You’re standing over a pot of boiling pasta water or a expensive ribeye steak, and the recipe calls for kosher salt. You look in the pantry. All you see is that familiar blue cylinder with the girl in the yellow raincoat. Is iodized salt the same as kosher salt? Not even close. If you swap them one-for-one, you’re probably going to ruin your dinner. Honestly, it’s the fastest way to turn a masterpiece into a salt lick.
The differences aren't just about fancy branding or marketing. They are physical. They are chemical. One is a precision tool for chefs; the other is a fortified mineral designed by the government to prevent goiters. You wouldn't use a sledgehammer to hang a picture frame, and you shouldn't use table salt when a recipe specifically asks for those big, crunchy kosher flakes.
✨ Don't miss: Windshield Crack Repair Kit: What Most People Get Wrong
The Physical Reality: It’s All About the Surface Area
Let’s talk texture. This is where most home cooks get tripped up. Iodized salt—what we usually call table salt—is made of tiny, uniform cubes. These little grains are dense. Because they are so small and pack together so tightly, a single tablespoon of table salt contains way more actual "saltiness" than a tablespoon of kosher salt.
Kosher salt is a different beast entirely. It has large, irregular, flaky crystals. Brands like Diamond Crystal or Morton have huge variations even between themselves. Diamond Crystal is hollow and light; Morton is denser and saltier. If you use a tablespoon of iodized salt where the recipe wanted Diamond Crystal, you are adding nearly double the sodium. That’s a massive mistake. You’ve basically salted your food twice.
Salt is the most important ingredient in your kitchen. It’s the only rock we eat. But because the shapes are so different, you can’t measure them by volume and expect the same results. If you’re a baker, you already know this. You weigh your flour because a "cup" of flour can vary. Salt is the same. Professional kitchens almost exclusively use kosher salt because those big flakes are easier to pinch with your fingers. You can feel the seasoning. You can see where it lands on a piece of meat. Try doing that with fine-grain iodized salt—it just slips through your fingers like sand.
The Iodine Factor and That Weird Metallic Aftertaste
Why is iodized salt even a thing? Back in the 1920s, people in the Great Lakes and Pacific Northwest regions of the United States were developing goiters—swollen thyroid glands—at an alarming rate. Why? The soil in those areas lacked iodine. The government decided the easiest way to get iodine into the general population was to put it in the salt. It worked. Goiters basically disappeared.
But there’s a trade-off.
Iodine has a flavor. Most people describe it as slightly metallic or "medicine-y." If you’re just salting a big pot of soup, you might not notice it. But if you’re seasoning something delicate like a piece of white fish or a sugar cookie, that chemical tang can really mess with the flavor profile. Kosher salt, by definition, is usually just sodium chloride. No additives. No anti-caking agents in many cases (though some brands add them). It tastes "cleaner."
I’ve met chefs who swear they can smell the iodine the second it hits a hot pan. It’s sharp. It’s aggressive. Kosher salt, on the other hand, melts into the food and enhances the natural flavors without adding its own weird chemical baggage.
What "Kosher" Actually Means (It’s Not What You Think)
A lot of people think kosher salt is "blessed" or somehow holier than other salts. That’s a myth. The name actually comes from the process of koshering meat. In Jewish dietary law, blood must be removed from meat before it can be eaten. Because the crystals of this salt are large and coarse, they are perfect for drawing out blood.
So, it’s really "koshering salt."
The salt itself is just salt. Most of it comes from salt mines, just like table salt. But the manufacturing process is manipulated to create those wide, flat grains that stick to the surface of meat. Table salt would just dissolve or bounce off. If you’re trying to dry-brine a chicken for Sunday roast, you need that surface area. You need the salt to sit there and do the work of osmosis.
The Great Conversion Headache
If you absolutely must use iodized salt when a recipe calls for kosher, you have to do some math. And honestly, who wants to do math while they’re sautéing onions?
📖 Related: The Red Black and Green American Flag: What It Actually Means and Why It Matters Now
Generally speaking, you should use about half the amount of table salt if the recipe calls for kosher salt. If it says 1 tablespoon of kosher salt, start with 1.5 teaspoons of iodized salt. But even then, it’s a gamble. Because different brands of kosher salt have different densities, there is no perfect universal conversion.
