You’re exhausted. It’s 3:15 AM, your coffee from yesterday is still sitting cold on the counter, and the tiny human in the bassinet is screaming at a decibel level that seems physically impossible for someone who weighs eight pounds. You’ve changed the diaper. You’ve offered the breast or bottle. You’ve checked for hair tourniquets on toes. Everything is fine, yet the wailing continues. In that moment of sheer, bone-deep fatigue, the question hits you: Is it ok to let a newborn cry? Maybe just for five minutes? Maybe while you step into the hallway to breathe?
The short answer is nuanced. The long answer involves a crash course in infant neurology and the way human stress responses develop. Honestly, there’s a massive difference between "giving yourself a minute to regulate" and "sleep training."
When we talk about newborns—typically defined as infants from birth to about 3 or 4 months—we are talking about a stage of development where the brain is essentially an external womb. They can't self-soothe. They don't have the neurological hardware to "calm down" on their own. So, while you aren't going to "break" your baby by putting them down in a safe space for a few minutes to regain your sanity, letting a newborn cry for extended periods without a response is generally advised against by every major pediatric organization.
The biology of a newborn's scream
Newborns don't cry to manipulate you. They literally can't. The prefrontal cortex—the part of the brain that handles logic, reasoning, and "if I cry, Mom will give me that toy"—is barely online. When a newborn cries, it is a biological reflex. It's their only way to communicate a survival need.
Dr. Darcia Narvaez, a researcher at the University of Notre Dame, has spent years studying how early experiences shape the developing brain. Her research suggests that when a baby’s needs are met consistently, it sets the "vagal tone," which is basically the body’s internal thermostat for stress. If a baby is left to cry for long periods, their system gets flooded with cortisol. Because they don't have the capacity to lower that cortisol themselves, they eventually stop crying not because they are "soothed," but because of a physiological shutdown response. It's a conservation of energy.
Why "Crying It Out" doesn't apply yet
You’ve probably heard of the Ferber Method or Weissbluth. These are popular sleep training techniques. But here’s the thing: even the staunchest advocates of these methods, like Dr. Richard Ferber himself, typically say you should wait until a baby is at least 4 to 6 months old.
📖 Related: Why the 45 degree angle bench is the missing link for your upper chest
Why? Because before that, the baby’s circadian rhythm hasn't fully formed. Their stomach is the size of a large walnut. They need to eat. They need the physical proximity to regulate their own heart rate and temperature. If you’re asking is it ok to let a newborn cry as part of a "sleep training" regimen at six weeks old, the medical consensus is a firm no.
When it is actually okay (and necessary) to walk away
Let’s be real for a second. Parenting is hard. Sometimes it feels like the walls are closing in. If you feel your frustration rising to a point where you might shake the baby or react out of anger, you must put the baby down.
In this specific context, yes, it is okay to let the newborn cry.
Place them on their back in a safe crib or bassinet. Close the door. Go to the kitchen. Drink a glass of water. Call a friend. The American Academy of Pediatrics (AAP) actually emphasizes this in their shaken baby syndrome prevention materials. A baby crying in a safe crib is much safer than a baby being held by a parent who has reached their breaking point. Ten minutes of crying while you collect your thoughts will not cause long-term psychological trauma. It's a safety reset.
The "Fourth Trimester" reality
We often forget that humans are born "early" compared to other mammals. A foal can walk within hours of birth. A human infant can’t even hold its own head up. This period is often called the Fourth Trimester.
👉 See also: The Truth Behind RFK Autism Destroys Families Claims and the Science of Neurodiversity
During this time, the baby expects to be held 24/7. In many cultures around the world, the concept of "letting a baby cry" is non-existent because the baby is literally strapped to an adult all day. We’ve built a modern society where we expect newborns to lie still in a plastic tub in a dark room and be quiet. That’s a tall order for a creature that just spent nine months in a warm, loud, vibrating environment with a constant food supply.
