International Holocaust Remembrance Day: What Most People Get Wrong

International Holocaust Remembrance Day: What Most People Get Wrong

It is easy to think you know the story. You’ve seen the black-and-white photos of the gates at Auschwitz-Birkenau. You’ve heard the number—six million Jews. But every year when International Holocaust Remembrance Day rolls around on January 27, I notice a weird gap between what we "know" and what actually happened. People treat it like a static history lesson, something tucked away in a dusty textbook, but the reality is way more visceral, messy, and frankly, terrifyingly bureaucratic.

We remember. Or at least, we say we do.

January 27 wasn't picked out of a hat. It’s the date the Soviet Red Army finally entered Auschwitz in 1945. Most people imagine a grand, cinematic liberation scene. In reality, the soldiers found a ghost factory. The Nazis had already forced nearly 60,000 prisoners on "death marches" toward the German interior. What was left were the few thousand too sick or too weak to walk, surrounded by piles of belongings—spectacles, suitcases, shoes—that the "efficient" Nazi machine hadn't had time to burn or ship back to Berlin.

The Logistics of a State-Sponsored Nightmare

When we talk about International Holocaust Remembrance Day, we’re not just mourning a tragedy. We’re looking at a breakdown of civilization that happened with a stamp of approval from the legal system. It wasn't just "evil people" doing evil things. It was teachers, doctors, and architects. It was the postal service delivering deportation notices.

The Holocaust, or the Shoah, was unique because of its industrial nature. This wasn't a spontaneous riot or a localized massacre. It was a continent-wide operation. Think about the paperwork. To move millions of people across borders to killing centers like Sobibor, Treblinka, and Belzec, you need train schedules. You need logistics experts. You need a budget.

Historians like Raul Hilberg, who wrote The Destruction of the European Jews, spent decades documenting how ordinary bureaucrats sat at desks and figured out the most cost-effective way to kill people. That is the part that usually gets lost in the memorial services. We focus on the monsters at the top, like Himmler or Heydrich, but we forget the guys who just "did their jobs" by making sure the trains arrived on time.

Why January 27?

The UN General Assembly didn't actually designate this day until 2005. That’s surprisingly late if you think about it. For decades, different countries had their own dates. Israel has Yom HaShoah, which follows the Hebrew calendar and usually falls in April to coincide with the anniversary of the Warsaw Ghetto Uprising. That’s a day focused more on resistance and the Jewish experience specifically.

International Holocaust Remembrance Day is broader. It’s meant for the whole world. It’s not just about the Jewish victims, though they were the primary target of the "Final Solution." It also forces us to acknowledge the Romani people, the Sinti, people with disabilities, LGBTQ+ individuals, and political dissidents who were caught in the same dragnet.

Honestly, the "international" part is the hardest to get right. How do you get 193 countries to agree on how to remember a genocide? You don't, really. You just provide the framework and hope they don't use it as a political prop.

Misconceptions That Stick Around

One thing that drives historians crazy is the idea that "nobody knew." That’s just not true. Information about the mass shootings by the Einsatzgruppen in the East and the gassings in occupied Poland was leaking out as early as 1941 and 1942.

The Polish resistance fighter Jan Karski literally snuck into the Warsaw Ghetto and a transit camp to see the horrors himself. He then traveled to London and Washington D.C. to tell the world. He met with President Franklin D. Roosevelt in 1943. He told him exactly what was happening. The response? It wasn't a priority. The Allies felt that the best way to save the Jews was simply to win the war as fast as possible. They refused to bomb the rail lines to Auschwitz because they didn't want to divert military resources.

Then there’s the myth that the camps were only in Poland. While the dedicated "death camps" were mostly in occupied Polish territory to keep them away from the German public’s daily view, there were thousands of sub-camps and ghettos spread across all of Europe. France had Drancy. The Netherlands had Westerbork. Italy had Fossoli. It was an integrated system.

The Problem with "Never Again"

You hear the phrase "Never Again" at every single ceremony. It’s a powerful sentiment, coined by survivors like Elie Wiesel. But if we’re being real, the phrase has become a bit of a cliché that masks our failures. Since 1945, we’ve seen Cambodia, Rwanda, Srebrenica, and Darfur.

