Himalayan pink salt. These contain dozens of trace minerals. You don’t need enough to make it taste like the ocean; just a tiny pinch in your morning glass is enough to help your cells grab onto the moisture.
Lemon or lime. This isn't just for flavor. Citrus adds potassium and helps alkalize the body (at least in terms of urine pH, which is a whole other debate).
Trace mineral drops. You can buy concentrated mineral liquids. A few drops in a gallon of RO water turns it from "dead" water back into something resembling a mountain spring.
Coconut water. If you’ve had a hard workout, skip the neon-colored sports drinks filled with Blue #1. Coconut water is basically nature’s IV bag. It’s incredibly high in potassium.
The Bio-Individuality of Thirst
The "eight glasses a day" rule is a total myth. It was based on a 1945 recommendation that people ignored the second half of: "most of this quantity is contained in prepared foods."
If you’re a 200-pound construction worker in Texas, you might need two gallons of water plus a massive amount of salt. If you’re a 120-pound office worker in Seattle who eats a lot of soup and salad, three glasses of water might be plenty.
Listen to your body. Is your mouth dry? Are you focused? Is your urine the color of pale straw? That’s the goal. If it’s crystal clear and you’re running to the bathroom every 30 minutes, you are over-hydrating with plain water. You are essentially washing your internal nutrients down the drain.
Actionable Steps for Better Hydration
Stop obsessing over the volume and start focusing on the quality and timing.
- The Morning Salt Trick: Start your day with 12 ounces of water and a tiny pinch of sea salt. This replenishes what you lost during respiration while you slept.
- Filter and Refill: If you use a Brita or RO system, add minerals back in. Whether it's a drop of concentrate or just eating a mineral-rich diet, don't let the water be "empty."
- Eat Your Fluids: Include a high-water-content fruit or vegetable with every meal. A side of berries or a few slices of cucumber goes a long way.
- Watch the Caffeine: Coffee is a mild diuretic, but the real issue is that it often replaces water intake. For every cup of coffee, have a glass of mineralized water.
- Don't Chug: Your body can only absorb about 20–27 ounces of water per hour. If you chug a liter in five minutes, most of it is going straight to your bladder. Sip consistently instead.
Is just drinking water healthy? It’s a foundation, but it’s not the whole house. To truly be hydrated, you need the minerals that tell the water where to go. Without them, you’re just passing through. Focus on the balance, add a little salt, eat your veggies, and stop worrying about hitting an arbitrary gallon goal every day. Your cells will thank you.