You're standing in the spice aisle, staring at a wall of blue canisters and glass grinders. It’s overwhelming. Most people just grab the cheapest one and keep moving, but then you see the labels: "Iodized Salt" on one, "Natural Sea Salt" on the other. You might wonder, is iodized salt sea salt? The short answer? Not usually.
But it’s also not a simple yes or no. Salt is a weirdly complex rabbit hole. If you’re like my friend Sarah, who thought sea salt was "healthier" just because it sounds fancy, you’re actually missing half the story. Chemically, they are siblings. Functionally? They are totally different tools.
The Core Confusion: Is Iodized Salt Sea Salt?
Let's clear the air. Most iodized salt you buy in that iconic round blue box is table salt. This stuff is mined from underground salt deposits—remnants of ancient, dried-up seas from millions of years ago. It’s processed heavily to remove minerals and then "fortified" with potassium iodide.
Sea salt is the fresh stuff. It’s harvested by evaporating current ocean water or saltwater lakes. Because it’s less processed, it keeps trace minerals like magnesium, calcium, and potassium. These give it a "briny" flavor and a crunchier texture.
So, basically, one comes from a mine, and the other comes from the coast.
Why do we even put iodine in salt anyway?
It sounds like a chemical additive, right? Well, it is. But it’s one with a massive backstory. Back in the early 1920s, people in the Great Lakes and Pacific Northwest regions of the U.S. were getting these massive swellings in their necks called goiters. It was a literal epidemic.
The soil in those areas lacked iodine. Since crops grow in soil, the food lacked iodine. Since people eat food, the people lacked iodine.
Enter David Marine, a physician who proved that iodine supplementation could prevent goiters. The government worked with salt companies because salt is the one thing everyone eats, regardless of how rich or poor they are. It was the first "functional food." By 1924, Morton Salt began distributing iodized salt nationwide. Goiters almost vanished. It’s one of the greatest public health wins in history, honestly.
The Mineral Myth and the "Natural" Trap
You’ve probably heard that sea salt is better for you because it has "natural minerals."
Technically, that’s true. It does have minerals. But here is the catch: the amounts are so tiny they don’t actually do anything for your health. You would have to eat a lethal amount of salt to get your daily requirement of magnesium from sea salt.
✨ Don't miss: Who Is the Head of the Food and Drug Administration? Meeting Dr. Marty Makary
Sea salt is mostly sodium chloride. Table salt is also mostly sodium chloride.
The real difference is the iodine. Most sea salts—unless the label specifically says "iodized"—contain very little iodine. If you switch entirely to gourmet Himalayan pink salt or flakey Maldon sea salt, you might actually run low on iodine if you don't get it from other sources like seaweed, dairy, or seafood.
Texture and Taste: Why Chefs Care
If you've ever watched a cooking show, you’ve seen them grab a handful of coarse salt and sprinkle it from high up. They aren't using the fine-grain iodized stuff.
Iodized salt has a specific, slightly metallic aftertaste. Most people can’t taste it in a soup or a stew, but if you put it on a slice of raw tomato, you might notice a tiny "zing" that feels a bit medicinal. Sea salt tastes cleaner.
Also, grain size matters.
- Table Salt: Tiny, uniform cubes. It dissolves fast. Great for baking because it distributes evenly in dough.
- Sea Salt: Flakes, pyramids, or big crunchy chunks. It’s "finishing salt." You put it on at the end so it hits your tongue in bursts of flavor.
Comparing the Two: A Quick Breakdown
Most people think salt is just salt, but if you look at how they're made, the gap is pretty wide. Table salt is blasted with heat and stripped of everything except sodium chloride. They add "anti-caking agents" like sodium aluminosilicate so it flows out of the shaker even when it’s humid.
Sea salt is usually just left in the sun. In places like Brittany, France (where they make Sel Gris), they use wooden rakes to harvest the salt from clay ponds. It’s labor-intensive. That’s why it costs six dollars instead of sixty cents.
Is one "Saltier" than the other?
Surprisingly, no. They both contain about 40% sodium by weight. However, because sea salt has bigger crystals, a tablespoon of it actually contains less sodium than a tablespoon of fine table salt. There is more "air" in the spoon. This is a common trick for people trying to lower their sodium intake—use coarse salt, and you'll technically eat less of it.
The Hidden Danger of Microplastics
Here is something nobody talked about ten years ago. Because we’ve done a pretty bad job of keeping plastic out of the ocean, researchers are now finding microplastics in sea salt.
A 2018 study published in Environmental Science & Technology looked at salt brands from 21 different countries. They found microplastics in the vast majority of sea salt samples. Table salt (the mined stuff) had much lower levels because those underground deposits were formed long before humans invented plastic water bottles.
Does it matter? We don't really know yet. The health effects of eating tiny bits of plastic are still being studied. But if you're a purist, the "ancient" salt from a mine is actually "cleaner" than the "natural" salt from the modern ocean.
Which One Should You Buy?
It depends on your diet.
If you eat a lot of processed food, you’re already getting plenty of salt (probably too much), but it’s rarely iodized. Most food manufacturers use non-iodized salt because it’s cheaper and doesn’t affect the flavor profile of their products.
If you cook at home using fresh ingredients and you don’t eat much dairy or fish, you probably need that blue box of iodized salt. Your thyroid depends on it to make hormones that regulate your metabolism. Without it, you get sluggish, your skin gets dry, and you might deal with brain fog.
The "Hybrid" Approach
What I do—and what many nutritionists suggest—is a mix.
- Use Iodized Salt for boiling pasta water, seasoning meat before cooking, and baking. It’s cheap and ensures your thyroid stays happy.
- Use Sea Salt for finishing. Sprinkle it over a steak, a salad, or those chocolate chip cookies you just pulled out of the oven.
Actionable Steps for Your Kitchen
Don't go throwing out your salt jars just yet. Just be smarter about how you use them.
- Check the Label: Look for "iodized" vs "non-iodized." If you only use sea salt, make sure you're eating other iodine-rich foods like eggs, yogurt, or nori.
- Store it Right: Salt absorbs moisture. If your sea salt gets clumpy, put a few grains of raw rice in the jar. It acts as a natural desiccant.
- Watch the Volume: If a recipe calls for a tablespoon of "salt," it usually means table salt. If you use coarse sea salt instead, your dish will be under-seasoned. If you use fine table salt when it asks for "coarse salt," you might ruin the meal with too much saltiness.
- Know Your Sources: If you're worried about microplastics, look for "Mined Sea Salt" (like Real Salt from Utah) which is technically ancient sea salt but hasn't been processed like standard table salt.
Stop worrying about which one is "healthier" in a vacuum. Both are fine in moderation. The real goal is flavor and making sure your body has the basic elements it needs to function. Sea salt isn't iodized salt, and that's okay—they both have a seat at the table.