Is Daylight Savings Time Actually Helping Us or Just Making Us Tired?

Is Daylight Savings Time Actually Helping Us or Just Making Us Tired?

Honestly, most of us just know it as that annoying weekend in March where we lose an hour of sleep and feel like zombies for a week. Or, if you're lucky, that day in November when you get a "free" hour. But is daylight savings time even necessary anymore? It’s one of those things we do because we’ve always done it, like keeping that one junk drawer in the kitchen full of dead batteries and old soy sauce packets. We call it "Daylight Saving Time" (no 's' at the end, technically, though everyone says it anyway), and it has been sparking heated debates in state legislatures and doctor's offices for decades.

It's weird.

We literally shift time. We decided as a society to collectively pretend it’s 7:00 AM when the sun says it’s 6:00 AM. Why? The common myth is that it was for farmers. That’s actually wrong. Farmers generally hate it because cows don't check clocks; they want to be milked when they’re ready, regardless of what the government says.

Where This Whole Time-Shifting Idea Started

Benjamin Franklin usually gets the blame. Back in 1784, he wrote a satirical essay suggesting Parisians could save money on candles by waking up earlier with the sun. He wasn't being serious. He even suggested firing cannons in the streets to wake people up.

The real push came much later.

George Hudson, an entomologist in New Zealand, wanted more daylight in the evenings to collect bugs. Then, during World War I, Germany became the first country to actually implement it to save fuel. If people are outside enjoying the sun, they aren't inside burning coal or oil for light. It was a war measure. Pure and simple. The U.S. followed suit, then stopped, then started again during World War II. It wasn't until the Uniform Time Act of 1966 that we got some actual rules on how this whole mess should work, though states like Arizona and Hawaii opted out.

They just stayed put. They looked at the chaos and said, "No thanks."

The Physical Toll Your Body Takes

Your brain has a master clock called the suprachiasmatic nucleus. It’s tiny. It’s in the hypothalamus. And it is incredibly sensitive to light. When we force our bodies to jump forward an hour in the spring, we aren't just changing a clock on the wall; we’re inducing a state of permanent "social jetlag."

Health experts are getting louder about this.

📖 Related: The Betta Fish in Vase with Plant Setup: Why Your Fish Is Probably Miserable

The American Academy of Sleep Medicine has been pretty blunt lately. They want to get rid of the seasonal shifts entirely. They argue that is daylight savings time actually dangerous for our hearts? The data says yes. Studies, including a well-known one from the University of Michigan, have shown a measurable spike in heart attacks on the Monday following the "spring forward" shift. It’s a 24% increase. That’s not a coincidence. Your heart doesn't like losing an hour of rhythm.

Why the Spring Forward is the Real Killer

It’s not just heart attacks. It’s car accidents too.

Researchers at the University of Colorado Boulder found that fatal motor vehicle accidents jump by about 6% in the week following the spring time change. People are tired. Their reaction times are off. They’re driving to work in the dark when they were used to the sun being up. It’s a mess for the circadian rhythm.

When you wake up in the dark, your body hasn't stopped producing melatonin. You’re essentially "sleepwalking" through your morning commute. You’ve probably felt that fog. It’s heavy. It’s that feeling where you’ve had three cups of coffee but your brain still feels like it’s wrapped in a wool blanket.

The Economic Myth of Saving Energy

We’re told we do this to save energy.

Does it work? Well, it depends on who you ask and where they live. Back in 2008, the Department of Energy did a big study and found that the 2005 extension of DST saved about 0.5% of total electricity per day. It sounds small, but it adds up across a whole country.

However, other studies suggest the opposite.

In Indiana, when the whole state finally moved to DST in 2006, researchers found that while people used less artificial light, they used way more air conditioning. If it’s light and hot at 8:00 PM, you’re cranking the AC. The "savings" on lightbulbs were completely wiped out by the cost of cooling homes.

👉 See also: Why the Siege of Vienna 1683 Still Echoes in European History Today

Retailers, however, love it.

The "Lobby for Daylight" is real. If it’s light out when you get off work, you’re much more likely to stop at the store, go to a restaurant, or hit the golf course. The barbecue industry and the golf industry have spent decades lobbying to keep DST because extra sunlight equals extra spending. It’s a business move disguised as a convenience.

The Sunshine Protection Act: Is Change Coming?

You might remember hearing about the Sunshine Protection Act. It’s a bill that would make Daylight Saving Time permanent. No more switching. No more "falling back."

Senator Marco Rubio has been a big champion of this.

In 2022, it actually passed the Senate by unanimous consent. People were shocked. It seemed like we were finally going to stop the madness. But then it stalled in the House. Why? Because while everyone agrees that switching clocks is annoying, nobody can agree on which time to keep.

  • Permanent Daylight Time: More sun in the evening, but kids are waiting for the bus in pitch-black darkness in the winter.
  • Permanent Standard Time: Better for sleep and health, but the sun sets at 4:30 PM in December, which is depressing for pretty much everyone.

Sleep scientists actually prefer permanent Standard Time. They say it aligns better with the sun’s "noon"—the point when the sun is highest. This is better for our internal biology. But the public? We want that 8:30 PM sunset in July. We want the patio drinks and the long bike rides.

So, we’re stuck with it for now. Unless you live in Phoenix.

If you’re trying to survive the next shift, you have to be proactive. You can't just wake up Sunday morning and hope for the best.

✨ Don't miss: Why the Blue Jordan 13 Retro Still Dominates the Streets

Start shifting your bedtime by 15 minutes a few days early. It sounds like something a "wellness influencer" would say, but it actually works for your hormones. Get sunlight in your eyes the second you wake up. This tells your brain to stop the melatonin and start the cortisol.

And for the love of everything, don't plan a long road trip or a major surgery the Monday after we spring forward. Give your body a break.

Quick Reality Check on Time Zones

We should also acknowledge that where you live in your time zone matters. If you’re on the western edge of a time zone, like in Grand Rapids, Michigan, the sun stays up much later than it does in Boston, even though they’re both on Eastern Time. These people suffer the most under DST. They are constantly out of sync with the sun.

What You Should Actually Do

Stop treating the time change like a minor inconvenience. It’s a biological stressor.

  1. Audit your sleep environment. If the sun is staying up later but you need to sleep, get blackout curtains. Don't fight the light; block it.
  2. Watch the caffeine. You’ll be tempted to double down on espresso that Monday morning. Don't. It will just keep you up later that night, making Tuesday even worse.
  3. Advocate if you care. If you hate the switch, tell your representatives. Many states (like California and Florida) have already signaled they want to stop the flip-flopping, but they need federal approval to make the move permanent.

The reality of is daylight savings time useful is that it’s a relic. It’s a leftover piece of industrial-age logic being applied to a digital-age world. We don't need to save candles anymore. We have LEDs. We don't need to worry about coal shortages in the same way the Kaiser did in 1916.

Until the law changes, your best bet is to respect your internal clock more than the one on your microwave. Take the Sunday nap. Go for a walk in the evening light. Just keep your eyes on the road on Monday morning.


Actionable Next Steps:

  • Check your local legislation: Several states have "trigger laws" that will automatically abolish the time change if the federal government gives the green light. See if yours is on the list.
  • Optimize your bedroom: Invest in a wake-up light alarm clock that simulates a sunrise; this helps reset your circadian rhythm more gently than a screaming iPhone alarm during the dark weeks of the transition.
  • Prioritize protein in the morning: After a time shift, your blood sugar can be more volatile due to lack of sleep. A high-protein breakfast can help stabilize your energy levels and prevent the "3 PM crash" that feels twice as hard during DST week.