You're standing at the Cafe trading table. Your heart is racing because someone just dropped a Permanent Smoke into the window, and they're asking for your physical Kitsune or a bundle of high-tiers. Or maybe you're the one holding the Smoke. Either way, the question of whether is creation a good trade for perm smoke depends entirely on whether you're looking for value or utility.
Trading in Blox Fruits is chaotic. Prices fluctuate based on the latest update leaks or whatever a famous YouTuber said that morning. Honestly, most players overvalue permanent fruits just because they cost Robux, but Smoke occupies a weird niche. It’s a common-tier fruit with a "Permanent" tag that feels more like a collector's item than a combat necessity.
The Value Gap: Physical Fruits vs. Permanent Smoke
When we talk about "Creation," we’re usually talking about the act of trading away high-value physical fruits—the ones you spent weeks grinding for—to get that purple "Permanent" text in your inventory.
Is it worth it?
Smoke is a Logia (Elemental). That’s its biggest selling point for low-level players. If you're in the First Sea, Smoke is a godsend because NPCs can’t touch you. But here’s the kicker: most people trading for perms are already in the Third Sea. By then, Smoke is basically a novelty. If you are giving up a Dragon (even before the rework hype) or a Dough for a Permanent Smoke, you are losing massive "liquid" value.
Physical high-tier fruits are like cash. You can use them to get almost anything else. A Permanent Smoke is like buying a lifetime supply of generic crackers. Sure, you’ll never go hungry, but do you actually want to eat crackers forever? Probably not.
What the Trade Calculators Don't Tell You
Most community value lists put Permanent Smoke at around 15,000,000 to 20,000,000 in "trade value" units. For perspective, a physical Leopard often sits way above that. If you find someone willing to take a single Mammoth or a Spirit for their Perm Smoke, you’ve technically won on the math.
💡 You might also like: Why Batman Arkham City Still Matters More Than Any Other Superhero Game
But math doesn't play the game. You do.
The reality is that Smoke’s flight is slow. Its damage scaling is mediocre. Its moveset—while decent for catching runners in PvP because of the "Smoke Cloud" stun—is easily outclassed by almost every Rare, Legendary, or Mythical fruit in the game. If you trade away a meta-relevant physical fruit for a permanent version of a fruit you'll use once a month, you've essentially deleted your purchasing power for a meme.
Why Some Pros Actually Want Perm Smoke
It sounds crazy, but there is a specific group of players where the answer to is creation a good trade for perm smoke is actually "Yes."
These are the Fruit Main Switchers.
If you have Permanent Buddha, Permanent Portal, and Permanent Kitsune, you're already set. At that point, you're just filling out the collection. Smoke is actually one of the better "low-tier" fruits for trolling or niche PvP builds. Because it’s an Elemental, you can use it to mess with players who don't have Aura active.
- The Flight Mechanic: Smoke’s flight allows you to stay mobile while keeping a trail behind you. It’s not fast, but it’s annoying to deal with in a cluttered fight.
- The Stun: The "C" move (Smoke Bomb) has a surprisingly decent hitbox.
- The Cooldowns: They are short. You can spam.
If you’re a 30M Bounty hunter who wants every advantage, having Smoke permanently available lets you switch to it for a specific fight without losing your current fruit forever. But for the average player? It’s a trap.
📖 Related: Will My Computer Play It? What People Get Wrong About System Requirements
The "Robux to Fruit" Conversion Trap
A Permanent Smoke costs 250 Robux. That’s relatively cheap in the grand scheme of Blox Fruits.
If you are the one with the Robux, do not buy Smoke to trade it. Most people want Permanent Buddha (1,650 Robux) or Permanent Portal (2,000 Robux). The "demand" for Smoke is incredibly low. You will sit in the Second Sea Cafe for hours trying to find someone who will give you anything better than a Quake or a Love fruit for it.
Honestly, it's better to save those Robux. Or, if you're the one trading fruits for the perm, don't overpay. If they ask for a Mythical, walk away. They are trying to fleece you based on the "Permanent" label alone.
Comparing Smoke to Other Budget Perms
If you're looking for a cheap permanent fruit, you have to look at the competition.
- Permanent Rocket: Purely for the memes. Zero trade value.
- Permanent Spin: Slightly better movement, still useless.
- Permanent Flame: This is the real rival. For 550 Robux, Flame is infinitely better than Smoke. It has an Awakening. It has massive AOE.
When you compare Smoke to Flame, Smoke looks even worse. The only thing Smoke has going for it is the lower mastery requirement. You can unlock all the moves in about twenty minutes of grinding at Fountain City or Chocolate Island.
Final Verdict on the Trade
So, is creation a good trade for perm smoke?
👉 See also: First Name in Country Crossword: Why These Clues Trip You Up
If you are trading away anything higher than a Venom or Control, you are getting robbed. The "creation" of this trade deal favors the person getting rid of the Smoke. Permanent fruits are permanent, yes, but they are only valuable if you actually want to use them.
Think about your inventory. If you give up your best physical fruits for Smoke, and then you get bored of Smoke (which will happen in about an hour), you are stuck. You can't "un-eat" a permanent fruit to get your physical fruits back. You have effectively downgraded your account's combat potential for a permanent slot you’ll rarely click on.
Stop and think. Are you doing this because you want Smoke? Or are you doing it just because you saw the word "Permanent"?
If it's the latter, cancel the trade.
Actionable Next Steps for Traders
Before you commit to a trade involving Permanent Smoke, follow these specific steps to ensure you aren't losing out on millions in value:
- Check the Current Stock: Go to the Blox Fruits Dealer. If Smoke is currently "In Stock," the trade value of the permanent version drops slightly because everyone can try it for Beli anyway.
- Test the Fruit: If you haven't used Smoke recently, eat a physical one. They are incredibly easy to find or roll. Spend thirty minutes using it in the Third Sea. If you find the damage output frustrating or the flight too slow, do not trade for the permanent version.
- Counter-Offer: If someone is offering you Perm Smoke for a high-tier Mythical, counter with two Legendaries (like Blizzard and Rumble). If they refuse, let them. There are thousands of players with 250 Robux; you can find another deal.
- Prioritize Utility: If you don't already have Permanent Buddha or Permanent Portal, focus all your "Creation" efforts on those. They are the only two fruits that fundamentally change how the game is played. Smoke is just a cosmetic change to your moveset.
- Audit Your Inventory: Look at what you're giving up. If those physical fruits are your only "currency" for getting a kitsune or a Dragon rework, keep them. Physical fruits are your leverage. Don't trade your leverage for a low-tier permanent.
Trading is a game of patience. Don't let the flash of a "Perm" offer blind you to the fact that Smoke is, at the end of the day, just Smoke. It's common for a reason. Keep your Mythicals until a better permanent—like Ice, Flame, or Light—comes across the table.