You know that scene in The Last Crusade where Indy smashes through the floor of a Venetian library to find a knight’s tomb? It’s iconic. It’s also basically the reason everyone thinks the Vatican is hiding a hoard of supernatural artifacts just waiting for a whip-cracking archaeologist to stumble upon them. People love the idea of Vatican relics Indiana Jones style—hidden chambers, glowing cups, and ancient maps leading to divine power.
But here’s the thing.
The reality of the Vatican’s relationship with "relics" is actually much weirder, and in some ways, more bureaucratic than anything George Lucas dreamt up. We aren't talking about gold idols that melt Nazis. We’re talking about the Archivio Apostolico Vaticano—the Vatican Apostolic Archive. Until recently, it was called the "Secret Archive," which honestly didn't help with the conspiracy theories.
Pop culture has spent decades blurring the lines between the archaeological grit of Dr. Jones and the liturgical reality of the Holy See. If you look at the history, the Vatican doesn't actually go around hunting for the Ark of the Covenant. They mostly try to keep track of the thousands of pieces of bone, wood, and cloth they already own.
The "Secret" Archive Isn't Actually Secret
Let’s clear this up first because it’s the biggest hurdle. The word secretum in Latin doesn't mean "top secret" in the James Bond sense. It means "private." It was the Pope’s personal library.
If Indiana Jones walked into the Vatican today, he wouldn't be fighting off a secret society of guardians. He’d be filling out paperwork. He would need a university degree, a letter of recommendation from a recognized research institution, and a very specific list of what he wanted to see. You can’t just "browse" the 53 miles of shelving.
There are genuine treasures there, though. We have the petition from the English peers asking Pope Clement VII to annul Henry VIII’s marriage to Catherine of Aragon. We have the transcript of the trial of Galileo. These are the "relics" of history. But for the Indy crowd, the focus is always on the physical objects—the Spear of Destiny, the True Cross, and the Holy Grail.
Did Indy Ever Actually Go to the Vatican?
In the films? Not really. In the expanded lore, like the Young Indiana Jones Chronicles or the various licensed novels, he circles the drain of Catholic history quite a bit. But the connection between Vatican relics Indiana Jones is mostly thematic. Indy is the ultimate secular explorer chasing the ultimate sacred objects.
The Vatican's actual collection of relics is managed by the Office for the Liturgical Celebrations of the Supreme Pontiff. They aren't stored in a dusty warehouse like the one at the end of Raiders of the Lost Ark. They are categorized by "class."
🔗 Read more: Love Island UK Who Is Still Together: The Reality of Romance After the Villa
- First-Class Relics: Items directly associated with events in Christ's life (manger, cross) or the physical remains of a saint (bone, hair).
- Second-Class Relics: Items the saint wore or used (a tunic, a book).
- Third-Class Relics: Items that have touched a first-class relic.
Indy only cares about the first-class stuff. The big hitters.
The Spear of Destiny: Fact vs. Lucasfilm
In the opening of Indiana Jones and the Dial of Destiny, we see Indy and Basil Smith trying to recover the Lance of Longinus—the spear that pierced the side of Christ. In the movie, it turns out to be a fake.
In real life, there are actually several "Spears of Destiny." The one in the Vatican is the "Saint Peter's Spear," kept in one of the four piers supporting the dome of St. Peter's Basilica. It doesn't have magical powers that allow you to conquer the world. It’s a broken blade that arrived in Rome in 1492 as a gift from the Ottoman Sultan Bayezid II.
The Vatican is actually pretty cautious about claiming these things are 100% authentic. They call them "objects of devotion." This nuance is exactly what an Indiana Jones movie ignores because "it’s a nice old spear" doesn't make for a good chase scene.
The Hunt for the Ark and the Vatican’s Stance
One of the most persistent rumors is that the Vatican knows exactly where the Ark of the Covenant is. Some theories suggest it was taken to Rome after the sack of Jerusalem in 70 AD and hidden under the Basilica of St. John Lateran.
Archaeologists like Dr. Eric Cline have pointed out that there is zero evidence for this. If the Vatican had the Ark, they’d have a hard time keeping the "divine lightning" under wraps.
Honestly, the Vatican’s approach to archaeology is much more about preservation than "discovery." They have the Pontificia Accademia Romana di Archeologia. These guys aren't wearing fedoras; they are meticulously documenting the catacombs. When the bones of St. Peter were "rediscovered" under the altar of St. Peter's Basilica in the 1940s and 50s, it wasn't a trap-filled adventure. It was a slow, damp, and incredibly tedious excavation led by Margherita Guarducci.
She found graffiti that said "Petros eni"—Peter is here. That’s the real-life Indy moment. No rolling boulders, just ancient scrawl in the dark.
💡 You might also like: Gwendoline Butler Dead in a Row: Why This 1957 Mystery Still Packs a Punch
Why the Indiana Jones Mythology Sticks to the Church
The Vatican represents the ultimate "Gatekeeper." In any "quest" narrative, you need an institution that holds the keys.
