Honestly, the "bra or no bra" debate is basically a minefield of old wives' tales and weirdly aggressive marketing. You’ve probably heard since middle school that if you stop wearing one, gravity will just take over. People say your chest will hit your knees by age forty. But then you see these French studies or TikTok influencers claiming that ditching the underwire actually makes your muscles stronger. It’s a lot of noise.
So, is it better to not wear a bra, or are we just setting ourselves up for a literal letdown?
The answer isn't a simple yes or no. It’s tied to your specific anatomy, how much you move, and—this is the big one—what you actually find comfortable. Science doesn't have a "one size fits all" decree here. Jean-Denis Rouillon, a professor at the University of Franche-Comté, spent fifteen years studying this. His research suggests that bras might actually make the supporting tissues lazy. But he also admits his study was limited to younger women and doesn't apply to everyone.
We need to talk about what happens to the Cooper’s ligaments, the skin, and your posture when you go rogue.
The Myth of the "Magic" Support
Most of us were told that bras are like scaffolding. Without them, the building collapses. That’s not exactly how human biology works. Your breasts are mostly fat and glandular tissue, held up by these thin, fibrous bands called Cooper’s ligaments.
They aren't muscles. You can’t "work them out" at the gym.
When you wear a highly restrictive bra 24/7, those ligaments don't have to do much work. Rouillon’s controversial study, which followed over 300 women, found that those who didn't wear bras actually saw a 7-millimeter lift in their nipples annually compared to bra-wearers. The theory is that the body adapts to the "load" by strengthening the natural connective tissue.
📖 Related: Why Your Pulse Is Racing: What Causes a High Heart Rate and When to Worry
It’s kind of like wearing a cast on a broken arm; if you leave it on too long, the muscle underneath withers away.
But hold on. This doesn't mean every person should burn their bras tonight. If you have a larger cup size, the sheer weight of the tissue can cause real physical pain in the back, neck, and shoulders. For these people, the "support" isn't about preventing sagging—it's about preventing a trip to the physical therapist.
What Actually Causes Sagging?
Let's get real about ptosis (that's the medical term for sagging). It’s going to happen. Sorry.
The biggest factors are things a bra can't touch:
- Age: Skin loses elasticity. It’s just life.
- Genetics: Look at your mom or grandmother. That’s your blueprint.
- Pregnancy and Breastfeeding: Hormonal shifts and weight changes stretch the skin.
- Smoking: This is a huge one. Smoking kills collagen, making skin snap like an old rubber band.
- BMI: Higher body mass means more weight for the ligaments to carry.
Whether you wear a bra or not likely ranks pretty low on the list of reasons why breasts change shape over time. A 2018 study published in Scientific Reports looked at breast morphology and found that age and BMI were the dominant predictors of shape changes, not the presence of an underwire.
Skin Health and the "Bra Rash"
If you've ever dealt with intertrigo, you know why some people swear it’s better to not wear a bra. Intertrigo is just a fancy name for the rash you get when skin rubs against skin in a warm, moist environment. Under the breasts is a prime spot for yeast infections or bacterial growth if sweat gets trapped by a tight band.
👉 See also: Why the Some Work All Play Podcast is the Only Running Content You Actually Need
Going braless allows the skin to breathe.
It also improves circulation. Think about those deep red indentations on your ribs at the end of a long day. Those marks are signs that the bra was literally compressing your lymphatic system and restricting blood flow. While it’s rarely dangerous, it’s definitely not "optimal" for your skin’s health.
The Sports Bra Exception
Here is where the "no bra" rule completely falls apart: exercise.
When you run, your breasts don't just move up and down. They move in a figure-eight pattern. This creates significant stress on the skin and the Cooper's ligaments. Without support during high-impact movement, you can actually cause micro-tears in the tissue.
This is painful. It’s also irreversible.
If you are an athlete or even a casual jogger, "is it better to not wear a bra" becomes a resounding no. You need a high-impact sports bra to minimize that displacement. Joanna Wakefield-Scurr, a professor at the University of Portsmouth, has done extensive research on breast biomechanics. Her team found that unsupported breasts can move up to 15 centimeters during a run. That’s a lot of strain.
✨ Don't miss: Why the Long Head of the Tricep is the Secret to Huge Arms
Why Comfort is Actually a Health Metric
We often dismiss comfort as a "luxury," but in terms of your nervous system, it’s a big deal. Constant discomfort from a poorly fitted bra can lead to shallow breathing and increased stress levels.
If you feel restricted, your body stays in a slight state of tension.
Conversely, for some, the feeling of being "unsecured" causes its own kind of stress. If you’re constantly adjusting your shirt or feeling self-conscious, your mental health takes a hit. The best choice is often the one that makes you forget you’re even wearing (or not wearing) anything at all.
How to Transition to Braless (If You Want To)
You don't have to go from a push-up bra to totally bare in one day. If you've worn a bra for decades, your body might actually feel sore if you quit cold turkey. Your muscles and ligaments need to adjust to the new weight distribution.
- Start at home. Take it off the second you walk through the door.
- Try a bralette. These offer a "hug" without the structural violence of an underwire.
- Check your posture. When you stop relying on straps to pull you up, you might notice you slouch. Focus on engaging your core and pulling your shoulders back.
- Listen to your back. If you start getting mid-back pain, your body might need more support than your natural tissues can currently provide.
Making the Final Call
There isn't a medical consensus that one way is definitively "healthier" for the average person. It’s a trade-off. You might gain skin health and potentially stronger connective tissue by going without. You might gain better posture and less back pain by wearing one—provided it actually fits.
Most people are wearing the wrong size anyway. A 2014 study found that about 80% of women are in a bra that doesn't fit them, which causes more harm than good regardless of the "bra vs. no bra" debate.
If your bra hurts, it’s definitely better to not wear it. If you feel more confident and physically stable with one on, keep wearing it. Just make sure it’s not strangling your ribcage.
Actionable Steps for Better Breast Health
- Get a Professional Fitting: If you choose to wear a bra, go to a boutique (not a big-box store) and get measured by someone who knows what they're doing.
- Incorporate Chest Exercises: While you can't exercise the breast itself, strengthening the pectoral muscles underneath can provide a "fuller" look and better structural base.
- Moisturize the Skin: Use a fragrance-free lotion to keep the skin on the chest elastic. Hydrated skin handles the stress of gravity better than dry, thin skin.
- Take "Bra Holidays": Even if you love your bra, give your lymphatic system a break by going braless for at least 8 to 10 hours a day (sleep counts!).
- Evaluate Your Impact Levels: Save the heavy-duty support for the gym and choose soft, non-wired options for daily errands to get the best of both worlds.