When the news broke in April 2025 that a man had firebombed the Pennsylvania Governor’s residence while Josh Shapiro and his family were inside, the internet did what it always does. It sprinted toward a narrative. Within hours, screenshots were flying. Some people claimed he was a radical leftist. Others were certain he was a far-right extremist. But if you're looking for a simple answer to is Cody Balmer MAGA, you're going to find that the truth is a lot messier than a campaign slogan.
Balmer, a 38-year-old from Harrisburg, didn't exactly fit into a neat box. Honestly, his digital footprint looks less like a manifesto and more like a chaotic collage of grievances.
He was eventually sentenced to 25 to 50 years in prison in October 2025 after pleading guilty to attempted murder, terrorism, and arson. But even after the sentencing, the question of his "side" remains one of the most searched things about the case. People want to know who "claims" him.
The Truth About Cody Balmer’s Political Beliefs
Let's get into the weeds. If you look at his voter registration, Cody Balmer was listed as an active voter with no party affiliation. He wasn't a registered Republican, nor was he a Democrat.
His social media was a total grab bag. In 2021, he was posting memes complaining that "Joe Biden owes me $2,000," which was a common refrain from people frustrated with the stimulus check rollout. He also shared content from people like Ron Paul and Tulsi Gabbard. That’s a specific vibe—mostly anti-establishment, libertarian-leaning, and deeply skeptical of the federal government.
Was he MAGA? It depends on who you ask and what year you’re looking at. His brother actually told reporters that Balmer was mostly a political independent until 2024. Around that time, he apparently tried to get his family members to vote for Donald Trump.
💡 You might also like: Passive Resistance Explained: Why It Is Way More Than Just Standing Still
The Misinformation Storm
The reason the "is Cody Balmer MAGA" question got so heated was thanks to some fake news that went viral right after the fire. A photo of Balmer wearing a mask was photoshopped to include the words "F--- Trump."
Political influencers on X (formerly Twitter) used that edited photo to claim he was a "radical Democrat." It was a lie. PolitiFact and other outlets quickly debunked it, finding the original photo from 2020 which had no such text.
On the flip side, some tried to paint him as a pure MAGA operative. That doesn't quite fit either. While he showed support for Trump later in life, his stated motive for attacking Governor Shapiro was focused on the war in Gaza and "perceived injustices toward the people of Palestine."
A Motive Without a Category
The attack happened on the first night of Passover. That’s a big deal. Because Shapiro is Jewish, there was immediate speculation about antisemitism.
When Balmer called 911 to essentially "explain" himself, he called Shapiro a "monster." He talked about not wanting to be part of the Governor's "plans for the Palestinian people." It was a confusing, rambling justification that mixed international politics with personal delusions. He even baselessly claimed the Governor was having his friends killed.
📖 Related: What Really Happened With the Women's Orchestra of Auschwitz
Basically, you have a guy who:
- Criticized Biden over gas prices and stimulus checks.
- Supported BLM at one point.
- Pitched Trump to his family in 2024.
- Expressed anti-lockdown and anti-vax views during COVID.
- Eventually attacked a Democratic governor over his stance on Israel.
It’s a "choose your own adventure" of political radicalization.
Mental Health and Radicalization
We can't talk about Balmer's politics without talking about his mental state. His family was very open about the fact that he struggled with schizophrenia and bipolar disorder. According to his mother, Christie Balmer, he had stopped taking his medication before the incident.
This is where the "is Cody Balmer MAGA" question starts to lose its utility. When someone is in the middle of a mental health crisis, they often latch onto whatever "enemy" is most visible in the news cycle. For Balmer, that was Josh Shapiro.
He didn't just bring Molotov cocktails; he brought a small sledgehammer. He told police he intended to beat the Governor if he found him. This wasn't a coordinated political hit. It was the violent act of an unstable man who had become obsessed with a specific set of grievances he found online.
👉 See also: How Much Did Trump Add to the National Debt Explained (Simply)
The October 2025 Sentencing
When Balmer stood in front of Judge Deborah E. Curcillo, the political labels didn't matter much. He pleaded guilty to 22 counts of arson—one for every person in the house, including Shapiro’s children.
The legal system treated him as a terrorist. He won't even be eligible for parole until April 2050. By then, the political climate of 2025 will be a distant memory, but the damage he did to the Governor’s Residence and the sense of security for public officials in Pennsylvania is permanent.
What This Tells Us About Modern Politics
If you’re trying to pin Cody Balmer to a specific movement, you’re likely going to miss the bigger picture. He represents a type of "cafeteria radicalization" that's becoming more common.
People pick and choose different beliefs from across the spectrum. They might hate big pharma, support certain Republican candidates, and then commit violence based on a leftist or pro-Palestine stance. It’s not a straight line.
Honestly, the "MAGA" label is too small to describe what happened here. It was a combination of untreated severe mental illness, an obsession with online political commentary, and a total breakdown of personal stability.
What you can do next:
To get a better handle on how political violence is changing, you should look into the FBI's reports on "lone actor" domestic terrorism. These reports often explain why people like Balmer don't fit into traditional groups like MAGA or Antifa. You can also follow local Pennsylvania outlets like Spotlight PA, which provided the most detailed coverage of the court proceedings and the mental health history that the national outlets often glossed over. Understanding the nuances of the Pennsylvania mental health commitment laws—which Balmer’s mother tried to use before the attack—is also key to seeing how this tragedy might have been prevented.