If you’re looking for a simple "yes" or "no" answer, you're probably going to be disappointed. The question of whether Jerusalem is in Palestine is one of the most explosive, deeply felt, and legally complex debates on the planet. Honestly, it depends entirely on who you ask, which map you’re looking at, and which international body’s resolution you’re reading.
It’s messy.
Geographically, the city sits on a plateau in the Judaean Mountains between the Mediterranean and the Dead Sea. But geography is the easy part. The politics? That’s where things get heavy. To some, Jerusalem is the eternal, undivided capital of Israel. To others, East Jerusalem is the occupied capital of the State of Palestine.
The International Tug-of-War
Most of the world doesn't recognize unilateral claims over the city. Since the 1947 UN Partition Plan (Resolution 181), the United Nations has technically viewed Jerusalem as a corpus separatum—a "separate entity" meant to be under international regime.
That didn't happen.
Instead, wars broke out. By the time the dust settled after the 1948 Arab-Israeli War, the city was sliced in half. Israel held the West, and Jordan held the East. This "Green Line" became the de facto border for nearly two decades. Everything changed in 1967. During the Six-Day War, Israel captured East Jerusalem from Jordan and later effectively annexed it.
Most countries still consider East Jerusalem to be occupied territory. When people ask "is Jerusalem in Palestine," they are often referring to the international consensus that views East Jerusalem as part of the Palestinian territories. The UN Security Council has passed numerous resolutions, such as Resolution 478, which condemned Israel's 1980 "Jerusalem Law" declaring the city the "complete and united" capital.
What Life Actually Looks Like on the Ground
If you walk through the Old City today, you aren't seeing borders or checkpoints between "Israel" and "Palestine." It feels like one bustling, ancient, and often tense metropolis.
Palestinians living in East Jerusalem—about 350,000 to 400,000 people—generally hold "permanent residency" status rather than Israeli citizenship. They pay Israeli taxes and receive some services, but they can't vote in national elections. They use Jordanian passports or travel documents. It’s a strange, limbo-like existence.
They consider themselves Palestinians living in a Palestinian city under occupation.
Meanwhile, Israel has built several large neighborhoods (often called settlements by the international community) in the eastern sectors. Places like Gilo or Ramat Eshkol are home to hundreds of thousands of Israelis. To the Israeli government, these are just neighborhoods of their capital. To the Palestinian Authority and the UN, these are illegal obstacles to peace located on Palestinian land.
The Religious Weight
Why does everyone care so much? It’s the holiness.
You have the Temple Mount, known to Muslims as the Haram al-Sharif. It houses the Al-Aqsa Mosque and the Dome of the Rock. It is the third holiest site in Islam. Directly below it is the Western Wall, the holiest place where Jews can pray, being a remnant of the Second Temple.
- Muslim Perspective: Jerusalem (Al-Quds) is central to the Palestinian national identity. The Al-Aqsa compound is a symbol of their presence and their future statehood.
- Jewish Perspective: Jerusalem (Yerushalayim) has been the heart of the Jewish faith for 3,000 years. It’s mentioned hundreds of times in the Hebrew Bible.
- Christian Perspective: The Church of the Holy Sepulchre marks where many believe Jesus was crucified and buried.
This spiritual overlap makes a political compromise feel like a betrayal of God to some.
The Shift in US Policy
For decades, the United States stayed somewhat neutral on the final status of Jerusalem, arguing it must be decided through negotiations. That shifted in 2017.
The Trump administration formally recognized Jerusalem as the capital of Israel and moved the US embassy there from Tel Aviv. This was a massive win for the Israeli government and a devastating blow to Palestinian leadership, who saw it as the US abandoning its role as a "fair mediator." While the Biden administration hasn't moved the embassy back, they have re-emphasized support for a two-state solution where Jerusalem’s status is eventually mutually agreed upon.
Is Jerusalem in Palestine? The Semantic Divide
If you look at a map produced by the Palestinian Authority, Jerusalem is the capital of Palestine. If you look at an Israeli map, it’s the undivided capital of Israel.
The Palestinian Declaration of Independence in 1988 named Jerusalem as its capital. Today, over 130 countries recognize the State of Palestine, and most of those recognize East Jerusalem as its capital. However, the Palestinian government lacks "sovereign control" over the city. They don't control the borders, the police, or the municipal planning.
💡 You might also like: Chinese Newspaper in English: Why Most People Get It Wrong
Israel exercises full "de facto" control.
This is why the answer is so polarized. If you define a country by who has the military and administrative power, the answer leans one way. If you define it by international law, historical claims, and the right to self-determination for the indigenous population, the answer leans the other.
Why "East" vs "West" Matters
We talk about East Jerusalem as the "Palestinian" part, but it’s not just a neighborhood. It includes the entire Old City. That means the Holy Sepulchre, the Western Wall, and Al-Aqsa are all technically in the area the international community considers occupied Palestinian territory.
The "West" is almost universally recognized as Israeli.
The friction arises because Israel argues that a divided Jerusalem simply doesn't work. They point to the period between 1948 and 1967 when Jews were barred from their holy sites in the East. Palestinians argue that without East Jerusalem as their sovereign capital, a Palestinian state is geographically and economically impossible.
Actionable Steps for Understanding the Conflict
Getting a grip on this topic requires moving past headlines. To truly understand the status of Jerusalem, you should look into these specific areas:
- Read the 1947 Partition Plan: Look at the original UN maps to see how the world initially envisioned the city.
- Study the 1993 Oslo Accords: These agreements specifically deferred the "Jerusalem question" to "final status negotiations" which have yet to be successfully completed.
- Follow Local News: Sources like Haaretz (Israeli left-leaning), The Jerusalem Post (Israeli right-leaning), and Al Jazeera or Wafa (Palestinian/Regional perspectives) will show you the daily reality of property disputes and archaeological excavations that fuel the fire.
- Examine the "Jerusalem Master Plan": Look at how the city municipality plans for the future. You’ll see how zoning laws and infrastructure projects are used as tools for demographic influence.
- Acknowledge the Human Element: Understand that for the people living there, this isn't a "keyword" or a "debate." It’s where they buy bread, where they pray, and where they fear losing their homes.
Jerusalem remains a "city of two tales." It is simultaneously the seat of the Israeli government and the heart of the Palestinian dream for independence. Until a final status agreement is reached, it will continue to exist in this complex, contested space between two nations.