The vibe at Lucas Oil Stadium is different these days. It’s not just the smell of overpriced popcorn or the deafening roar when the roof opens on a crisp October afternoon. It’s a feeling that the franchise is finally done looking in the rearview mirror. For years, NFL football Indianapolis Colts fans were stuck in a sort of collective mourning period. When Andrew Luck walked off the field in 2019, he didn't just take his generational talent with him; he took the team's identity.
What followed was a carousel. Philip Rivers, Carson Wentz, Matt Ryan—it felt like the front office was trying to fix a shattered vase with scotch tape. It was exhausting. Honestly, watching the offense during the 2022 season was like watching a slow-motion car crash in a blizzard. But things have shifted. The arrival of Anthony Richardson and the steady, albeit aggressive, hand of Shane Steichen has changed the math. We aren't talking about "what if" anymore. We're talking about "what's next."
The Anthony Richardson Gamble: High Ceiling or High Risk?
Let’s be real. If you’re talking about NFL football Indianapolis Colts right now, you’re talking about number five. Anthony Richardson is a human highlight reel, but he’s also a bit of a mystery box. You’ve seen the 60-yard bombs that look like they were shot out of a cannon. You’ve also seen the injury reports.
The NFL is a brutal league. It doesn't care how high your vertical jump is if you can't stay on the turf for four quarters. Critics like to point at his completion percentage from Florida, claiming he’s too raw. But they said the same thing about Josh Allen. Steichen’s job is to bridge that gap. The offense is no longer the stodgy, run-run-pass-punt disaster of the Frank Reich era. It’s vertical. It’s fast. It’s built to stress a defense until they snap.
But what happens if he doesn't slide? That’s the nightmare scenario every Colts fan has burned into their brain after the Luck saga. General Manager Chris Ballard has bet his entire legacy on this kid’s durability and development. If Richardson hits, the Colts are a Super Bowl contender for the next decade. If he doesn't, we're looking at a total teardown by 2027. There is no middle ground here. It’s high-stakes poker with a billion-dollar franchise on the line.
📖 Related: The Truth About the Memphis Grizzlies Record 2025: Why the Standings Don't Tell the Whole Story
Why the Defense is Actually the Story
Everyone focuses on the quarterback. It’s natural. But the real backbone of this squad has quietly been the defensive front. DeForest Buckner is a certified monster. He’s the kind of player who doesn't just win his matchup; he ruins the entire offensive scheme. When you pair him with the emergence of Laiatu Latu—the guy many experts considered the best pure pass rusher in his draft class—you start to see a blueprint.
The secondary is a different story. It’s young. Sometimes, it’s frustratingly young. You’ll see a corner play a perfect three quarters and then get toasted on a double move because he got greedy. That’s the tax you pay for going cheap on veterans to save cap space for big-ticket extensions like Jonathan Taylor’s. Defensive Coordinator Gus Bradley runs a system that's pretty predictable, but it works if the front four can get home. If they don't? Well, get ready to see some shootouts.
- The Trench War: The offensive line, led by Quenton Nelson, has returned to form. Nelson looks like the "Pancake King" again after a couple of seasons hampered by nagging injuries.
- The Playmaker: Jonathan Taylor is still the engine. When he’s healthy, the play-action pass becomes a weapon of mass destruction.
- The Coaching Edge: Shane Steichen might be the best play-caller the Colts have had since the early 2000s. He doesn't coach scared.
The Lucas Oil Factor and the AFC South Grinder
The AFC South used to be the "AFC South-ish." It was the laughingstock of the league. Not anymore. C.J. Stroud in Houston has turned the Texans into a juggernaut overnight. Trevor Lawrence is still a threat in Jacksonville, even if the Jags are wildly inconsistent. And Tennessee is always a physical headache.
Winning the division isn't a given. It’s a gauntlet. For the NFL football Indianapolis Colts, the path to the playoffs goes through NRG Stadium and TIAA Bank Field. The Colts have struggled in Jacksonville for what feels like a century. Breaking that curse is step one.
👉 See also: The Division 2 National Championship Game: How Ferris State Just Redrew the Record Books
Misconceptions About Chris Ballard’s "Cheapness"
There’s this narrative that Chris Ballard is afraid to spend money. "Binder Ballard" is a meme for a reason. But if you look at the actual numbers, the Colts spend. They just spend on their own. They believe in the "draft and develop" model more than almost any other team in the league.
Is it the right move? In a world where the Rams bought a Super Bowl with trades and free agents, Ballard’s approach feels old-school. It’s risky because one bad draft class can set you back three years. However, it builds a locker room culture that’s incredibly tight. These guys grew up together in the system. They aren't mercenaries; they're Colts.
The Legacy of the Horseshoe
You can't talk about Indy football without mentioning the ghost of Peyton Manning. His statue sits outside the stadium for a reason. He set a standard that is almost impossible to maintain. Fans in Indianapolis are spoiled—and I say that with love. We expect 10 wins and a playoff berth every single year because that’s what we had for two decades.
The transition from the Manning/Luck era to whatever this is has been jarring. We’ve had to learn how to be "scrappy." We’ve had to learn how to appreciate a 9-8 season where the team showed heart. But the patience is wearing thin. Jim Irsay is a passionate owner—sometimes too passionate on social media—but he wants to win. He’s not content with being "competitive." He wants another ring before his time is up.
✨ Don't miss: Por qué los partidos de Primera B de Chile son más entretenidos que la división de honor
Practical Steps for Following the Colts This Season
If you’re trying to keep up with the team, don’t just watch the box scores. You have to look at the advanced metrics.
- Watch the Snap Counts: See how often Shane Steichen is using "11 personnel" (one RB, one TE, three WRs). It tells you how much he trusts the young wideouts like Josh Downs and Alec Pierce.
- Monitor the Injury Report: Specifically regarding the offensive line. This team lives and dies by the health of its front five. If Braden Smith is out, the right side of the line becomes a sieve.
- Follow Local Beats: Guys like Stephen Holder or Zak Keefer provide way more nuance than the national "talking heads" who only see the highlights. They understand the locker room dynamics.
- Check the Red Zone Percentage: The Colts have struggled to finish drives in the past. If they can turn those field goals into touchdowns, they’re a top-10 offense.
The reality of NFL football Indianapolis Colts is that they are currently the league's biggest "if." If Richardson stays healthy, they're dangerous. If the young secondary holds up, they're elite. If the coaching remains aggressive, they’re a nightmare to prepare for. It’s a season of variables. But for the first time in a long time, the variables actually have a high ceiling.
Stop waiting for the "next Andrew Luck." He’s not coming back. Instead, appreciate what’s being built: a fast, physical, and slightly chaotic team that mirrors the personality of its head coach. The Horseshoe is back in the conversation, and honestly, the NFL is just more fun when the Colts are relevant.
What To Do Next
To truly understand where this team is heading, your next move should be focusing on the development of the young core rather than the veteran additions.
- Analyze the 2024 and 2025 Draft Classes: Look at the snap counts for second and third-year players. If guys like Adonai Mitchell are getting 80% of the snaps, the team is officially in "win-now" development mode.
- Attend a Training Camp Session: If you’re local, go to Grand Park in Westfield. Seeing the speed of Anthony Richardson in person is the only way to gauge if he's actually refining his footwork or just relying on raw athleticism.
- Watch the All-22 Film: If you have NFL+, watch the coaches' film. Pay attention to how the Colts' offensive line handles stunts and twists. Their ability to protect the "A-gap" is the secret sauce to keeping a mobile quarterback safe and productive over a 17-game stretch.