You’ve probably seen the standard advice a thousand times. Take 5 grams. Every day. Forever. It is the gold standard, the "safe" bet, and the dosage used in approximately a million clinical trials. But then you hit the gym or scroll through a forum and see guys swearing that 10 grams creatine per day changed their entire physique. They claim they feel "fuller," stronger, and less fatigued. So, who's right? The cautious researchers or the guys moving four plates?
Honestly, it’s complicated.
Creatine monohydrate is likely the most studied supplement on the planet. We know it works. It saturates your muscle cells with phosphocreatine, which helps you regenerate ATP—basically the "energy currency" of your cells—during those heavy sets of squats or high-intensity sprints. But the human body has a limit. It’s like a sponge. Once the sponge is soaked, pouring more water on it doesn't make it "wetter." It just makes a mess on the floor.
For most people, that mess happens right around the 5-gram mark. But you aren't "most people," are you? Maybe you're 240 pounds of lean mass. Maybe you're a vegetarian whose natural creatine levels are basement-low. In those cases, the rules of the game change.
The Science of Muscle Saturation
Why do we even talk about 10 grams? It usually starts with the loading phase. Traditionally, people take 20 grams a day for a week to saturate their muscles quickly, then drop to 5 grams to maintain it. However, some evidence suggests that larger individuals—think heavyweights or those with high levels of muscle mass—might need more than the standard dose just to keep those levels topped off.
Dr. Eric Rawson, a leading researcher on creatine at Messiah University, has noted that while 3 to 5 grams works for the average 70kg (154lb) person, the math shifts as body weight increases. If you are a massive human, 10 grams creatine per day might actually be your maintenance dose, not an "overdose."
Think about it this way.
A 130-pound marathoner and a 260-pound defensive lineman have vastly different storage capacities. If the defensive lineman sticks to 3 grams, he might actually see his muscle creatine levels slowly decline over time because his body is using and turning over more than he's putting in. It’s a simple input-output problem.
✨ Don't miss: Egg Supplement Facts: Why Powdered Yolks Are Actually Taking Over
What Happens to the Extra 5 Grams?
If your body doesn't need it, it goes to the bathroom. Literally.
Creatine that isn't absorbed by the muscle cells stays in the gut or enters the bloodstream only to be filtered out by the kidneys and excreted as creatinine. This is where the "waste of money" argument comes from. If your muscles are already at 100% capacity, that extra scoop is just expensive urine.
But there’s a catch.
Some people are "non-responders" or "low-responders" to creatine. They take the standard dose and see zero weight gain, zero strength increase, and zero change in muscle fullness. For these individuals, bumping up the dose is a common experiment. Does it work? Sometimes. By increasing the concentration of creatine in the gut and blood, you might force a bit more into the cells via the sodium-dependent creatine transporter (CreaT1).
Digestion, Bloating, and the "Bathroom Emergency"
We have to talk about the side effects. If you've ever taken too much creatine on an empty stomach, you know the feeling. It’s a sudden, urgent need to find a restroom.
Creatine is osmotically active. That’s a fancy way of saying it pulls water toward it. When you dump 10 grams creatine per day into your stomach all at once, it can draw water into the intestines before it gets absorbed. The result? Cramping, bloating, and diarrhea.
To avoid this, most experts suggest splitting the dose.
🔗 Read more: Is Tap Water Okay to Drink? The Messy Truth About Your Kitchen Faucet
Take 5 grams in the morning with breakfast. Take another 5 grams after your workout with a protein shake. This gives your digestive system a fighting chance to actually process the powder. It also helps with the "bloat" factor. Many people complain that creatine makes them look soft or puffy. This usually happens when the creatine is sitting in the gut or under the skin rather than inside the muscle cell. Smaller, frequent doses combined with plenty of water usually fix this overnight.
Does 10 Grams Damage the Kidneys?
This is the myth that refuses to die.
Decades of research, including long-term studies on athletes, have shown that creatine does not damage healthy kidneys. Even at higher doses. However, if you already have pre-existing kidney disease, you should be cautious. Why? Because your kidneys have to work to filter the byproduct, creatinine. If you’re taking 10 grams, your blood creatinine levels will likely show up as "high" on a standard blood test.
