You’re standing in the spice aisle, staring at two nearly identical canisters. One is a dollar. The other is also a dollar. One says "iodized" in bold letters, and the other says "this salt does not supply iodide, a necessary nutrient." Honestly, most of us just grab whatever is closest to our reach because, at the end of the day, it’s just salt. Sodium chloride. The stuff that makes fries taste like life.
But that tiny label actually represents one of the most successful public health interventions in human history. It’s also the source of a weird amount of modern confusion.
👉 See also: Is NOW Sports Whey Protein Actually Good? Why This Basic Supplement Still Wins
We’ve entered this era where "natural" is always better, right? People are ditching the classic blue Morton’s umbrella girl for pink Himalayan rocks or gray Atlantic flakes. They assume the "unprocessed" stuff is superior. While those specialty salts are great for a crunch on your steak, skipping the iodine entirely can actually mess with your biology in ways that aren’t exactly "natural" or fun.
The debate between iodized vs uniodized salt isn't just about flavor or gourmet cooking; it’s about your thyroid.
Why We Even Started Putting Chemicals in Our Salt
Back in the early 1920s, the United States had a massive problem, particularly in the Great Lakes, Appalachians, and Northwest regions. They called it the "Goiter Belt." Thousands of people—especially children—developed huge, swollen lumps in their necks. This was the thyroid gland quite literally screaming for help.
Dr. David Marine is the name usually associated with the fix. He proved that giving kids iodine supplements could prevent goiters. But you can't exactly go door-to-door with medicine bottles forever. The solution? Put it in the one thing everyone eats every single day. Salt.
By 1924, Michigan became the testing ground for iodized salt. Within a decade, goiter rates plummeted. It was basically a miracle.
The reason this matters now is that our soil isn't getting any richer in minerals. Iodine comes from the ocean. If you live inland and eat produce grown in iodine-poor soil, you aren't getting that nutrient unless it’s added to your diet. Your thyroid uses iodine to produce hormones like thyroxine (T4) and triiodothyronine (T3). These hormones are the "project managers" of your metabolism. They tell your heart how fast to beat and your body how quickly to burn energy.
Without enough iodine, things get sluggish. You get tired. You feel cold. You might gain weight for no apparent reason. It's a slow-motion breakdown.
The Case for Staying Uniodized
So, if iodized salt is so great, why does the uniodized stuff even exist?
Well, for one, some people genuinely don't need the extra help. If you live on the coast and eat a lot of seafood—cod, shrimp, seaweed, tuna—you're likely swimming in iodine naturally. Seaweed, specifically kelp, is an absolute iodine bomb. One sheet of dried nori can have a significant chunk of your daily requirement. Dairy is another big source because of the way cows are fed and the iodine-based cleaners used on milking equipment.
Then there's the culinary side.
Ask any professional chef about iodized vs uniodized salt, and they’ll probably tell you to throw the iodized stuff in the trash. There is a faint, metallic aftertaste to iodized salt. Most people don't notice it in a stew or a heavily seasoned dish, but on a piece of delicate white fish? You'll taste it.
Iodized salt also has anti-caking agents like calcium silicate. These keep the salt from clumping in humid weather, but they can make pickling brines cloudy or slightly change the texture of fermented foods like sauerkraut or kimchi. This is why "pickling salt" or "kosher salt" is almost always uniodized.
Kosher salt is the darling of the kitchen because of its structure. The large, coarse flakes are easy to pinch with your fingers, giving you more control over the seasoning process. Table salt, which is usually iodized, is fine-grained and flows way too fast. If you’re trying to season a chicken breast with fine table salt, you’re probably going to over-salt it.
The Hidden Risk of the "Fancy Salt" Trend
Here is the thing that makes me a bit nervous about the current kitchen trends.
We are seeing a resurgence in iodine deficiency in developed countries. A study published in The Lancet several years ago highlighted that even in mild cases, iodine deficiency during pregnancy can lead to lower IQ scores in children. It’s not just about the "lump in the neck" anymore; it’s about brain development.
A lot of people think that because Himalayan Pink Salt or Celtic Sea Salt is "sea salt," it must have iodine.
That is a myth.
While sea salt does contain trace amounts of iodine because it comes from the ocean, it’s nowhere near the concentration found in fortified table salt. To get your daily recommended intake of iodine from unfortified sea salt, you’d have to eat so much salt your blood pressure would probably hit the ceiling.
I've talked to people who have completely replaced their standard table salt with these boutique salts because they want the minerals. But most "trace minerals" in pink salt are present in such microscopic amounts they don't actually do anything for your health. You’re trading a vital, necessary nutrient (iodine) for the aesthetic of pink crystals.
Does Heat Destroy the Iodine?
This is a question that comes up a lot in cooking circles. People worry that if they add iodized salt to a boiling pot of pasta water, the iodine just "evaporates."
Not really.
Iodine is relatively stable during cooking. You might lose a tiny percentage—some studies suggest maybe 10% to 50% depending on the length of boiling and the pH of the food—but most of it stays in the dish. However, if you store your salt in an open container in a hot, humid kitchen, the iodine can slowly sublimate over many months. Keep your salt lid tight.
👉 See also: Why the Ban on Red Dye 3 is Taking So Long
Making the Practical Choice
You don't have to pick a "team" here. You can be a "both" person.
I keep a big box of Diamond Crystal Kosher Salt (uniodized) for my everyday cooking. It’s what I use to season meat and pasta water. It gives the best texture. But I also keep a standard canister of iodized salt for the dinner table or for baking recipes where the grain size needs to be consistent.
If you’re vegan, you have to be extra careful. You aren't getting iodine from dairy or fish. Unless you are eating a lot of seaweed, you basically must use iodized salt or take a supplement.
And if you have an autoimmune thyroid condition like Hashimoto’s, you should actually talk to your doctor before loading up on iodine. In some specific cases, too much iodine can actually trigger a flare-up. Biology is never as simple as "more is better."
The Bottom Line on Salt Selection
The difference between iodized vs uniodized salt isn't about quality; it's about purpose.
Think of iodized salt as a cheap, effective insurance policy. It’s there to make sure your thyroid has the raw materials it needs to keep your metabolism and brain functioning. Uniodized salt, especially kosher and sea salt, is a culinary tool.
If you want to optimize your kitchen and your health, follow these steps:
📖 Related: Why Relationship is Important: The Science and Messy Reality of Human Connection
- Check your diet: If you eat fish and dairy regularly, you’re likely fine using whatever salt you want.
- Plant-based eaters take note: If you don't eat animal products, make sure your table salt is iodized or check your multivitamin for iodine content.
- Use the right tool: Use coarse uniodized salt for seasoning meats and finishing dishes where texture matters.
- Don't trust the "natural" label: Do not assume your expensive pink or gray salt is providing the iodine you need. It almost certainly isn't.
- Check the labels of processed foods: Most salt used in processed foods (bread, canned soups, frozen dinners) in the U.S. is actually not iodized. You can't rely on "junk food" to give you your iodine fix.
Your body only needs a tiny amount of iodine—about 150 micrograms a day for most adults. That’s roughly the amount in half a teaspoon of iodized salt. It’s a small amount, but the cost of missing it is way higher than the dollar you'll spend on the blue canister at the grocery store.