If you were around for the 2000s, you know that "Colts vs. Patriots" wasn't just another game on the schedule. It was an event. It was the NFL's answer to a heavyweight title fight, usually featuring two of the smartest quarterbacks to ever play the game. Honestly, it kind of defined a whole generation of football fans.
Fast forward to today, and while the names on the jerseys have changed, the intensity usually hasn't. Whether they are fighting for AFC dominance or just trying to stay relevant in a shifting league, whenever the Indiana Colts vs New England Patriots matchup pops up, people pay attention.
Why This Specific Rivalry Still Matters
Most rivalries are based on geography. Think Bears and Packers or Giants and Eagles. But the Colts and Patriots? That was built on pure, unadulterated excellence. For years, the road to the Super Bowl went through either Foxborough or Indianapolis. It was basically a prerequisite for winning a ring.
Take the latest meeting on December 1, 2024. It wasn't exactly the Manning-Brady era in terms of star power, but the drama was 100% there. The Colts managed to edge out the Patriots 25–24 in a nail-biter at Gillette Stadium. It’s games like that—decided by a single point—that keep the fire under this "blood feud" burning. You've got New England leading the all-time series 53–32, but Indy has actually won four of the last five. The momentum is shifting, and it’s fascinating to watch.
✨ Don't miss: The Division 2 National Championship Game: How Ferris State Just Redrew the Record Books
The Stats That Actually Tell the Story
If you look at the raw numbers, the Patriots have the historical upper hand. They've won 53 games to the Colts' 32. But that doesn't tell you about the 2006 AFC Championship, where the Colts erased a 21–6 halftime deficit to win 38–34. That game basically broke the "Manning can't win the big one" narrative forever.
Then you have the 2010s, where the Patriots went on an absolute tear, winning eight straight against Indy. Including the infamous "Deflategate" game—the 2014 AFC Championship where New England won 45–7. That night didn't just end a season; it started a legal odyssey that lasted 544 days and changed how the NFL handles equipment.
The Modern Era: Richardson vs. Maye
We aren't in the 2000s anymore. The legendary figures are in the Hall of Fame (or headed there), and we have a new crop of talent trying to make their own history.
🔗 Read more: Por qué los partidos de Primera B de Chile son más entretenidos que la división de honor
In that December 2024 thriller, we saw Anthony Richardson making plays with his legs—scoring a rushing touchdown in the second quarter—while the Patriots relied on a young Drake Maye. It’s a different style of football. It’s more athletic, maybe a bit more chaotic, but the stakes feel just as high for the fans in the stands.
The Patriots have found some stability with guys like Rhamondre Stevenson, who recently climbed into the top 10 on New England's all-time rushing list. On the other side, the Colts have Jonathan Taylor, who is consistently one of the most dangerous backs in the league. When Taylor is healthy, the Indiana Colts vs New England Patriots dynamic changes completely because the Patriots' defense has to commit so many resources to stopping the run.
Misconceptions About the Matchup
One big thing people get wrong is thinking this rivalry died when Brady left. It didn't. It just evolved. It’s less about "who is the GOAT" now and more about "who can rebuild faster."
💡 You might also like: South Carolina women's basketball schedule: What Most People Get Wrong
Also, people forget that these teams were division rivals until 2002. They played twice a year in the AFC East. When the Colts moved to the AFC South, the NFL actually expected the rivalry to fade. Instead, it got better because they kept meeting in the playoffs.
What to Watch For Next Time
When these two meet again, don't just look at the scoreboard. Watch the trenches. The Colts' offensive line, anchored by Quenton Nelson, is still one of the best units when they are in sync. New England’s defense, under various iterations of leadership, always tries to take away a team's best weapon.
If you're betting or just analyzing the game, here are some things to keep in mind:
- Turnover Margin: In the 2024 game, the Patriots defense picked off two passes. That’s usually the decider in these close matchups.
- Red Zone Efficiency: New England has a history of making teams settle for field goals. In their 2024 loss, despite the close score, the Patriots defense forced Indy into several long drives that didn't end in six points.
- The "Germany" Factor: We've even seen this rivalry go international, like the 10-6 defensive struggle in Frankfurt back in 2023. These teams play each other tight regardless of the zip code.
Actionable Insights for Fans and Analysts
If you're tracking the Indiana Colts vs New England Patriots rivalry for the upcoming seasons, you should focus on the development of the young QBs. The gap between a "franchise guy" and a "bridge guy" is what usually decides this series.
- Monitor the Injury Report: Specifically for Jonathan Taylor. The Colts' win percentage jumps significantly when he carries the ball 20+ times.
- Watch the Patriots' Secondary: They are rebuilding a unit that was once the gold standard. Christian Gonzalez is the name to watch there; his ability to travel with WR1s like Michael Pittman Jr. changes how the Colts can call plays.
- Historical Trends: Don't ignore the "post-bye" stats. Both teams historically perform better with extra rest, often leading to those high-scoring classics we saw in the mid-2000s.
The days of Manning and Brady are gone, but the ghost of those games still haunts the turf every time these two teams meet. It’s a rivalry built on respect, a little bit of hatred, and a whole lot of history.