The value of International Holocaust Remembrance Day isn't in repeating a slogan. It’s in the uncomfortable realization that the Holocaust didn't start with gas chambers. It started with words. It started with laws that made it okay to treat a neighbor as "other."

The Nuremberg Laws of 1935 didn't kill anyone directly. They just said Jews couldn't marry non-Jews or fly the German flag. It was a slow, legalistic stripping of humanity. By the time the violence became physical on Kristallnacht in 1938, the "legal" groundwork had been laid for three years.

Education vs. Memory

There is a difference between knowing a date and understanding a process.

A lot of schools do a "paperclip project" or have kids read The Diary of Anne Frank. That’s a start. But Anne Frank’s diary ends before the real horror begins. She died in Bergen-Belsen of typhus, likely in February or March 1945, just weeks before the British liberated the camp. If we only read the diary, we get her beautiful, optimistic spirit, but we miss the brutal reality of the end.

We need to look at the testimonies of people like Primo Levi, who wrote If This Is a Man. He didn't write about "hope" in the way we usually like it. He wrote about the "grey zone"—the impossible moral choices prisoners were forced to make just to survive another hour. That nuance is what’s missing from the 30-second clips on the evening news.

How to Actually Observe the Day

If you want to do more than just post a black square or a candle emoji on social media, you have to get specific. Generalities are the enemy of memory.

🔗 Read more: Will Michelle Obama Run For President In 2028? What She Actually Said This Year

  1. Read a specific testimony. Don't just read a summary. Look at the USC Shoah Foundation archives. They have thousands of hours of video testimony from survivors. Pick one name. Watch their story. It takes it from a "statistic of six million" to a single person with a favorite song, a difficult mother, and a life they wanted to live.
  2. Visit a local site or museum. You don't have to be in Berlin or D.C. Many cities have small Holocaust memorials or education centers.
  3. Support the survivors who are still with us. We are in the final years where we have living witnesses. Most survivors are now in their late 80s or 90s. Many live in poverty. Organizations like the Conference on Jewish Material Claims Against Germany work to provide them with home care and medicine.
  4. Check your own "bystander" tendencies. The vast majority of people during the Holocaust weren't "evil Nazis." They were bystanders. They watched their neighbors get taken away and did nothing because they were scared, or indifferent, or they benefitted from the empty apartment left behind.

International Holocaust Remembrance Day is a mirror. It asks us what we would have done. And honestly? Most of us like to think we would have been the heroes, the "Righteous Among the Nations" like Oskar Schindler or Irena Sendler. But history suggests most of us would have just kept our heads down.

Recognizing that uncomfortable truth is the only way to make "Never Again" mean anything.

The commemoration isn't just for the dead. It’s a warning for the living about how quickly a modern, "civilized" society can dismantle itself if the right pressure is applied to the wrong cracks. It’s about the fragility of the rule of law. It’s about the danger of the "it can't happen here" mindset.

When you see the news on January 27, don't just look at the politicians laying wreaths. Look at the faces of the survivors. Listen to the names. Remember that every single "statistic" was a person who had a breakfast that morning, a plan for the next day, and a world that failed them.

The work of remembrance is never finished. It's an active, daily choice to see the humanity in others even when it's inconvenient.

✨ Don't miss: Is Canada Becoming Part of the US? What Most People Get Wrong

Practical Steps for Moving Forward

  • Audit your sources. When you read about historical events, check if the author is using primary sources or just regurgitating tropes.
  • Identify dehumanizing language. Notice when politicians or media outlets use metaphors like "vermin," "infestation," or "cancer" to describe groups of people. That was the specific vocabulary of the Third Reich.
  • Support Holocaust education legislation. Many states and countries still don't mandate Holocaust education in schools. Advocate for curriculum that includes the history of antisemitism and the mechanics of state-sponsored genocide.
  • Visit the Arolsen Archives online. They hold the world's most comprehensive archive on Nazi persecutions. You can search names and see the actual documents—the arrest warrants, the transport lists. It makes the "paperwork of evil" undeniably real.

Reflecting on this history is heavy. It's supposed to be. If it feels easy or "inspiring," you're probably not looking at the whole picture. True remembrance is a burden we carry to ensure we don't trip over the same stones in the future.