The short answer is no. Mostly.
If you are looking at the United States, the United Kingdom, Canada, or Australia, the answer is a firm no. It’s not a crime. But that wasn't always the case, and honestly, the history of how we got here is pretty dark. People used to be punished for trying to end their lives. We’re talking about property being seized by the state or even weird posthumous trials. It sounds like something out of a medieval horror movie, but for a long time, the law viewed a person’s life as the property of the Crown or the State.
Today, things have shifted toward a public health perspective. However, just because it isn't "criminal" doesn't mean the law ignores it. There are still massive legal implications when it comes to involuntary commitment, police intervention, and how "assisted" deaths are handled.
The big shift in the law
So, is attempted suicide against the law in 2026? In the U.S., it was effectively decriminalized across the board by the late 20th century. The last state to have it on the books as a crime was South Carolina, which finally did away with that archaic classification in the 1960s.
It’s about mental health now.
When a 911 call comes in for a suicide attempt, the police aren't there to put you in handcuffs and take you to jail for a trial. Their legal authority usually stems from "welfare check" statutes or emergency mental health acts. These laws allow the state to take someone into custody—not for punishment, but for protection. You've probably heard of a "5150" in California or a "Baker Act" in Florida. These are the modern legal tools that replaced the old criminal laws. They allow for an involuntary 72-hour hold if the person is deemed a danger to themselves or others.
It’s a weird middle ground. You aren't a criminal, but you aren't exactly "free" to leave the hospital either. This is where the legal nuance gets really sticky.
Global exceptions that will surprise you
Don't assume this is the rule everywhere. In some parts of the world, trying to take your own life can still land you in a prison cell.
Countries like Nigeria, Kenya, and Pakistan have historically maintained laws that criminalize the act. In Nigeria, for instance, Section 327 of the Criminal Code makes attempted suicide a misdemeanor punishable by up to one year in prison. It’s controversial. Human rights groups and doctors have been screaming for years that this prevents people from seeking help because they’re terrified of being arrested at the hospital.
💡 You might also like: What's a Good Resting Heart Rate? The Numbers Most People Get Wrong
India had a massive legal battle over this. For decades, Section 309 of the Indian Penal Code made it a crime. It wasn't until the Mental Healthcare Act of 2017 that the government basically neutered that law. Now, the presumption is that anyone who attempts suicide is under severe stress and shouldn't be punished.
Still, the "law" and the "practice" don't always match. Even where it's technically illegal, many police officers and judges are hesitant to prosecute. But the fact that the law exists at all creates a huge stigma. It’s a mess.
Why did we ever make it illegal?
It’s mostly religious and economic.
Back in the day, the Church viewed it as a mortal sin. Because the Church and the State were basically the same thing, a sin was a crime. On the economic side, a person was a taxpayer and a potential soldier. If you "destroyed" yourself, you were essentially stealing a resource from the King. It’s a cold way to look at human life, but that's the legal history.
Common law in England used to label it "felo de se," which means "felon of oneself." If someone succeeded, the state could technically take their house and leave their family with nothing. Brutal.
The UK didn't officially decriminalize it until the Suicide Act 1961. Think about that. That isn't that long ago. There are people alive today who grew up in a world where trying to die was a felony.
The law on "Assisting" vs. "Attempting"
This is where the line is drawn in the sand.
While is attempted suicide against the law usually results in a "no," the law is incredibly strict about helping someone do it. In almost every jurisdiction, "Assisting Suicide" is a major felony.
📖 Related: What Really Happened When a Mom Gives Son Viagra: The Real Story and Medical Risks
- State vs. Person: The state argues it has an interest in preserving life.
- The Glucksberg Case: In the U.S. Supreme Court case Washington v. Glucksberg (1997), the court ruled that there is no "right" to assistance in dying under the Constitution.
- Medical Aid in Dying (MAID): Some states like Oregon, Washington, and Colorado have passed "Death with Dignity" laws. These are very specific. You have to be terminally ill with a short life expectancy. It’s not "suicide" in the traditional legal sense; it's a medical procedure.
