You’re standing on the dirt, checking the scoreboard, and you see your batting average dip. You just drove a ball deep into center field. The runner on third tagged up and scored easily. You did your job. You got the RBI. So, why did your average go down? This brings us to the weird, often confusing world of baseball scoring and the question: is a sac fly an at bat?
The short answer is no. But the "why" is where things get interesting for anyone who cares about stats.
💡 You might also like: Ohio State Score Today: How the Buckeyes Just Handled Business
Baseball is a game of tiny margins. One hit can be the difference between a .299 average and the hallowed .300 mark. If a sacrifice fly counted as an at bat, players would be punished for doing exactly what the coach asked. They’d be penalized for being team players. Thankfully, the rulebook—specifically MLB Rule 9.02(a)(1)—protects the hitter here. It's one of the few times the game actually gives you a break.
The Difference Between an At Bat and a Plate Appearance
To understand if is a sac fly an at bat, we have to look at the hierarchy of stats. Every time you step into that box with a bat in your hand, you've made a plate appearance (PA). That's the broad bucket. Think of it like a tax return; everything goes in there. But not everything in that bucket counts as an at bat (AB).
An at bat is a specific subset. It’s supposed to measure your "opportunity" to get a hit under normal circumstances. Walks don't count as at bats. Hit-by-pitches don't count. And, crucially, sacrifice flies are excluded.
Why? Because the logic suggests that if you successfully fly out to score a run, you shouldn't be "charged" for an out in your batting average calculation. You traded your own out for a run. That’s a win for the team, so the official scorer treats it as if the turn at the plate never happened for the purposes of your average. It's like it's wiped from the record, at least in the denominator of that $hits / at bats$ equation.
How the Sacrifice Fly Affects Your Stats
Let's talk numbers. This is where it gets slightly painful for some guys. While the sacrifice fly doesn't hurt your Batting Average (AVG), it actually does hurt your On-Base Percentage (OBP).
Wait. What?
📖 Related: Why the score of New England football game tells a bigger story than you think
Yeah, it’s a bit of a quirk. When the sacrifice fly rule was being messed with throughout the 20th century—and believe me, it was changed many times—the powers that be decided that OBP should measure how often you don't get out. Since a sacrifice fly is, by definition, an out, it counts against you in the OBP formula.
So, if you go 1-for-3 with a sac fly:
- Your Batting Average is .333 (1 hit in 3 at bats).
- Your On-Base Percentage is .250 (1 time on base in 4 plate appearances).
It feels unfair. You did something productive, yet your OBP takes a hit. Some purists argue this is because OBP is a pure "avoiding an out" metric, and since you were caught, you failed to avoid an out. Others think it’s just a weird holdover from when the rules were written by guys who probably didn't foresee the obsession with modern analytics like OPS.
A Brief, Messy History of the Rule
The rule regarding is a sac fly an at bat wasn't always a settled matter. In the early days of the sport, the "sacrifice" only applied to bunts. The sacrifice fly rule as we know it didn't even exist until 1908. Even then, it was flaky.
The National and American Leagues actually disagreed on it for a while. In 1931, they abolished the sacrifice fly rule entirely. If you hit a fly ball to score a run, it was just a regular out. Your average tanked. Imagine being a power hitter in the 30s and losing ten points off your average because you were too good at hitting long flies.
They finally brought it back for good in 1954. Since then, it’s stayed relatively consistent: no at bat, but yes, it counts as a plate appearance.
When Does a Fly Ball Become a Sacrifice?
It’s not just any fly ball. There are rules. For a play to be ruled a sacrifice fly, two main things have to happen:
- There must be fewer than two outs. (You can't sacrifice if the inning ends on your out).
- A runner must score directly on the play.
What if the runner tags up but only moves from second to third? That’s not a sacrifice fly. That’s just a productive out. It counts as an at bat. It lowers your average. Tough luck. The scorer only grants the "sacrifice" status if that runner crosses home plate.