Understanding "Purple Crying"
Sometimes, you do everything right and they still cry. This is what experts call the Period of PURPLE Crying. It usually starts around 2 weeks of age and can last until about 3 or 4 months.
- Peak of crying (more each week, peaking at month 2).
- Unexpected (starts and stops for no reason).
- Resists soothing.
- Pain-like face (even if they aren't in pain).
- Long-lasting (can go on for 5 hours a day).
- Evening (the dreaded "witching hour").
If you’re in the middle of this, you aren't doing anything wrong. The baby isn't "bad." This is a developmental phase. In these moments, it’s about "being with" the cry rather than trying to "fix" it. If you’ve held them, rocked them, and checked their needs, and they are still screaming, it’s okay to just hold them and let them get it out. You are providing a "secure base," even if they aren't quieting down immediately.
The impact on the brain and attachment
There is a lot of fear-mongering online about "permanent brain damage" from crying. Let's dial that back. Science shows that what matters most is the overall pattern of care.
If a parent is generally responsive, warm, and attentive, a few instances of the baby crying for 15 minutes because the parent was in the shower or stuck in traffic aren't going to result in an insecure attachment style. Attachment is built over thousands of small interactions. It’s the "serve and return" relationship that the Harvard Center on the Developing Child talks about. You respond to their "serve" (a cry, a look, a coo), and that builds neural pathways.
✨ Don't miss: Medicine Ball Set With Rack: What Your Home Gym Is Actually Missing
The danger is "toxic stress." This happens when a child experiences frequent, prolonged, or severe adversity—such as chronic neglect—without adequate adult support. A newborn crying because they are being sleep-trained too early or ignored for hours on end can fall into this category. But a baby crying while you're warming up a bottle? That’s just life.
How to handle the crying without losing your mind
If you’re struggling with the question of is it ok to let a newborn cry, you likely need some practical strategies to bridge the gap between "responding to every whim" and "ignoring the baby."
- The 5-Minute Rule: If you’re overwhelmed, set a timer. Put the baby down, walk away for five minutes. Often, just knowing there is an "end" to your break helps you reset.
- Check the basics, then pivot: Hungry? Wet? Hot? Cold? If the answers are no, try a sensory shift. Step outside into the cold air. Put them in a lukewarm bath. The change in temperature often "breaks" the crying cycle.
- Use white noise: Newborns are used to the sound of blood rushing through the placenta, which is louder than a vacuum cleaner. Silence is actually stressful for them.
- Lower your expectations: Your only job right now is keeping the human alive and keeping yourself sane. The laundry can wait. The "thank you" notes for baby gifts can wait.
Final thoughts on newborn distress
Ultimately, your instinct to respond is there for a reason. Evolutionarily, a baby who didn't cry didn't get fed, and a parent who didn't respond didn't pass on their genes.
It is okay to let a newborn cry for short durations when you are attending to your own basic needs or when you are feeling emotionally dysregulated. It is not recommended to let a newborn cry it out for the purpose of teaching them to sleep or "toughening them up." They simply aren't ready for those lessons yet.
Give yourself some grace. This stage is temporary. It feels like an eternity when you're in it, but by month four or five, their brain will have changed enough that you can start looking at more formal sleep boundaries. For now, if they’re crying and you’ve got the capacity, pick them up. If you’re at your limit, put them down safely and take a breath.
Actionable Next Steps
- Audit your support system: If you find yourself asking if it’s okay to let the baby cry because you are physically unable to hold them anymore, you need a break. Reach out to a neighbor, friend, or partner to take over for two hours today.
- Track the "Witching Hour": Start noticing if the crying happens at the same time every day. Most newborns have a fussy period between 4 PM and 8 PM. Knowing it's coming can help you prepare mentally.
- Talk to your pediatrician: If the crying seems excessive (more than 3 hours a day), rule out reflux or a cow's milk protein allergy. Sometimes "crying it out" isn't a behavioral issue, but a medical one.
- Invest in a good baby carrier: Many newborns stop crying the second they feel the pressure of being "worn." It keeps them close but gives you your hands back so you can at least make a sandwich.