You’re standing in the grocery aisle. It’s a wall of white and pink crystals. On one hand, you’ve got the classic, cheap cardboard cylinder of iodized salt—the stuff your grandma used. On the other, there's the fancy, hand-harvested Himalayan pink salt or grey Celtic sea salt that costs five times as much. Most people grab the fancy stuff because it looks "cleaner" or more natural. But honestly? That choice might be messing with your brain and your metabolism in ways you didn't expect.
We’ve basically forgotten why we started putting iodine in salt in the first place.
Back in the 1920s, the "Goiter Belt" was a real thing in the United States. In places like Michigan or the Great Lakes region, people had these massive, visible swellings in their necks. It wasn't a mystery; the soil there was just totally stripped of iodine. No iodine in the soil means no iodine in the crops. No iodine in the crops means your thyroid—the little butterfly-shaped gland in your neck—can't make the hormones that keep your heart beating and your brain firing.
👉 See also: Stop Hurting Your Spine: Why The Lower Back Romanian Deadlift Is Actually A Myth
It was a massive public health crisis. So, the government and companies like Morton Salt decided to just spray the salt with potassium iodide. Problem solved. Or it was, until we all decided that "processed" salt was the enemy.
The Iodine Deficiency Comeback
It’s making a comeback. No, seriously.
According to the World Health Organization (WHO), iodine deficiency is still one of the most prevalent yet preventable causes of brain damage worldwide. While we think of it as a "developing world" problem, researchers are seeing a dip in iodine levels in Western countries again. Why? Because we’ve switched to designer salts that don't have a drop of added iodine.
If you look at a tub of gourmet sea salt, it usually says "This salt does not supply iodide, a necessary nutrient" in tiny print on the back. Most people never read that. They just assume salt is salt.
It isn't.
If you’re a vegan or someone who avoids dairy and seafood, you’re already at a disadvantage. Iodine naturally hangs out in the ocean. Seaweed is loaded with it. Cod is great. Dairy has it too, mostly because farmers use iodine-based cleaners on the cows' udders, and it leaches into the milk. But if you’ve swapped milk for almond water and you’re using "natural" pink salt, your iodine intake might be effectively zero.
What Happens When You Skip the Iodine?
Your thyroid is basically a factory. Its only job is to take iodine and an amino acid called tyrosine and turn them into T4 and T3 hormones.
When the factory runs out of raw materials, it panics. It grows bigger to try and "catch" more iodine from your bloodstream. That’s the goiter. But before you get a visible lump, you’ll feel the brain fog. You’ll feel cold all the time. Your hair might start thinning, and you'll gain weight even if you're eating like a rabbit.
It’s subtle. You just feel "off."
For pregnant women, the stakes are way higher. The fetus needs iodine to build a brain. Period. Even a mild deficiency during pregnancy can shave a few points off a child's future IQ. This isn't fear-mongering; it's basic endocrinology. Dr. Elizabeth Pearce, a thyroid expert at Boston University, has been vocal about how many prenatal vitamins in the U.S. don't even contain iodine. If the mom isn't using iodized salt, the baby isn't getting what it needs.
The Great Pink Salt Myth
Let’s talk about Himalayan pink salt. Everyone loves it. It’s pretty. People claim it has "84 trace minerals."
Technically? Maybe. But the amounts are so infinitesimal that you’d have to eat a literal bucket of salt to get your daily requirement of magnesium or iron from it. At that point, your blood pressure would probably explode. Pink salt is mostly sodium chloride—just like the cheap stuff—but without the iodine.
When Should You Actually Avoid Iodized Salt?
Is there a downside? Kinda.
Some people are genuinely sensitive to the additives in table salt. To keep it flowing freely, companies add "anti-caking agents" like sodium aluminosilicate or yellow prussiate of soda. If you’re a purist, that sounds gross. Also, if you’re a high-end chef, iodized salt can sometimes have a slightly metallic "off" taste, especially in delicate ferments like pickles or sourdough.
🔗 Read more: Exactly How Much Protein in a 6 oz Chicken Breast? The Answer is Kinda Complicated
And then there’s Hashimoto’s.
This is where it gets complicated. Hashimoto’s thyroiditis is an autoimmune condition where your body attacks your thyroid. For some people with this specific condition, a huge blast of iodine can actually trigger a "flare" or make the inflammation worse. It's the Wolff-Chaikoff effect. Basically, the thyroid gets overwhelmed by the sudden influx of iodine and just... shuts down.
If you have an autoimmune thyroid issue, you really need to be working with a functional med doc or an endocrinologist before you start dumping iodized salt on everything.
Finding the Middle Ground
You don't have to choose between "toxic" table salt and "healthy" sea salt.
One of the best ways to get iodine without the anti-caking agents is through food. Eat some kelp or nori. Have a piece of white fish once a week. If you love your Maldon sea salt flakes for the crunch (and who doesn't?), keep using them as a finishing salt. Just make sure you're getting your iodine from somewhere else.
Or, do what a lot of nutrition-conscious people do: use a high-quality iodized salt for your everyday cooking water (like for pasta or potatoes) and save the expensive grey salt for the table.
How much do you actually need?
The RDA for adults is around 150 micrograms. That’s not much. About half a teaspoon of iodized salt covers you for the day.
But remember, salt loses its iodine over time. If that blue tub in your pantry has been sitting there since 2019, the iodine has likely sublimated (turned into gas) and vanished. Keep your salt in a sealed container in a cool, dark place.
Practical Steps for Your Kitchen
If you’re worried you’ve been missing out, don't just start swallowing iodine drops. That’s a one-way ticket to thyroid dysfunction. Instead, take a look at your pantry and your lifestyle.
- Check your salt labels. If it says "non-iodized," you need an alternative source.
- Rotate your seafood. Cod, shrimp, and tuna are excellent sources.
- Don't fear the egg. The yolk contains about 25 micrograms of iodine. Eat the whole egg.
- Swap your greens. Occasionally use dried seaweed (nori) as a snack or sprinkle dulse flakes on your salads.
- Test, don't guess. If you’re constantly exhausted and cold, ask your doctor for a full thyroid panel, including TSH, Free T4, and Free T3. A simple urinary iodine test can also tell you exactly where you stand.
The "iodized salt vs sea salt" debate isn't about which one is "natural." It’s about a specific nutrient that our modern soil simply doesn't provide anymore. You can be the healthiest person on earth, eating organic kale and grass-fed beef, and still be iodine deficient if you're not paying attention.
Balance the gourmet stuff with the functional stuff. Your thyroid will thank you.