Everyone wants to talk about 1979. It is the shadow that never quite leaves Terre Haute. When you bring up Indiana State Sycamores men's basketball, people immediately picture Larry Bird's blonde mop-top and that iconic showdown with Magic Johnson. But honestly? If you’re only looking at the rafters, you’re missing the absolute chaos and grit of what’s happening on the floor right now in 2026.
The program is currently in a fascinating, somewhat painful, and entirely necessary period of reinvention.
The Post-Cream Cheese Era
Let’s be real. Last year was a gut punch. Following that magical 2024 NIT run—the one where the "Cream Cheese" Robbie Avila became a national folk hero—the roster basically dissolved. When Josh Schertz left for Saint Louis, it wasn't just a coaching change. It was a total system reset. Fans at the Hulman Center went from watching one of the most efficient offenses in the country to wondering who was even going to suit up.
Enter Matthew Graves.
Graves isn't some outsider; he was the associate head coach during that 32-win explosion. He knows the DNA of the program. But his first year at the helm in 2024-25 was a lesson in gravity. The Sycamores finished 14-18. It wasn't pretty. They scored a ton of points—averaging over 80 per game—but they couldn't stop a nosebleed on the other end.
Why the Indiana State Sycamores Men's Basketball Identity is Changing
You’ve probably noticed the vibe is different this season. In the 2025-26 campaign, Graves is trying to find a middle ground between the high-octane "Schertz-ball" and a defense that actually shows up.
👉 See also: Ja Morant Height: Why the NBA Star Looks Bigger Than He Actually Is
Right now, the team is sitting at 9-9.
It's a rollercoaster. One night they’re dropping 104 on Illinois Tech, and the next they’re getting bullied at Duke. But look closer at the roster. Samage Teel has been a revelation. Last year he was a spark plug; now, he’s the engine. He's averaging nearly 17 points and over 5 assists, carrying the scoring load while the younger guys like Jaden Daughtry find their feet.
The Transfer Portal Tax
The Sycamores are basically the poster child for the "Mid-Major Tax." You develop a kid like Ryan Conwell, he turns into a star, and then high-major programs come waving NIL checks. Conwell is at Louisville now. Avila is at Saint Louis. It sucks for the local fans, but it’s the reality of the sport in 2026.
To survive, Indiana State has had to become experts in the portal themselves. They aren't looking for the five-star recruits who want a pit stop; they’re looking for the seniors who were overlooked. Kmani Doughty and Camp Wagner aren't household names yet, but they represent the "next man up" philosophy that Graves is betting his career on.
The Hulman Center Experience
If you haven't been to Terre Haute lately, the arena is actually kind of incredible now. The $50 million renovation wrapped up a few years back, but it feels like the community is just now truly inhabiting it. They’ve added these massive glass entryways and a "Champions Club" that overlooks the floor.
✨ Don't miss: Hulk Hogan Lifting Andre the Giant: What Really Happened at WrestleMania III
It’s loud.
Even during a .500 season, the attendance stays solid. People in the Wabash Valley don't just like basketball; they need it. There’s a specific kind of pride in being a Sycamore that doesn't exist at the bigger state schools. It's grittier.
What the Critics Miss
A lot of national media types look at the Missouri Valley Conference (MVC) and think it's a one-bid league that's sliding. They’re wrong. The Valley is a meat grinder. Losing to Bradley in triple overtime (which happened just a few weeks ago, 108-99) isn't a "bad loss." It's a battle.
The Sycamores are currently 2-5 in conference play. That looks bad on paper. But look at the margins. They lost to Drake by two points on the road. They beat Belmont in overtime. This isn't a team that's getting blown out; it's a team that hasn't learned how to close the door yet.
The Path Forward
So, where does Indiana State go from here? Honestly, the "Larry Bird era" needs to stay in the museum. Not because it isn't great, but because it’s an impossible standard.
🔗 Read more: Formula One Points Table Explained: Why the Math Matters More Than the Racing
The goal for Matthew Graves isn't to find the next Larry Bird. That’s not happening. The goal is to build a program that can finish in the top three of the MVC consistently. To do that, they need to fix the defensive efficiency. Ranking 342nd in points allowed (like they did last season) is a death sentence.
The next few weeks are critical. With home games against Drake and Valparaiso looming, the Sycamores have a chance to climb back toward the top half of the standings.
Practical Steps for Following the Sycamores:
- Watch the Perimeter: Keep an eye on the three-point volume. This team lives and dies by the arc. When they hit 10+ threes, they almost always win.
- Monitor the Defense: If you see the opponent's field goal percentage dipping below 44%, it means Graves' defensive adjustments are actually sticking.
- Support NIL: If you're a die-hard, look into the local collectives. In the current landscape, that’s the only way to keep players like Samage Teel from jumping to the Big Ten.
- Check the "True" Stats: Don't just look at wins and losses. Look at the NET rankings and Strength of Schedule. Playing at Duke and Ohio State helps the program’s bank account and long-term recruitment, even if the scoreboard looks ugly.
The Sycamores aren't a finished product, and they aren't the 1979 squad. They’re a group of kids trying to prove that Terre Haute is still a place where basketball means something. And that's worth watching.