You’re driving up a winding, wooded road in Westchester County, and suddenly, there it is. A literal stone castle. It feels like you’ve accidentally crossed the Atlantic and landed in the Scottish Highlands, but honestly, you’re just about 45 minutes north of Manhattan. This is Castle Hotel and Spa Tarrytown, a place that looks so much like a movie set that people often assume it’s just a facade. It isn't.
It’s real stone. It’s real history. And it’s perched on the highest point in Tarrytown, looking down at the Hudson River like it owns the place.
If you’re looking for a generic Hilton experience, this isn't it. This place is weird, beautiful, and sometimes a little bit haunting in that "old money" sort of way. Built over a century ago, it’s survived various owners and renovations, yet it keeps that specific, heavy atmosphere of the Gilded Age. You’ve probably seen photos of the crenelated towers and thought, "Is that actually a hotel?" Yeah, it is. But before you drop several hundred dollars on a weekend stay, you should probably know what’s actually happening behind those massive oak doors.
The Gilded Age Bones of Carrollcliffe
Most people just call it "The Castle," but its birth name was Carrollcliffe. It was the brainchild of General Howard Carroll, a man who clearly had a flair for the dramatic. He built this massive estate in two stages between 1897 and 1910. He didn't just want a house; he wanted a statement piece inspired by Norman fortifications in Wales and Scotland.
Imagine the ego it takes to build a castle in New York.
The craftsmanship is honestly staggering. We’re talking about hand-hewn stone walls that are two feet thick. The woodwork inside? It’s solid oak, carved with the kind of detail you just don't see anymore because it costs a fortune in labor. After Carroll’s family moved out, the place went through some strange phases, including a stint as an office for a financial firm, before finally becoming the Castle Hotel and Spa Tarrytown we know today.
📖 Related: Novotel Perth Adelaide Terrace: What Most People Get Wrong
What It’s Actually Like to Stay There
Here’s the thing. Old buildings are finicky.
When you stay here, you’re choosing between the original castle rooms and the "Equus" wing. If you want the full-on Downton Abbey vibe, you try for the suites in the main building. They have high ceilings, massive windows, and a certain gravity to them. The newer wing is more like a high-end luxury hotel. It’s nice, sure, but it lacks that "I might meet a ghost in the hallway" energy that makes the main castle special.
The views are the real seller. From the hilltop, the Hudson Valley stretches out beneath you. On a clear day, the Tappan Zee Bridge (or the Mario Cuomo Bridge, if we’re being official) glitters in the distance.
The Sankara Spa Situation
A lot of people come specifically for the spa. It’s called Sankara now. It’s small. If you’re expecting a sprawling, 50,000-square-foot resort spa like you’d find in Vegas, you’ll be disappointed. But it’s intimate. They do these holistic treatments that actually feel personalized. The relaxation lounge is basically a quiet cocoon where you can forget that I-87 is buzzing just a few miles away. It’s a very specific kind of luxury—less "look at me" and more "leave me alone."
Dining at Equus
The on-site restaurant, Equus, is where things get fancy. It’s won those AAA Four Diamond awards, and the dining room feels like a royal banquet hall. Think wood-burning fireplaces and crystal chandeliers. The menu usually leans heavily into local Hudson Valley ingredients.
👉 See also: Magnolia Fort Worth Texas: Why This Street Still Defines the Near Southside
Is it expensive? Oh, absolutely.
Is it worth it? If you’re celebrating an anniversary or trying to impress someone, yes. If you just want a burger, maybe drive down into the town of Tarrytown instead.
The Tarrytown Context
You can’t talk about the Castle without talking about its neighbors. Tarrytown and Sleepy Hollow are intertwined. You’re minutes away from Lyndhurst Mansion (another gothic masterpiece) and Sunnyside, Washington Irving’s old home.
In October, this whole area goes insane because of the Headless Horseman legends. If you stay at the Castle Hotel and Spa Tarrytown during the fall, you are right in the epicenter of Halloween culture. But fair warning: traffic in Tarrytown in October is a nightmare. It’s better to park your car at the castle and use ride-shares or just walk the trails if you’re feeling adventurous.
Why Some People Get This Place Wrong
A common misconception is that the Castle is a massive, sprawling resort. It’s actually quite boutique. With only about 31 rooms, it’s quiet. If you show up expecting a bustling lobby with a Starbucks and a gift shop, you’re in the wrong place. This is a place for reading a leather-bound book by a fireplace. It's for slow mornings.
Another thing? The hill. It’s a steep climb. If you decide to walk down into town for dinner, remember you have to get back up. Most people end up Ubering back because that incline is no joke after a glass of wine.
✨ Don't miss: Why Molly Butler Lodge & Restaurant is Still the Heart of Greer After a Century
Realities of Historic Luxury
Let's be real for a second. Historic hotels have quirks.
- The elevators might be a bit slow.
- The layout can be confusing because it wasn't originally designed to be a hotel.
- Sometimes the Wi-Fi struggles with those two-foot-thick stone walls.
But that’s part of the trade-off. You’re trading modern architectural perfection for character. You’re sleeping in a room where people were hosting gala balls a hundred years ago.
Making the Most of Your Stay
If you’re planning a trip, don't just sit in your room. The grounds are 11 acres of manicured gardens and wooded paths. There’s an outdoor pool that’s open seasonally, and it’s arguably one of the most scenic places to swim in the entire state of New York. It feels very "private estate."
For the best experience, try to book during the "shoulder" seasons. Late spring is incredible when the gardens are blooming, and early November offers that crisp air and late-turning leaves without the massive crowds of the Halloween season.
Actionable Steps for Your Visit
- Request a Castle Room: If you want the authentic experience, specifically ask if there are rooms available in the original 1897 structure rather than the addition.
- Book Spa Treatments Early: Because Sankara is boutique and has limited treatment rooms, they fill up weeks in advance, especially on weekends.
- Explore the Old Croton Aqueduct Trail: It’s right nearby and offers a great way to see the backyards of some of the most beautiful estates in Westchester.
- Dinner Reservations are Mandatory: Even if you are staying at the hotel, don't assume you can just walk into Equus on a Saturday night.
- Check the Event Calendar: The Castle is a huge wedding venue. If you want a quiet stay, call and ask if there’s a massive 200-person wedding happening during your dates. If there is, the common areas might be a bit louder than usual.
The Castle Hotel and Spa Tarrytown isn't just a place to sleep. It’s a weird, wonderful relic of an era when people had too much money and an obsession with European royalty. It’s a slice of history that you can actually touch, and even if it’s just for one night, living like a Gilded Age baron is a pretty decent way to spend a weekend.