your edit looks like one pupil is larger than the other like he's just had an eye exam or something.
I'm going for a semi-chiseled look, so I'd like to have hard edges.
I listened on the eyes, the were trapezoidal, so I made them round. Couldn't do anything to the pupils without making it look like he's going to bust up crying/on-drugs or something.
I'm also not going for 100% realism, obviously no one has straight-up RED hair.
Don't get me wrong I appreciate your help, but I'd like to keep some aspects stylized.
Nose still looks strange, but I'd like it to remain large-ish.
Went around the lip's little, not quite sure about them.
As for the shading, all I can say is it's far better shading then I've done on human faces in the past.