Think about the Shroud of Turin. The Vatican doesn't officially claim it is the burial cloth of Jesus, but they own it (it was willed to the Holy See in 1983). They allow scientific testing, like the 1988 carbon dating that suggested a medieval origin, but they also acknowledge the flaws in that testing. They leave the door open for mystery.
That "open door" is where Indiana Jones lives.
The movies tap into the tension between faith and science. Indy starts as a skeptic ("I don't believe in magic, a lot of superstitious hocus-pocus") and ends up closing his eyes so his head doesn't explode when the Ark opens. The Vatican lives in that exact same space—managing the physical reality of these objects while maintaining their spiritual significance.
Real Vatican Relics That Feel Like Movie Props
If you want to see things that look like they belong in a Lucasfilm storyboard, you don't go to the Secret Archives. You go to the Lipsanotheca or the Treasury of St. Peter’s.
- The Mandylion of Edessa: A cloth supposedly imprinted with the face of Jesus. It's kept in the private Matilda Chapel in the Apostolic Palace.
- The Chains of St. Peter: Located in San Pietro in Vincoli. Legend says two sets of chains—one from Peter’s imprisonment in Jerusalem and one from Rome—miraculously fused together.
- The True Cross Fragments: There are pieces of the "True Cross" scattered all over Rome, specifically in the Basilica of the Holy Cross in Jerusalem (Santa Croce in Gerusalemme).
These objects are surrounded by gold, crystal, and marble. They are intensely "cinematic." But unlike the movies, where a relic is a tool to be used, in the Vatican, a relic is an object to be venerated.
The Ethics of the "Looting" Narrative
Indiana Jones is famous for saying "It belongs in a museum!"
This is a point of real-world friction. Many "Vatican relics" were brought to Rome during the Crusades or through various historical upheavals. Modern archaeology has a much more complicated view of "ownership" than Indy did in 1936.
📖 Related: Why ASAP Rocky F kin Problems Still Runs the Club Over a Decade Later
The Vatican actually returns relics quite often. In 2004, John Paul II returned the relics of St. Gregory the Nazianzen and St. John Chrysostom to the Orthodox Church in Constantinople (Istanbul). This is the "anti-Indy" move. Instead of stealing the idol from the temple, the institution is giving the "relic" back to its original home to heal historical wounds.
How to Explore This Yourself (Without the Whip)
If you are obsessed with the intersection of the Vatican relics Indiana Jones vibe and actual history, you can get closer than you think. You don't need to break into the basement.
- Book a Scavi Tour: This is the excavation under St. Peter’s. It’s limited to about 250 people a day. You walk through a 1st-century Roman necropolis. It’s narrow, it’s hot, and it feels exactly like the beginning of an adventure movie.
- The Vatican Museums (Missionary-Ethnological Section): This is where the "Indiana Jones" stuff actually is. It contains thousands of objects from indigenous cultures sent to the Popes over centuries.
- The Sancta Sanctorum: Located at the top of the Scala Sancta (Holy Stairs). It was the private chapel of the early Popes and contains a "not-made-by-human-hands" icon of Christ.
Basically, the "adventure" is there, but it’s hidden in plain sight.
What Most People Get Wrong
The biggest misconception is that the Vatican is hiding "dangerous" relics. The idea that there’s a basement full of objects that could end the world is fun for a screenplay, but it misses the point of what a relic is to the Church.
To the Vatican, a relic isn't a weapon. It’s a "witness." It’s a physical link to a person they believe is currently in heaven.
When Indiana Jones finds the Grail in The Last Crusade, he finds it in a lost canyon in Alexandretta. In reality, there are dozens of "Grails." The most famous is in Valencia, Spain. The Vatican has never officially "authenticated" one as the the cup, because the moment you do that, you turn a matter of faith into a matter of forensic science.
And faith, as Indy eventually learns, doesn't need a lab report.
Actionable Steps for the "Indy" Historian
If you're looking to dive deeper into the real world of ecclesiastical archaeology and the mysteries Indy chased, start here:
- Read the official Archive reports: The Vatican Apostolic Archive website occasionally releases registers of what has been digitized. Look for the "Leonine" documents—they opened up a lot of the 19th-century files.
- Study the "Sack of Rome" (1527): If you want to know why so many relics are "missing" or "hidden," this is the historical event to research. It was a chaotic period where many of the Church's treasures were actually looted or destroyed, creating the "gaps" in history that novelists love to fill.
- Visit the Treasury of Santa Croce in Gerusalemme: If you are in Rome, skip the long line at the Vatican Museums for one afternoon and go here. You’ll see the "Titulus Crucis" (the sign that hung over Jesus) and thorns allegedly from the Crown of Thorns. Whether you believe they are real or not, the history of how they got to Rome is a wilder story than most movies.
The hunt for Vatican relics Indiana Jones style is really a hunt for the tangible side of the intangible. We want to touch the past. We want the stories to be true. The Vatican just happens to be the world's oldest lost-and-found for those stories.