You’ve seen the headlines. They pop up every time Carrie Underwood takes a stage without her husband or posts a solo selfie. It’s the kind of noise that follows every massive star, but for the "Before He Cheats" singer, the "is Carrie Underwood getting divorce" question has become a permanent fixture on the internet. Honestly, if you believed every tabloid cover at the grocery store, she and Mike Fisher would have split up roughly forty-five times by now.
But they haven't.
Despite the constant chatter about "trouble in paradise" and "career-ending fights," Carrie and Mike are still standing. As we move through early 2026, the couple is actually looking more solid than the rumors would have you believe. They’ve been married since 2010. That's a lifetime in Hollywood years. It hasn't always been easy, and they’ve been remarkably open about the fact that they don’t always see eye-to-eye, but a legal split? It’s just not in the cards right now.
Why Everyone Thinks They’re Splitting
The rumor mill isn't just born out of thin air; it’s usually fueled by the sheer distance their careers demand. Carrie is a powerhouse. Between her massive Las Vegas residency, Reflection, which wrapped up its historic run in 2025, and her return to the American Idol judging panel for Season 24 in 2026, she is rarely just sitting at home.
Mike, on the other hand, is a retired NHL captain. He’s a guy who loves the quiet life on their 400-acre farm in Franklin, Tennessee.
Sources close to the couple (the "unnamed" ones that Carrie herself says usually don't exist) often claim that Mike struggles with being a "stay-at-home dad" while Carrie’s career continues to skyrocket. There was a lot of talk in late 2024 and throughout 2025 about Mike wanting to get back into hockey as a coach. The narrative was simple: he wanted to travel, she wanted him home with the kids, and the resulting friction was "tearing them apart."
It’s a classic tabloid trope.
📖 Related: Is There Actually a Wife of Tiger Shroff? Sorting Fact from Viral Fiction
The Residency Tension
When Carrie extended her Vegas residency back in 2024, the "red flags" started flying. People assumed Mike was miserable being left with the boys, Isaiah and Jacob. But here’s the thing: Mike was literally seen supporting her at the American Idol finale in 2025. They walked the red carpet at the Opry 100 Celebration just a few months ago. If there were a massive, marriage-ending rift, they’re doing a world-class job of hiding it while standing in front of thousands of flashing cameras.
Faith as the Foundation
You can't talk about Carrie and Mike without talking about their faith. They basically built their entire relationship on it. In their 2020 docuseries, Mike and Carrie: God & Country, they were brutally honest. They admitted they have different personalities. Carrie is a self-proclaimed homebody who can be a bit of a "hermit," while Mike is the social butterfly.
They also went through the absolute heartbreak of three miscarriages before their second son, Jacob, was born.
"I had always been afraid to be angry," Carrie once said about that time. She felt like she couldn't complain because her life was so blessed. But those kinds of trials either break a couple or weld them together. For them, it seems to have been the latter. When fans see a cryptic Bible verse on Mike’s Instagram and immediately comment "Praying for your marriage!" he’s been known to clap back. Back in 2018, he famously replied to a fan saying, "We’ve never been better."
He hasn't changed that tune.
The "Too Hollywood" Accusation
Another common thread in the divorce rumors is the idea that Mike thinks Carrie has become "too Hollywood." It’s a weird claim for a woman who spends her Tuesday mornings cleaning out a chicken coop and posting about her garden harvest.
👉 See also: Bea Alonzo and Boyfriend Vincent Co: What Really Happened Behind the Scenes
Carrie’s life in 2026 is a blend of two worlds:
- The Glam: Judging American Idol and performing at festivals like Tanglewood.
- The Grit: Living on a farm, homeschooling (at times), and running her fitness app, Fit52.
If she were "too Hollywood," she probably wouldn't be sharing tips on how to use home-grown ingredients for cleaner meals or talking about her "wardrobe-changing" sons who wear three outfits a day.
The Reality of 2026
So, where do they actually stand?
As of January 2026, Carrie is gearing up for a busy year. She’s confirmed for the Tanglewood Popular Artist series in August and is back in the judge's chair alongside Luke Bryan and Lionel Richie. Mike is still the "anchor" at home, but he’s also pursuing his own passions in the outdoors and hunting industry.
They aren't "divorcing." They're just busy.
The fact that they don't post a "lovey-dovey" photo every single day is often mistaken for a sign of trouble. In reality, it’s probably just a sign of a couple that’s been together for sixteen years and doesn't feel the need to prove anything to the internet. They’ve survived house fires (like the one in their garage in 2024), career shifts, and the relentless pressure of the spotlight.
✨ Don't miss: What Really Happened With Dane Witherspoon: His Life and Passing Explained
How to Tell Fact from Fiction
When you see a headline claiming Carrie is packing her bags, look for the evidence. Are there legal filings? No. Has her wedding ring disappeared? Nope. Has she stopped mentioning Mike in interviews? Quite the opposite; she frequently talks about the "simplicity" of her life with him on the farm.
If you’re following this story, here is how to stay grounded:
- Ignore "Insiders": Unless it comes from a verified representative or the couple themselves, take "source" quotes with a massive grain of salt.
- Watch the Red Carpets: In the celeb world, the red carpet is the "official" statement. If they are showing up together, the marriage is active.
- Check the Timeline: Many "breaking news" stories about their divorce actually recycle quotes from 2018 or 2022.
The truth is, Carrie Underwood and Mike Fisher have a marriage that looks like a lot of others—full of compromise, occasionally stressful, but ultimately held together by a shared history and two kids they adore. They aren't perfect, but they aren't finished.
Stop worrying about the "is Carrie Underwood getting divorce" rumors and start looking forward to her new music and her return to the Idol stage. That’s where the real story is.
Next Steps for Fans:
Keep an eye on the official American Idol press releases for Season 24. Carrie often shares behind-the-scenes glimpses of her family life during the filming season, which provides a much more accurate look at her world than any tabloid ever could. You can also follow Mike's "Catchin' Deers" ventures to see what he's up to while Carrie is under the bright lights.