If you help a friend buy the materials or you sit there and encourage them, you could face 10 to 20 years in prison. Even if you didn't pull a trigger or provide a weapon, "encouraging" can be a crime. Look at the Michelle Carter case in Massachusetts. She was convicted of involuntary manslaughter for sending texts to her boyfriend encouraging him to follow through with his plan. The law is evolving to include digital communication as a form of "assistance" or "coercion."
Police intervention and the use of force
Since it’s not a crime, why do the police show up with sirens blaring?
This is a point of huge tension. Because the law treats a suicide attempt as a "mental health emergency," police have the legal right to use "reasonable force" to stop you.
This creates a paradox. If you are holding a knife to your own throat, the police can legally taser you or tackle you to "save" you. From a legal standpoint, they are protecting you from yourself. From a civil liberties standpoint, many argue this can escalate a crisis into a violent confrontation.
There is a growing movement to replace police with mobile crisis units—social workers and nurses—because, again, no crime is being committed. If there’s no crime, why bring a gun to the scene?
Insurance, Wills, and the "Fine Print"
The law doesn't just live in the criminal code. It lives in your contracts.
Most life insurance policies have a "suicide clause." Usually, if a person dies by suicide within the first two years of the policy, the company doesn't have to pay the death benefit. They just refund the premiums. After two years, they generally have to pay out.
Then there’s the issue of "wrongful death" lawsuits. If someone attempts suicide in a hospital or a jail, their family might sue the facility for "failure to protect." The legal argument is that the institution had a "duty of care" and breached it by not spotting the warning signs.
👉 See also: Understanding BD Veritor Covid Test Results: What the Lines Actually Mean
What happens after the attempt?
When the immediate crisis is over, the legal system stays involved for a bit.
- The Evaluation: A psychiatrist will do a risk assessment.
- The Hearing: If the doctors want to keep you longer than the initial 72 hours, they often have to go before a judge or a mental health commissioner.
- Patient Rights: You have the right to a lawyer in these hearings in many states. You can argue that you aren't a danger and should be released.
It’s a civil procedure, not a criminal one. There’s no "guilty" or "not guilty." There is only "gravely disabled" or "not gravely disabled."
Moving toward a different framework
The trend globally is moving toward total decriminalization.
The World Health Organization (WHO) has been pushing hard for this. They argue that criminalization only adds to the pain and prevents people from getting the medical help they desperately need. When you treat a person like a criminal, they stop talking. When they stop talking, they die.
The law is slowly catching up to the science of the brain. We now know that a suicide attempt is often the result of a physiological crisis—a "brain storm"—rather than a calculated legal decision.
Actionable insights and reality checks
If you or someone you know is navigating the aftermath of an attempt, here is what the legal reality looks like:
- You don't need a criminal defense lawyer. You might need a patient advocate or a mental health attorney if you're being held against your will, but you aren't going to "trial" for the act itself.
- Check your local statutes. If you are in a country where it is still criminalized, seek help through anonymous hotlines or NGOs that offer legal protection alongside medical care.
- Privacy laws (HIPAA) still apply. In the U.S., your medical records regarding a suicide attempt are private. An employer shouldn't have access to them under normal circumstances, though certain "high-security" jobs or military roles have different disclosure rules.
- Documentation matters. If you are involved in a "hold," make sure you understand the paperwork. Is it a voluntary admission or an involuntary one? This matters for things like future firearm ownership rights in certain states.
The law is no longer about punishment in the West. It’s about a complicated, sometimes messy, and often frustrating system of forced "safety." It’s a far cry from the days of seizing property and throwing people in dungeons, but it’s still a system that can feel incredibly restrictive when you're caught in the middle of it.
If you're in a dark place, the law isn't there to judge you anymore—it's ostensibly there to keep you here, even if the way it does that feels overwhelming. Focus on the medical side. The legal side, for the most part, has moved on from seeing you as a criminal.
Resources for immediate help:
- 988 Suicide & Crisis Lifeline: Call or text 988 (USA).
- Crisis Text Line: Text HOME to 741741.
- International Resources: Check Find A Helpline for country-specific numbers.