Also, it doesn't have to be a literal "fly" ball. A line drive caught by the shortstop that allows a runner to score from third? Still a sac fly. An outfielder dropping a ball that would have been a sac fly? That can be ruled a sacrifice fly too, provided the scorer thinks the run would have scored anyway. That’s a judgment call, and scorers are human. They make mistakes, and players definitely let them hear about it.
The Mental Game: "Giving Yourself Up"
Players talk about "giving yourself up" all the time. It's a mindset. When there’s a runner on third and less than two outs, the hitter’s internal math changes. You aren't necessarily looking for a gap-shot double anymore. You’re looking for something elevated. Something deep.
If a player is in a slump, they might actually want a sac fly. It’s a way to contribute without the pressure of needing a base hit. And since we know that a sac fly is not an at bat, it won't keep the slump alive in the box score. It keeps the batting average stable. For a guy hitting .190, that's a lifeline.
But then there’s the OBP issue. In the modern era, front offices value OBP more than almost anything else. If a player hits too many sac flies, their "value" in the eyes of a computer might actually drop, even if they are driving in runs. It's one of those areas where old-school "RBI guys" clash with new-school "Value guys."
Comparing the Sac Fly to the Sac Bunt
They are cousins, but not twins. A sacrifice bunt is also not an at bat. However, unlike the sac fly, a sacrifice bunt does not count against your On-Base Percentage.
The logic here is even more skewed. The idea is that a bunt is a 100% intentional act of giving up an out. A fly ball, conversely, is usually a failed attempt at a hit that happened to be deep enough to score a run. The official scorers assume you wanted to hit a home run or a single, but you "settled" for a sac fly. With a bunt, the intent is clear from the moment you square your shoulders.
💡 You might also like: Denver Broncos vs 49ers: Why This Interconference Rivalry Still Stings
Is it fair? Probably not. But that’s baseball. It’s a game of weird traditions and 150-year-old logic puzzles.
The Impact on the Hall of Fame
Believe it or not, these rules matter for legacy. Look at guys like Ted Williams or Eddie Murray. These were men who lived in the "productive out" zone. If sacrifice flies had been counted as at bats during their entire careers, their career batting averages would be lower.
In a sport where the difference between a Hall of Famer and a "very good" player is often just twenty or thirty hits over twenty years, the sac fly rule is a silent protector of greatness. It allows the power hitters to stay aggressive without fearing the statistical consequences of a deep fly out.
Actionable Insights for Fans and Players
If you're tracking stats—whether for your own Sunday league or just following the MLB—keep these points in mind so you don't get tripped up:
- Check the denominator: If you see a player go 0-for-4 but they had a sac fly, their total plate appearances for the day was actually 5. If you're calculating their stats manually, don't add that 5th trip to the "at bat" column.
- The RBI connection: Every sacrifice fly results in an RBI (Run Batted In), but not every RBI is a sacrifice fly. If you ground out and a run scores, you get the RBI, but you do get charged with an at bat. That’s a "productive out," not a sacrifice.
- Scorekeeping nuance: If you’re scoring a game, remember that a sacrifice fly can be awarded even on an error. If the outfielder drops the ball but the runner would have scored anyway, you mark it "SF" and don't charge the batter with an AB.
- Fantasy Baseball impact: Most leagues use OBP or OPS instead of just batting average now. Remember that your slugger hitting a sac fly is actually a slight "net negative" for his OBP, even though he helped his team win.
Understanding that is a sac fly an at bat helps demystify the box score. It’s one of the few rules that rewards a player for an out. It acknowledges that in baseball, sometimes the best thing you can do is fail in a very specific, productive way. Next time you see a guy walk back to the dugout after a long fly ball, look at the scoreboard. If that runner crossed home, the hitter’s average stayed exactly where it was, and in the world of baseball, that's a small victory.