Don't panic.
If you tell your doctor you're taking 10 grams creatine per day, they’ll understand why your labs look a bit funky. It’s not a sign of kidney failure; it’s a sign that you’re supplementing with a lot of creatine. It’s a "false positive" for kidney stress in an otherwise healthy athlete.
The Brain and the 10-Gram Connection
Here is where the 10-gram dose gets really interesting. Most of the focus on creatine is from the neck down. But your brain uses a massive amount of energy. Recent studies, like those discussed by Dr. Darren Candow, suggest that the brain might actually require higher doses of creatine than the muscles do to see cognitive benefits.
While 5 grams is enough to saturate the quads, the blood-brain barrier is a bit more stubborn.
💡 You might also like: The Stanford Prison Experiment Unlocking the Truth: What Most People Get Wrong
Emerging research into creatine for concussion recovery, mental fatigue, and even depression often uses higher dosages—sometimes 0.1g per kg of body weight. For a 200-pound person, that’s about 9 or 10 grams. If you’re taking it for "brain gains"—focus, memory, or neuroprotection—the 10-gram mark might actually be the sweet spot.
Real-World Scenarios: Who Actually Needs It?
- The Hypertrophy Hunter: If you’re in a heavy bulking phase and weighing over 220 pounds, 5 grams might not be cutting it. You have more "storage bins" to fill.
- The Vegan Athlete: Since creatine is found almost exclusively in red meat and fish, vegans often start with lower baseline levels. A higher initial dose can help bridge that gap faster.
- The Aging Lifter: As we get older, we lose muscle mass (sarcopenia). Some studies suggest that older adults benefit from higher doses to maintain muscle integrity and bone density.
- The Double-Session Athlete: If you’re training twice a day—say, morning cardio and evening lifting—your turnover of phosphocreatine is much higher. You’re burning through your stores faster than a hobbyist.
How to Do It Right
If you decide to try 10 grams creatine per day, don't just double your scoop and hope for the best.
First, stick to Creatine Monohydrate. Don't get distracted by "Creatine HCL" or "Buffered Creatine" or "Liquid Creatine." They are almost always more expensive and less effective. Monohydrate is the king for a reason.
Second, hydration is non-negotiable. You need to drink significantly more water. If you're dehydrated, the creatine can't do its job of volumizing the muscle cells, and you’ll just end up with a headache and a stomach ache.
Third, monitor your weight and your lifts. If you move from 5g to 10g and nothing changes after three weeks—no extra reps, no weight gain, no improved recovery—then your body was already saturated at 5g. Your "sponge" was already full. In that case, go back down and save your money.
Breaking Down the Daily Routine
You don't need a spreadsheet, but a little timing helps.
- Morning: 5g mixed into coffee or water.
- Post-Workout: 5g mixed into a carbohydrate-rich meal or shake.
Insulin helps "drive" creatine into the muscle cells. Taking your second dose with some fruit or a starch can actually improve the uptake, making that 10-gram dose more effective than if you took it on an empty stomach.
Practical Steps for Moving Forward
If you're currently taking 5 grams and plateauing, or if you're a larger individual, here is how to transition.
- Split the dose immediately. Do not take 10 grams at once. Your stomach will thank you.
- Give it a 4-week trial. It takes time for the extra storage to manifest in your training. Watch for a slight increase in "water weight"—this is intra-muscular, which is a good thing.
- Check your digestion. If you experience any GI distress, back off to 7 grams or go back to 5. The benefit of the extra 5 grams is never worth chronic stomach issues.
- Prioritize Monohydrate. Ensure your supplement is "Creapure" or a high-quality, third-party tested monohydrate to avoid impurities that can cause side effects.
- Evaluate based on performance. The only reason to take more is to perform better. If your bench press stays the same and your sprints aren't faster, the extra scoop is just a placebo.
Ultimately, 10 grams creatine per day isn't dangerous for most, but it isn't a magic pill either. It's a tool for specific people with specific goals or specific body types. Most will find that 5 grams is the "forever" dose, but for the outliers, that extra scoop might just be the edge they're looking for.