You're standing in front of the fridge, staring at the rows of flavored seltzers. You've already had three today. Maybe four. The crisp "pssh" of the can opening is basically the soundtrack to your afternoon. But then that little voice in your head—the one that usually ruins things—whispers: Wait, is drinking too much carbonated water bad for you?
It's a fair question. We’ve been conditioned for decades to associate bubbles with soda, and soda is, well, terrible for us. We think of dissolved enamel and bloated bellies. We worry about our bones leaching calcium because some study from the 90s mentioned phosphoric acid. But sparkling water isn't soda. It’s just water and carbon dioxide. Right?
Mostly.
The Acid Trip: Your Teeth and the pH Problem
Let’s get the scary stuff out of the way first. When you dissolve carbon dioxide in water, a chemical reaction occurs that creates carbonic acid. This is what gives seltzer its slightly tart bite. Because of this, carbonated water is more acidic than flat water. On the pH scale, pure water is a neutral 7. Carbonated water usually sits between a 3 and 4.
That sounds bad.
If you’ve ever seen those middle school science experiments where a tooth dissolves in a glass of Coke, you might be panicking. But here’s the nuance: researchers like Dr. Edmond Hewlett from the UCLA School of Dentistry have pointed out that while sparkling water is more acidic than regular water, it is nowhere near as erosive as soda or even orange juice.
In a 2001 study published in the Journal of Oral Rehabilitation, researchers found that the erosive potential of sparkling water was about 100 times less than that of sugary soft drinks. Basically, your saliva does a pretty incredible job of neutralizing that mild acidity almost immediately.
But—and this is a big but—not all bubbles are created equal.
💡 You might also like: Is Tap Water Okay to Drink? The Messy Truth About Your Kitchen Faucet
If you’re chugging "sparkling mineral water," you’re actually in a better spot. The minerals, like calcium and magnesium, act as a buffer against the acid. It’s the flavored ones you have to watch out for. Citrus flavors like lemon, lime, and grapefruit often contain citric acid. That’s a double whammy for your enamel. If you're wondering if drinking too much carbonated water bad for you when it's flavored with lime, the answer is "maybe." If you're sipping it all day, never giving your mouth a break, you're essentially bathing your teeth in a mild acid bath.
The Bloat Factor: Why Your Stomach Might Hate the Bubbles
Carbonated water is literally gas. You are swallowing air.
Naturally, that gas has to go somewhere. For some people, it goes up (burping). For others, it goes down (flatulence). But for people with sensitive digestive systems, particularly those with Irritable Bowel Syndrome (IBS), those bubbles can be a nightmare.
Dr. Courtney Schuchmann, a registered dietitian at UChicago Medicine, often notes that the trapped gas can cause significant distension. This leads to cramping and that "I can't zip my pants" feeling. If you’re already prone to bloating, then yes, drinking too much carbonated water is definitely bad for you in a "comfort and social dignity" kind of way.
Interestingly, there's a weird paradox with digestion. For some, the carbonation actually helps. A study published in the European Journal of Gastroenterology & Hepatology found that carbonated water helped relieve indigestion and even improved gallbladder emptying in some patients. It’s one of those things where you really have to listen to your own gut. Literally.
The Bone Myth: Will Your Skeleton Turn to Dust?
We need to kill this myth once and for all.
There is a long-standing fear that carbonation leaches calcium from your bones, leading to osteoporosis. This fear largely stems from the Framingham Osteoporosis Study, which found that women who drank cola—not sparkling water, but cola—had lower bone mineral density.
📖 Related: The Stanford Prison Experiment Unlocking the Truth: What Most People Get Wrong
The culprit wasn't the bubbles. It was the phosphoric acid.
Phosphorus is an essential mineral, but when you have too much of it and not enough calcium, it can wreak havoc on your bone health. Most carbonated waters do not contain phosphoric acid. In fact, some mineral waters are actually a decent source of calcium. So, if you’re worried about your bones, you can breathe easy. Your seltzer habit isn't making you brittle.
The Hunger Games: Does Seltzer Make You Crave Snacks?
This is where things get a little weird and controversial.
A few years ago, a study published in Obesity Research & Clinical Practice made headlines. It suggested that carbon dioxide in drinks could increase levels of ghrelin, the "hunger hormone." The study was done on rats and a small group of human volunteers. The rats who drank carbonated water ate more and gained more weight than those who drank flat water.
Does this mean your LaCroix is making you fat?
Probably not. The human sample size was tiny, and the results haven't been widely replicated in a way that suggests a massive public health crisis. However, some people do report feeling "emptier" after the initial bloat of a carbonated drink wears off, which might lead to snacking. If you find yourself reaching for the chips every time you finish a bottle of Perrier, it might be worth switching to flat water for a week to see if the cravings subside.
Hidden Ingredients: Not All Bubbles Are "Just Water"
When people ask if drinking too much carbonated water is bad for you, they're usually thinking about the CO2. But you have to look at the label.
👉 See also: In the Veins of the Drowning: The Dark Reality of Saltwater vs Freshwater
- Club Soda: This usually has added sodium. If you’re watching your blood pressure, these milligrams add up fast.
- Tonic Water: This is essentially soda. It contains quinine for bitterness but also a massive amount of sugar (or high fructose corn syrup) to balance it out.
- "Sparkling Water Beverages": These often contain sucralose or aspartame. While the FDA deems these safe, many people find they cause headaches or further digestive upset.
If you’re drinking straight-up seltzer or mineral water, you’re fine. If you’re drinking three liters of tonic water, you’re basically drinking a desert.
Practical Steps for the Seltzer Obsessed
If you aren't ready to give up the fizz, you don't necessarily have to. You just need to be smarter about how you consume it. Expert consensus generally suggests that for a healthy individual, carbonated water is a perfectly fine way to hydrate. It counts toward your daily water intake just as much as flat water does.
Protect your teeth. Use a straw. This bypasses the teeth and sends the acidic water straight to the back of the throat. Also, don't brush your teeth immediately after drinking something acidic; your enamel is actually slightly softened in that moment. Wait 30 minutes.
Neutralize with food. Drinking sparkling water with a meal is better than sipping it alone. The act of chewing produces extra saliva, and the food helps neutralize the acid. Plus, it's just a better palate cleanser.
Watch the flavors. If you’re drinking five cans a day, try to make at least three of them unflavored. Your teeth will thank you.
Check the sodium. If you have heart issues or hypertension, stick to seltzer (no added minerals/salt) rather than club soda.
Listen to your stomach. If you feel like a balloon about to pop, stop. It's not rocket science. Your body is telling you that it can't handle the gas volume.
The reality is that carbonated water is a tool. For many, it’s the only way they can stay hydrated because they find flat water "boring." If the choice is between being dehydrated or drinking sparkling water, the bubbles win every single time. Just don't let the "natural flavors" hide a mountain of citric acid, and keep an eye on your gut health. You're probably doing just fine.
Next Steps for the Health-Conscious:
- Conduct a "Gut Check": For the next three days, track your bloating levels on a scale of 1-10. On day four, switch entirely to flat water and see if that number drops.
- Read the Fine Print: Check your favorite brand for "sodium" or "phosphoric acid." If either is present in high amounts, consider switching to a cleaner brand like Topo Chico or San Pellegrino.
- The Nighttime Rule: Avoid carbonated water within two hours of sleep if you struggle with acid reflux. The gas can push stomach acid into the esophagus when you lie down.