We all remember that specific corner of the internet back in 2020. People were losing their absolute minds over videos of sneakers, onions, and rolls of toilet paper being sliced open with a chef's knife to reveal layers of sponge and buttercream. It was a weird time. But when Netflix decided to take that specific "hyper-realistic cake" trend and turn it into a high-stakes competition, nobody really knew if it would land or just feel like a dated meme. Honestly, Is It Cake Season 1 ended up being a massive hit because it leaned into the absurdity of the premise while showcasing some genuinely mind-blowing artistry.
It's simple. Too simple, maybe.
Host Mikey Day, who you probably know from Saturday Night Live, spends most of his time roaming the set with a large knife, looking slightly unhinged, and hacking at random objects. The core of the show involves a group of incredibly talented bakers trying to fool a panel of celebrity judges. If the judges can't tell the difference between a real gym bag and a cake gym bag from several feet away, the baker wins money. It’s low-stakes drama that feels high-stakes because the craftsmanship is so intense.
The Contestants Who Carried Is It Cake Season 1
The show wouldn't have worked without the right personalities. You had Andrew Fuller, who has this sort of Tim Burton aesthetic and a penchant for the macabre. Then there was April Julian, whose precision was honestly terrifying at times. These weren't just "hobbyists" making birthday cakes for their nephews; these were world-class sugar artists who understood the physics of light, shadow, and texture.
Take the "Fast Food" challenge.
Think about how hard it is to make a piece of cake look like a greasy, translucent piece of pepperoni or a wilted lettuce leaf. It’s about the "gloss." If the cake is too matte, the human eye knows it's bread. If it’s too shiny, it looks like plastic. Finding that middle ground where a judge's brain short-circuits is where the magic happened in season one.
Andrew Fuller eventually took home the big prize, but the path there was filled with some genuinely controversial moments. Remember the "taco" incident? Some fans felt the judges were being a bit too lenient, or perhaps the lighting on the set made everything look a bit too "cakey." That's the thing about this show—it's highly subjective. What looks like a leather boot to one person looks like chocolate ganache to another.
💡 You might also like: Are U Coming to the Tree: The Hunger Games Song That Became a Viral Anthem
Why We Couldn't Stop Watching
The pacing was chaotic.
Mikey Day's energy is a love-it-or-hate-it situation, but he kept the show from taking itself too seriously. If this had been a posh, British-style tent competition, it would have failed. It needed the flashing lights and the silly "Cash or Cake" segments where contestants had to pick out which bag of money was actually a cake to win extra dough. It was pure, unadulterated junk-food television, but it was made with a high level of technical respect for the bakers.
The Technical Wizardry Behind Hyper-Realism
Let's talk about the "Is It Cake Season 1" techniques that changed the game. Most of these bakers used something called modeling chocolate rather than traditional fondant. Fondant tastes like sugary cardboard and sags under heat. Modeling chocolate, however, can be sculpted like clay.
- Airbrushing: Using edible dyes to create depth.
- Texturing: Using actual objects (like a clean piece of sandpaper or crumpled foil) to press patterns into the "skin" of the cake.
- Structure: Using internal "armatures" made of PVC pipe or wood to make a cake stand on a tiny "shoe" heel.
One of the most impressive feats was seeing how they handled the "decoy" items. The show's producers had to find real-world objects that looked just slightly off so that the cake stood a chance. If the real object is too perfect, the cake looks like a fake every time. It’s a weird psychological game of matching the imperfections of reality.
✨ Don't miss: Public Enemy TV series cast: Who Really Brings This Belgian Noir to Life
The Cultural Impact of the First Season
Before this show, hyper-realistic baking was a niche corner of Instagram and TikTok. After the first season aired, the demand for these types of cakes skyrocketed. Small businesses started getting requests for "cake that looks like my dog" or "cake that looks like a stack of pancakes." It changed the industry. It also proved that Netflix could take a fleeting internet trend and give it enough legs to last multiple seasons.
There’s a specific kind of tension in watching a celebrity judge point a finger at a decoy and shout, "That one! Number three!" only to have the knife thud against a real piece of plastic. You feel for them. You also realize how easily the human brain is tricked by a bit of well-placed brown food coloring.
What You Should Do Next
If you’re looking to dive back into the world of Is It Cake Season 1 or even try your hand at the craft, here is the best way to approach it.
First, go back and re-watch the finale. Specifically, look at the "suitcase" challenge. It’s a masterclass in how to use "weathering" techniques—making something look old and used—to hide the fact that it's made of sugar. If you're a baker, stop using pre-made fondant. Start playing with modeling chocolate; it’s a 1:1 ratio of melted chocolate and corn syrup, and it stays workable for much longer.
For those just looking for entertainment, pay attention to the background decoys in the early episodes. You can often spot the "tells" that the judges missed simply because you have a better camera angle. It turns the viewing experience into a game you can play at home.
Finally, check out the social media feeds of the original cast. Most of them, like Justin Ellen or Dessiree Salaverria, post behind-the-scenes "builds" that show the internal supports. It’s actually more of an engineering show than a cooking show when you get down to the brass tacks of it. Understanding the "internal skeleton" of a hyper-realistic cake makes the final reveal even more impressive because you realize they aren't just stacking sponges—they're building sculptures that happen to be edible.