- Diamond Crystal Kosher Salt: Very light. You need almost twice as much of this compared to table salt.
- Morton Kosher Salt: Middle of the road. Denser than Diamond, but still less salty by volume than table salt.
- Iodized Table Salt: The heavyweight. Use with extreme caution.
Think about it like this: if you fill a bucket with golf balls, there’s a lot of air between them. If you fill that same bucket with sand, it’s going to be much heavier. Kosher salt is the golf balls. Iodized salt is the sand.
When Should You Actually Use Iodized Salt?
Is iodized salt useless? No. It has its place. Because it dissolves so quickly, it’s actually better for baking recipes that don't have a lot of liquid. If you’re making a pie crust or a delicate shortbread, large flakes of kosher salt might not dissolve, leaving you with "salt bombs" in your mouth. Some people like that contrast, but usually, you want a uniform saltiness in your dough.
It’s also fine for boiling water for pasta or potatoes. The iodine flavor gets diluted in gallons of water, and the fine grains dissolve instantly. Plus, table salt is cheaper. If you’re throwing a handful of salt into a 12-quart stockpot, you might as well save the expensive stuff.
What About Sea Salt?
This is where the waters get even muddier. People often ask if sea salt is a better substitute for kosher salt than iodized salt is. Maybe. Sea salt is harvested from evaporated ocean water. It contains trace minerals like magnesium and potassium, which give it a more complex flavor.
However, sea salt comes in all shapes and sizes. You can get "fine" sea salt, which behaves exactly like iodized table salt. You can get "flaky" sea salt, like Maldon, which is even crunchier than kosher salt. If you’re swapping sea salt for kosher, you still have to look at the grain size. If the grains look like table salt, use the "half-measure" rule. If they look like big flakes, you’re probably safe with a one-to-one swap.
The Sodium Myth
A common misconception is that kosher salt is "healthier" or has less sodium. Nutritionally, they are almost identical by weight. Sodium chloride is sodium chloride. Your body doesn't care if the salt came from a mine in Utah or the Mediterranean Sea. The "health" benefit only comes from the fact that because the flakes are larger, you often end up using less total salt to get the same flavor impact on the surface of your food.
If you have a thyroid condition, your doctor might actually tell you to stick with iodized salt. Iodine is a necessary nutrient. But for the average person with a varied diet—including eggs, dairy, and seafood—you’re likely getting plenty of iodine elsewhere. You don't need to rely on your salt shaker for it.
Practical Steps for Your Kitchen
If you want to level up your cooking immediately, stop treating all salt the same. Your food will thank you. Here is how you should actually handle this in your own home:
- Buy a Box of Diamond Crystal: It is the industry standard for a reason. Most recipes from major food sites (Bon Appétit, Serious Eats, NYT Cooking) are tested using this specific brand. It’s very forgiving.
- Get a Salt Cellar: Throw away the shaker for your "prepping" salt. You want to be able to reach in and grab a three-finger pinch. This gives you way more control than shaking a jar and hoping for the best.
- Taste as You Go: This is the golden rule. Never blindly follow a measurement. Add a little, taste, and add more. It is easy to add salt, but it is nearly impossible to take it out once it’s in there.
- Save the Iodized Salt for the "Backups": Keep it for baking or for salting large pots of water, but keep it away from your steaks, your roasted vegetables, and your finishing touches.
- Check the Label: Some "kosher" salts contain yellow prussiate of soda as an anti-caking agent. If you want the purest flavor, look for a brand that lists only one ingredient: salt.
Switching to kosher salt for your daily cooking is one of those small changes that has a massive impact. It’s not just a snobby chef thing; it’s a physics thing. Once you get used to the feel of those big, crunchy flakes between your fingers, you’ll never go back to the "sand" in the blue box for your dinner prep. Your palate will get sharper, your seasoning will be more consistent, and you'll finally understand why that restaurant steak tastes so much better than the one you make at home. It’s usually just the salt.