You're lying in bed at 2:00 AM, scrolling through old photos, and that one specific text thread is staring back at you. It’s a classic dilemma. Everyone has an opinion on it. Your best friend probably says "don't do it," while your mom might remind you that "people change." But when you're actually sitting there wondering is it bad to get back with your ex, the answer isn't a simple yes or no. It’s complicated. It’s human.
Relationships don't just happen in a vacuum. They’re messy. Sometimes they end because of a massive explosion, but other times, they just sort of... fade out because the timing was garbage. Dr. Reneé Thompson, a researcher who has looked into "relationship cycling," notes that about half of young adults have broken up and gotten back together at least once. So, if you're considering it, you're definitely not some weird outlier. You're just part of a very large, very conflicted club.
Why we crave the familiar (even when it hurts)
Nostalgia is a powerful drug. Honestly, it’s a biological trick. Our brains have this annoying habit of "fading affect bias," which basically means we forget the bad memories faster than the good ones. You remember the way they smelled or that hilarious joke they told at dinner, but you conveniently forget the three-hour argument about the dishes or the way they made you feel small in front of your friends.
When you ask yourself is it bad to get back with your ex, you have to figure out if you're missing them or just missing the safety of being known. Loneliness is heavy. It's much easier to slide back into a comfortable routine than it is to download a dating app and explain your life story to five different strangers over lukewarm coffee.
The dopamine hit of reconciliation
There is a genuine physiological rush when you reconnect. It’s like a "honeymoon phase" on steroids because there’s already an established intimacy. You don't have to guess if they like the way you cook or what your favorite movie is. They already know. This "on-again, off-again" cycle creates an intermittent reinforcement pattern, which—fun fact—is the same psychological mechanism that makes gambling so addictive. You’re chasing the high of the "on" periods to justify the "off" ones.
The "New Relationship" illusion
Here is where most people trip up. They think they are starting a new chapter, but they’re actually just re-reading the same book and hoping for a different ending. If you haven't changed, and they haven't changed, the relationship won't change. Period.
Think about why you broke up in the first place. Was it a "circumstantial" break? Maybe one of you moved for a job, or someone was going through a personal crisis that made them unavailable. Those are often the most successful reunions. But if the breakup was "interactional"—meaning you fought constantly, there was a lack of trust, or your values didn't align—those issues don't just evaporate because you spent six months apart.
💡 You might also like: Exactly How Long Is Eight Inches? Real-World Examples to Get It Right
Research from Kansas State University suggests that couples who break up and get back together tend to be less satisfied in the long run. They communicate less effectively and have lower levels of decision-making. Why? Because the "threat" of a breakup is always looming in the background. Once the seal is broken, it's easier to break it again.
Red flags that mean "stay away"
Sometimes, it really is bad to get back with your ex. Like, objectively bad. If there was any form of emotional or physical abuse, the answer is a hard no. Don't go back.
But even in less extreme cases, there are signs that you’re headed for a wreck.
- The "Vortex of Boredom": You’re only texting them because you’re bored on a Tuesday night.
- The Comparison Trap: You’ve been on three bad dates and decided your ex was "fine" compared to the nightmare you just met at the bar.
- Unresolved Betrayal: If they cheated and you still haven't truly forgiven them, you're just inviting a ghost into your bed. It will haunt every text message and every late night at the office.
If you’re looking for a sign, look at your growth. Have you actually done the work? Have they? If the only thing that has changed is the date on the calendar, you're just setting yourself up for the same heartbreak with a different haircut.
When it actually works (and why)
Is it always a disaster? No. Some people actually make it work. These are the "Success Stories," but they usually share a few common traits. They didn't just "fall back into it." They made a conscious choice to rebuild.
I remember a couple, let’s call them Sarah and Mark. They broke up for two years. Sarah went to therapy to deal with her anxiety; Mark moved across the country, realized he hated being away from his family, and matured significantly. When they met up again, they weren't the same people who broke up. They had to get to know the "new" versions of each other. They treated the second attempt like a brand-new relationship, not a continuation of the old one.
📖 Related: Icy blonde balayage on brown hair: Why your stylist keeps saying no (and how to get it anyway)
Questions you need to answer honestly
You have to be brutal with yourself here. No lying.
- What has actually changed in the environment or our personalities?
- Am I okay with the fact that the "old" relationship is dead and we have to build a new one?
- Can I honestly stop bringing up the past mistakes once we move forward?
If you can't answer those, it's probably bad to get back with your ex.
The "Backsliding" Trap
We’ve all been there. It’s called "sliding versus deciding." Most people slide back into a relationship because it’s convenient. You’re at a party, you’ve had a few drinks, you leave together, and suddenly you’re "dating" again without ever having a conversation about what went wrong the first time.
Sliding is dangerous. It bypasses the necessary conversations about boundaries and expectations. If you don't decide to be together with intention, you're just waiting for the old patterns to resurface. And they will. They always do.
How to navigate the "Second First Date"
If you’ve decided to give it another shot, stop. Don’t just move back in or start staying over every night. Slow down.
Go on actual dates. Talk about the hard stuff. Bring up the reason for the breakup in a calm, non-accusatory way. If you find yourself screaming about the same things within the first week, take that as the giant neon exit sign it is. You need to see evidence of change, not just promises of it. People love to promise the moon when they’re lonely, but the moon is a long way off and very cold.
Practical steps for moving forward (or moving on)
So, you're standing at the crossroads. What now?
First, enforce a cooling-off period. If you just broke up three weeks ago, you are in no state to decide if you should be together forever. Your brain is literally detoxing from the chemicals of that person. Give it 90 days of "no contact" before you even consider a "check-in" coffee.
Second, write a "Why We Broke Up" list. Be mean. Be honest. Keep it on your phone. Every time you feel that warm, fuzzy urge to text them, read the list. Remind yourself of the nights you cried or the times they ignored your calls. It’s a reality check for your heart.
Third, talk to a neutral third party. Not your best friend who hates your ex, and not their sister who loves you. A therapist or a truly objective mentor. Someone who can point out your blind spots.
👉 See also: Why Being Slothful Is Actually Killing Your Focus (And How to Fix It)
Lastly, if you do decide to go back, set a deadline. Give it six months. If the same toxic patterns are back, you have to promise yourself to walk away for good. No more cycling. No more "maybe next time."
The truth is, getting back with an ex isn't inherently "bad." It’s just risky. It’s a high-stakes gamble with your emotional health. Sometimes the house wins, and sometimes you hit the jackpot. Just make sure you’re playing with your head, not just your lonely heart.
Actionable Next Steps:
- The 24-Hour Rule: If you feel the urge to reach out, wait 24 hours. If you still feel the same way tomorrow, write the text in your notes app instead of sending it.
- Identify the "Trigger": Did you see a movie they liked? Did you have a bad day at work? Pinpoint why you're thinking of them now. Usually, it’s about a void in your current life, not a presence in your past.
- The "Audit" Conversation: If you meet up, don't talk about "us." Talk about what you've learned about yourself since the split. If they haven't learned anything about themselves, they aren't ready to be with you.
- Establish New Boundaries: If you get back together, you cannot go back to the same house/routine/schedule. Change the scenery. Create new memories that aren't tainted by the old ghosts.